!" $%& '($$&) *+ $%& ,&$!$!*" +*) %(-&(. /*),0. *+ %*)(/!* )1 '*)(2&.3 4)1 !"# ("$*"!* /1 '*"/0,(3 !" '!"!.$&) 40(" ,*"/& &")!2&3 5&"1 +(-!(" /1 6&) !"# /*21 5(2!2&* 7!"$("()1 51)1 "891 :;<;: =>? :;;<@3 (ABCD E:3 ;FGH3 &" -("/ I/8>JKAJC8>3 4B3 41L +(/$.M •
•
•
•
•
•
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cting on these allegations, the Court ordered the City Fiscal to reinvestigate and assigned him to be the Court’s commissioner tasked to accept evidences of the alleged Constitutional violations.
E" @&.'&75&* 042 13402 '>& C('6 ;(+(+ *&.)*' )" '>& *&("A&+'(G!'()" !88(*7("G '>& &P(+'&"<& )8 ! #$%&' ! #$%&' )'*%+ &*+
ISSUE:
WON the petitioners were legally arrested HELD: •
•
•
•
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
N%&)&+*)&2 !+ !8)*&+'!' '>& .&'('()"+ +>)B/# 5&2 !+ '>&6 !*& >&*&562 O!.'!..&O2 V('> <)+'+ !G!("+' '>& .&'('()"&*+?
