Cases in Negotiable Instruments Law

PRELIMINARY CONSIDERATIONS d !""#$%&'$()*+), -. ! " # $ %& "%&'(%& " )*)* ")+ ,)" " ) * * " " ) " " * ) * - .* ) / / ) %& ) + - .*" . ) ) '0 &" 0"+ ,) "(".*%& ) ") " *1 2 " " .* +1 )) & + 3 * .* " 0 +1 0 4 ) -" +)0 5*+ " * 6 ) )" + 267++%/&&8 4 & + 0" + '9) &" " : " 0" ) .* ' 0 &" .*1 %&")" + (;< '0 & = 1 > - + 2 6 " " " + .5 /. ? 0 2 " )?0 ": - ?0 " " " ) @ ) 0 2" )=

) c Ê Ê

0 #*)11&'$(2)**$, !"""##"$%&'!

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Ê Ê

"

: @ 0*"!1*"" : 0 " ) ""*" 1* *""*) )* : -@ $ - 3 - Ê ( 4562&-7)1&)**)&)*# )8*9 ) :&")" ##1 ;4&1+'1' & ;<& )+$'"%& 67"8&"$$1 * 4 0;52!62&#'## + 74&")8 +'19 ; -&&;")&"$$'9 , / & )8)+%8&)8367"$$% 45620 11188&)1-72)**), -.-.*- +7.*8* )30)! ")"+" " ! +" + 3 + 6 4 ' " 3$ 30))/ ) "'

"/'- 2* 3 ( & 3$ ) ) " 3$ ) 4 4 &" ' " 3 + + 30)0) % *+"- *" . - *"3+ +)* 0 " 3$ !" )">@>)31 >) "> .* 3 0) - 4 ' " ""/4 ' " /"" & 4 ' " " - &" 6 " 3 0) 3$ * " ) "&'" - &4 ' 4 ' "*30)/ . - 4 ' " 30) ) "* - :* 3 0) A - + " : ) 3 0)" " )")* %9) &" " *=) 30)0 +! +=* ) 0) % "' %" @ "///')30) " 3 0) = * 3 0) 1 @ "= *0 +! +1@ " " " * ) .5 /. + 1 >(> )" " " " 2 0 9 Ô Ê Ê

6 ! ")> E786 * =78 = 78 " @ = 78 = 785 " >0/75 8)> F 78 = 78 ) . > -2 * > > )(- @ 0 / 9 6 ! * "30) > "> 0 && 9 6 ! - ( - 3+ * 6 * * E > ; * ".*G- +"+.> :=> ")" ##1 ;)$&)**" -. ) ""* " 0 . 7+-,8)+ $ * + $)+-,: C )"0 "--"0 ." -)@ $) !" *1 "+-, + $*@ $, -," "" *> > $*("(> ) > 6 ""+:786" *10 )+-,+ $ ) > :"6> + $)+-, ("*:1 ) +-,2 '" / -+ $ * " /"( C )"" *) "" &< "@ 1 " 1" 78 : ( =7"8 =7/8)++ . Ê Ê

857+-,8 H 86 H 85 )+-,H /. -+-, 09/" * 9 6 ! " ")$E 786 * = 78 = 78 "@ = 78 = 785 " - ( "" 6 "" 5

") )@" - " ) @" ) 5 1+-, ?96 ! " "" " 6" )" +-, ) ") ")+-, ) C" ) + $7 ) )) 8 ) " ) "" ")(" ) ;40 !"%)8&"% 67)*%$, -.D "-*! 0 "&9) %&"* + .*+ %"">>C)!C C@ 9) %&"@ "* !C C *" " -*!// -*! )+ 26-+ ) .5 /. ? 0 78 9 6 ! " * >> * "* 1 * 5*I"J II " - * *" > "* 1)"; "F"78 1 "78* " 78 " - * " " F* F. .* ; *" = * 5 * " " "*" ")" + " * * ) Ê Ê

6 * " *"I * ) J * * "*)C " " )" * 6

F 1 *

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º Ê Ê

) =( ) C"+ " ">:)> A.:) *) :) " : :) ) =") " .*:)A."+ : K + >78> * *" + :)5 "+(* ; - )#118#&");"$$', -. 0 . ) + ) 2 + ! 0$" ! A ,) +" A , . - ) A @ 2"6-@ A) 2-)) " 2- " - ")5)") " " " !0$" " " ! A G ,)+ ) :6" )" &2 " @ )" ;78 %%"& ' @ 6 2(*"+ 0 @ 2" NO " :) 2, " ) 0$ ! ) " ) ! :" 0$!* - "0$!) (") : @ " (@" " " - " ) - : " ( - A-+ : - P *- " + " * *- A) +- "" ) " ) .5 2" /.- + 0 ) 2- @ 2" " * ) 2 - ) " ) + . " 0 Ê Ê

@ ." " 0'96 ! >5 " E785 16 1 " : )> 2 " ) 2" @ - ) ( " ) * ) C)@ " ? (722!!0& ? /3 ?&2 :(;& 06&&*$&& @& 3/ &3 & & & @ A & 3 A & ( &/

A &- & & @ & & 3 @&A (/3 2+-0E ,!6 ! 9B " NO0 ) " "! 9B NO =- ! 9B NO" ! 9B NPO-A .9D+*.*

**" NO?0*( = ,$ 9 =! 9B ("0-!++!93"!!9++!930-!6-!306* B700;744& E -() )*" "* " * : ) " I++ ?9-+! 0,=J - P I J( ) -+ P :* 600?E6 P )( P"* " );*" 5* " " 2) "8 )=8) (=/8( I"JI JI"JI "J I"JI"JI "JI"JI ")J 5) "" " * 5)(+*9%'" )" " Q ") " 20&96 ! )E 0& == R2;706 00720C =>=78,) )") )=78, =78.=78, * Ê Ê

C )")+*9%' ) I,JI/"J)" )""@7&8" *6" )" 2"P)")* "

( ) & *

Ê AE 7D&""" #889 2B-;)#* ##1 3?/;&"#% '+#9 3640 < 6 &")* +'8 =>-; 674 &&)"$ 18#

3?; ))))*$&"+()**%, -. A C 0 +2 .) 9 " 4" A - + + + 4 " "0-)@ "" @ - "+ C )" 4 @ %2 )!,S+ 2 + "4" -9,S "" )@ *"" " 4" 0 @ + - " @ " , S%9) "4" *)0"7878"A / A + % 9) 0 , S @ % 9) " 4 / , S ) " "" ) "4" )C " " : / , S %9) 6*"4" ,S,4 = ) ",S * : = , S ) " ) " : ) : = , S * ) ) " 0 & 9 6 ! 5 " ) , S1 / ,S .5** $) ) /.34 +2" "4" C)*,4 ,S+2 +?0&96 ! ") ) ) ) " ) * $6 * ) " 4" - ) ë Ê Ê

C">*) ) ? * ) " )*" )= 3)> " * : - ) - + + C )0,> )0 $ ) :" >- @ : * " 4" ,S 3640 < 6 1%#)*&* )**', -.6@,).*A$7,.A805"@ )",.A ""% 4 / /< 0 5 " ) "/"% 9) /" 0 5 * ,.A + .*+") /% /%"

"/% / " "-* 1 ) - * ),.A $)2 "*!DC " * ,.A1 7 8 6 +". *"++" .* + ?" . . * . .*" 0 - " +" " .** +" * ,.A 4 &" ,.A 0 5 ; ! D C " + ?" 0 - " 6 + .* " ! 78 - "/"% @ 05 4 /=78 - * @ 0 5" ,.A" + .* +" @ ! D C " 0 5" , - , - + " ,.A" ! ! "A) + .5,.A" " " ) /.-* " *+ )$ * *) "" 1 * *C )")" *)) " *" ) 4 ) ) " ) ) @ 0 & 9 6 ! " ) *" ) >) ) ) )>- " ) ,) " )" 5 ) " )" ) ) C" 78 +.**" /% /%/% / " )",.A5 ) *,.A" " *" 0 5 .* 0,.A))* ") 7 *8 - " ) * ) : ,.A 6 * ) ) ,.A " ) 6 " 0 5" " ) (" c Ê Ê

=>-;56 674 !'*8#)&"1-72)*1', -. & ,4)S @ )90*0+"!" " / " & " <6 )(" < " 0* +" 9 0* 0 +" !" " ) 2 G 6)+ E>.2G6)+ 9 ,= ,= = ) 0. D - A0 + 7.+ ! ,8 .E A , !2 39 96!! "3>-*",S " / & " *,S "0* 0*"&9) & + 2 6 6" . 6 0* (,S " ), ",S ""% ' "",S 0"A /A + 1 : " 0 '/" 0* " / / & = ) < " / = 9 " 0 0* > > " = " *" = 0& 96 ! E78 =78 = 78 = 78 * ) ) .50* : /. 6 1 > > 0 ) ) 0 & 96 ! C )" 0* > >) )"">A > 0*" > >* " " , S " 0*- """" 0*1 ) "" )- 0* " 2 " (" C + " ) *

cc Ê Ê

C !,A0

c 36&$' %*89 ^ A;& )'1$+#&;)%&"$$'9 &)#% #*+ 36 !)%)"8&'$67)*8), -. 0 /")"+3 * " 3$ 2:"* 33$3 $ " +" * 3" 3$ " 3$ " 3" 3$ ) ) * 3$ 3)* ) 1 " * * 3$ 3 3$ A 3$ * * 3 3$3"3 *3$@ * 3$ * ) "3 >0 >* *53$)*3 )") +"@ $ S A , G + @ $ 3$"*"%%' @)3$ * - * ) , 3, +2 "3$3$ , )* , ) ) * & , 3 - + 2 6 " C + S $" " 33$, &" 0 / " 3" ),.5, / ),.9 0 "96 ! " > * E78- =78- ) " ) " =78-*) =78- > , * )3$" (( 3 +" * @ 3$,SA =* " * )F( ) , *3$" 1 6 1 3$ 1 * C) " , 3$" " * c^ Ê Ê

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cÔ Ê Ê

0 "),) ? K" ) ?)#% #*+ 2+-0E43 .*+P+*" P* *-***- @!C** "!* 53 *" 1 3 ) C@ ) -*)* 2 " " C !" )5* *" ! ! *3)) ) - *P*)3 C!,E P* P** * ? "*! *C 6)*- P* * 6P* * " *"* ) * "* * A- Êd ( ;!(& )%&)*1*9 ) 2 &)* *"#9 !&")$ '%"9 & ;!;6&'#1 '%$9 * < &"*67"$$89 + ;4&$% 67"$$+9 - (B2& )81"+#&;"$&"$$1 ;!(0 1$%**&)% 67)*1*, -.6 "A00"4 )()"6(*= B. / "." " 4 + " +* /

/ - A .*" % 4 " % "+(40* )"6" " B." C )" " ) )" . )

0*0*-* +(4 ) +(4 ) 3)0)6 0730608." " cÊ Ê

) 3060 " * C )" ) @" * % " . - A .* * /' " % "" +(4 - * .05+(4* 20).*"." * * *C"+(4 ) . 7.8 # $ +21 .0-)+2"!" .0).7++#(%&'8+ 26A$"# $+ " ).0"+ 2 !" 0 1 * ++ & % " +(4" +(4 ) 1 * * % "C"01* % " +*+ % 6"1*)) . ) 0 * " " > ) &+)+ "> : 01 +(41 0 '" ) : ))" ) +(4 ),.50"" 96 ! / ),. 0 7! 8 9 6 ! ) > *" " " " ) ) " 0 ) " " * " * > + " " 78 "*" """78)) "7/8 . ") )) @ 2 ")) 9)" ) " ) " - "" 2 &)* *"# - . 0"0)S)*S )00)(*S -"*0S + "0) 0P - 0)1 )- 0 )+ C!,E 0 ) S" : )) @ - 0S P* 0 "S0)0:)2" S"S 1* 00)" S c Ê Ê

"*F F "( *" " : - ) - E :)* :)* (* ) C) : ) 6 ) : 0" )) S )- "00)

? ?")$ '%)

2+-0E )))* )) C * ) @* * * * *- ")@C * - ., ) -A-++

C!,EA P " - -) )* *- * ) ) ) ) ) )()) - ) * P ) -* " )* P && 3E3 & 2+-0E " ".*7.*+ * ? ).*8 !- 78 @ (*"), " 0/" 0 " &"!- ")".* " / "&/ &4 /" - + +(C)E *" ) =** )) @ =*" cº Ê Ê

) != * " "(= 6A" .* .*++$.*((-- )) 78 * * "*" +0 96 ! 796!8"* =* - !)" E -@ *?*1-#" @ " ' -"4 /" " ( *-" " " , *: )) 2 " ,C0%"A A : ) " )"0 ,"- " *1" (!" @ : - *-?1 (" % ! ( "-)) " - A )$- " " . " %/" %/ @ * /-"- +3A0 // 9/%%+ " 4 " &" : *"* - *1>)> > >6" * * >> 6 "+ *>> 0 96!6 @ ,-- ")$- >> : -+ )*"" )$- @ ,-- * 5*>>"+ - +0 96!"*1 * "*")"(* :)"-) ) 2 "+ *@- : (* )* " c0 Ê Ê

" ! ) @ 9"+ *)") 1 ; 600?E "* )$- H .)*".* " !- " )$- 6" ("A* " *"

'

)$- -)$- " ) 3)++ " - "+ "" 1 0" " ) + " ))R> (*>* "!-" /. ( )$- "* ) =" >> 96! 9"0 96!> *" """ )) " >@" ")$E78 "*" ""=78 )) =7/8

=) & ; - ) ) "* "* & " * " & R " &/ = ): )&% )" 1..!"#./ 0"1=!1/211/ & ) *" ) )&& + " " 6) ) 3$%4541%63 0 96!> ) ) ) > "> ) >0" )) "*) / 6 ) ) " )) ""* " ") % ? " " " "" """

) A" 5 * "*!" *" *& c Ê Ê

- " : >@>)*( 2 "#./ !1 ) "))@ " @ ' ) "( 6Ê17411" + E @@@- 6 1 " """ - " ) "" ) = $ " C ")" " )" " @ " - 1 " -" )" ) 7A+!"/(/%8 9>)>! ) )) "@ )78 ) *2 " !*= @ ) ) - ! * ) -)

(*" ) ")@ 6 " "+ ) + " @ 0 " ") 6 ) + ) A % A + 0) " @") )) ) )

/ - " ",,&"A + +(3A+S 9 /%/-- 3-3 3*

cë Ê Ê

3 - Ê ( &(2""&)**$9 ) 4&"%8 #*)9 4&$% 67"$$89 & 4&(2')&)**89 * (!&88 "*9 + 7 7&(2')&)*+%9 4F6& )#&)*119 , 6B&-72*&)**'9 8 6640&'%$ ##89 (9 &)#' "$9 (( &'*' 1*9 () 6;- 4&)%;"$$#9 ( 747<&$8367"$$89 (& 406 ;7& )%$""1&(2"$&"$$*9 (* 74-&#367"$$*

4&"%8 #*) - . ,+0 *)* " 9.- * + .+ -* C )")"9. * 0 + - +*.+ .+ 9., " .+ ( / 3. 6 $ $ 6 " 096! 6" * F 09. -+*) @)" ") )* . -*P -) *- "*P " -"*"9. *.+ 6

^ Ê Ê

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c Ê Ê

1 )"* ) *-** " 6**-*" C" * ) * * C )" * )6 *") )")C"9." *" ) - * C )")- " *9. 6 *(9. ()- " - *(9. *(.* *.*" " " 2 " 6 9. .* " ) )" -+ )- "" * - ) - 2 * ")))" 5 @ * 7 ' 4 '8" * 1 2 '"- 1 * 6"* $4 " - * * ) - 1 - )) 1 C" ) - * $ 72 8" )* * 1") /"/ 9. <6")-) </"/9. - *" .*" 9. < /"/ 6 * 2 " ) " ",+.* 1

74 7 !#$+*8&')(2)*+%, -. '2 &/" -".*+* & 4 &/ "%&A .*"-* . - A .* ) ) *">!$> %4 A .* . - "%&-) . - "A .*) "%&" 0A .* ++ 4 &&" ) * ")" 0 A .* = ") " -( , $ " " % 0 && 2 ( 4 - &'" + + : A .* =, $", $-2: ++ " *+ 26" . )" " A .* "%&" &4 &&"

" =) ) ), $ " , $ (- ),. 5 @ ) * ^^ Ê Ê

/ ),.6.)2"/ 6 &'"/95 " *)" $ ) " )-* !$" "AA!$"" " *AA!$, $"", $ * " )" 6B0 *""##*-72)**', - . 3 0 * * *-* **36 *3"3 1) * 01)) ** , " @ )6 )* "1) *-3 * *-* * / 3. 2 ) )) 0 P " ) - * ))* 6* P3 ) C* *" )* $3) )-* " " * * *@ * * **)) * ) )*"1 @ (*1@ ) **P 6& 4;&& 2E "" , 6).+;)C *".*+ " " "D " ** **6 )* . 0 " 4 /" " )7'8* *" "&/%/%* " )2A$)" )@ ",A$" ^Ô Ê Ê

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Ê Ê

- * " * ) - ) ) * 6" * ") " *5CA2 A" 3A9-, - ,+ 9) &ASA0,",A-+ ". " %A690--,+0 A,A, 747<&$8367"$$8 2+-0E å

å å

å å

å å

9)" %EA,+$7+$8 *+*>+0C> 9)%" % " * $" * 5.* * @" ) "** +C +7+C+8A 9)&" %E+$P) * ** +$ * D ) -E+$* * 3 C)*D D 9)% 9)% 3 +$*( " 4 /" E- ( D +A-+E2)+$

600?E5;9+$)* C!,EK0+ å å

6"* " " %9) %%9) % 0% =R5 ")"@ " $" . "

å

å

å å

+$ $9 @ 3 - @ ) ) * " 3 0 " )"*) ) V >969-K> * V * " /* V >969-K>* > 9 -C ?09,0 0 9!K> 5 **")*" P -5.1"" *+$ ^

Ê Ê

74-&#367"$$* 2+-0E !. 7.8 .2 + 7.28 / " " . 2 - .P " 6 * I. 2 + ! .J %" " +.*+7+.*8-* I2,P J 5 ( . 2" . * * + 7*8" .* - + 7*8. * 6".P " " . 2 ) 6 P * .".P * .2 ) ** )" A-+ 7A-+8* * .""1"* ./'*A-+"6 ) .2 ." 6 * "6 *. 2. - "* .* " (.2) $ " *.:).2 0% 501

".":$""!74Ê6##1" - " I $J * I U. 2 NO) :*)U.2 "J) P " 600?E -0% 501 ".":$)E5 "6 7 8 . *" " .P(.2 - ) )

$: +"" " *" ." * " " .2 $" * @ * * ? " . 2 6.2611) *H ^º Ê Ê

P -)96 ! : *( )): P611) * - "*"*" * *

*" - * *" * * * I ; * J" "* "" 5 *P " *7+.*8 )) :* "*" * * " * ) ( * - -A Ê ) - 26&&)88 "%89 " ;&-72"&"$$)9 ' 4 &-72)"&"$$)9 # - 2&7%&)*119 % 6/&")+ '"9 8 4;(&##+++9 + 2 -&"$$ 8'+9 1 &(0& )#"8#)&)+(2"$$89 * 4;& B&))(2"$$8 N3A9' '2 "O &Ñ - -/ / & Ñ 2+-0E 5 !67!68" !6 ") - !6"!6 -" " )" " * ( C"P *!6 6, "5 @7&8*" ",/" !6-* (*C )" "!6 * 6"*P % "'''!6 ) '

^0 Ê Ê

. *") !6* /C )"C"4 " &"!6* A$+.*+7A+.+8-* I J- * )A+.+ 4 " &" * )7 8* 9)&" '" 7/8 ).. 6* " "/"/' "&"% ?"5 - /" " ! 053?6!-K S0..- P 600?E $ .. - 78 )..E78* * ) * * =78) * * *) * * 7 8 " ) "*J @ * ) C I ((J.* - "A-++) * " !* " " .. * ".. '".#.6@ - "*P* * )*4 " &" ',/" " * * 0.. C @** ) ( 0..)E 4!67$1!56"666!"-*" * *" 7 8 *"#.6)* * "* * )7 8*) * I* J* * *)* 0)) " #.6 * *I * 7 8 *J- " ) )7 8*"* * ** * ^ Ê Ê

+P" ) * * A" #.6 * 78 *"78 * ** * -* 7 8#.6 * * 69 ?0& 96 ! "I* @ J. *" *@7&8")* ' *C* * " * ) ) ")* *? "!6 ** " * )7 8* -"" )* * *P" P) ). +*! C )" !."4Ê1 ())999" *9)" " * 4=B40> )#)*81&)"-72"$$) -. 0 2 0 3 ! $ 3 6 + .* 7 ? .* 8 F 9 0 & %,A" 6 "0 @ ) ) -0 + ".* ' ) 7+) + & ( 8 >0 5 A)> -+ +".% ",23 ) ) * * , -" .*1 S %" " %""C )" ( " *1 " ,3 ** )0 !;+++C"4 A)- " ", 3 )1* " 4,63 ,3 : .*" )": * " ) * )" 3 ) - + # $ +" . // - -+ * A-+ ".' # $ +" - + ) 6 " A-+ : ) - * : * = " = " @ " " 1 " 6 " -+ .//- )+ " '2 " ") ,A-+# $+". '"+)+#( '(/'&"= *-*) 0 + 7 0.6 ",3 )1* "0* )A)")*C )", 3 :" @ ^ë Ê Ê

*0 ",-") *"%0 ",3 *>> " : ** ,3 5) ) * )*"* 8 .5* P* /.9 * 6 ) "" ? " 5 " 6@" * " >"> " " - @ -

* 6"* ) 7(;8 *2 * * - " ) * 78 " C"*)) @ 1*1* *1 * 6 1 * 1 * * *1 *6"@ * *" ) 6*1 * **-** - 6 " * ) ) " @ 2 " " 6 " * *6"3 )" * 1* ( ," 6"* ") (C" ** ) :-+ *.* 6/&")+ '" -.9. +$S" : "( .*+* ""/ ' "/ 0 ' -"*06)C 6706C68 : " *-*" )" )+ " " *? " * , ' "06C6 * " ) ) & /"06C6 )) * 1@6 " * : )* * 0 -( + +$ S" * & " + -(+"06C6 /"106C6)+ " 9, 96 ! )06C6) * ) ) 06C6 ) Ô Ê Ê

),. 5 ( * / ),.0 96 ! - ) > E 78 . 5 ( *" " =78. " =78.=78. = 78 5 > ) " ?!6+)*7878 . " 78 " " >> - 0 ?!6+ * ( *" * " 78@0 "" /+)+ @ " 0 C""+$S" ?!6+1 : +" ?!6+ @ *0 @ * ",.5 06C6 )9, ?!6+ / ",.- =@ 0%96 ! 0%75) 8)>9 ) E 78 5 = 78 5 )=785 =785 @ =785 >6" ?!6+10 ) 0)* : 0 * " )@* 6 " *" " ) 9," * ") " " *" " @ 6 " 9 6 ! "- " $9 - ** - ) * + " * ) * : C" " "06C6" *06C6 @ ?!6+ * *"9, - &( &(0& )#"8#)&)+(2"$$8 2+-0E %" "NO")4+$ " 0) *"NO "N+$ONO )+$".*6N7.68O+*9&/

" %" " "" +$P ' ) " # $ + 5 %" " N+$O * NONO * 0 ))7'85 "N+$O **- .* 6 , " " N+$O * -" N+$O NO * N+$O NO 0" N+$O ) Ôc Ê Ê

NO * NO * * "N+$O@ 4 " + # $ + ) NO N)O N. O NO )"N)ON.O NO'" -* )N+$O 0&" N+$O@ )!* -" " P 600?E5 9* ( ) C!,E -+ () 9 * *" * * @-"* @ - "+$P* *7 8 * * -) *C" : @ *" C" @ @* +$ *" + # $ + @ () ) - + #. 6 ) . * +$ 0&" " ) @ "@ * ) )" *C)* * ) 4;& B&))(2"$$8 2+-0E 4 &" ".*"7!!6,8 @.9., (( ?0 T" 33 0 + 73308 - " 9 ..&% % )PS)-0 537?)A8 + V'/;0 - @ +* 2.* !" C* 5 " !!6, 330 ) "%'% * 4 " " 9 3 6 ! 78 @ ) ! 3 ")@ 0 " ! ! S 9 3 @ + 3 ;+)0 7 ")8" !!6,@3305!!6,@+*" 330)@) + " !!6, ! 3 0 @ ) !!6, C )" " !!6, A330"@"+*2.*!7 *8" !!6,")@ .!!6, :@ Ô^ Ê Ê

" 93 @ !3 "" :@ NO !* " 9 3 ! ! S @ + 3 ;+)0 " ): ) " "")";!!6, 330N O - ) "")";NO- P 600?E59",S !3 + 3 ; ) 0 " @" C!,E 0 96 ! "" - ( ; " ))-" N%O - ; ? ) " N O "@ ) " @ PN&OC N'O-"@:) 33 0 ) ") ) !3 3 / - Ê ) B067/ &367)*&)*1$9 " 240BA4&8'+))9 ' ;&"'$ 8#19 # 4;&()+&)**"9 % 6/&)+% '))9 8 ?&"1# 8#'9 + ?& )#1"))&"%(2"$$89 1 G7;&)% 67"$$89 * 24562 & )+$*1#5)+$*1+&(2'$&"$$*9 )$ <(A&"$7"$)$ ;&"'$ 8#1 2E.+G+2"67.++268")) " "D- 373D8")" '6 " .++26" / 4 ' * ' "A 1 )

, '".++26 " )" 1 ) .++26 * """0 ' , "3D 06)C "6706C68 4 '" *-+.-

& &%""/ ' " .++26"3D06C6 , &" '" 06C6 * -+.- & &' G & &" "" 0 G /" ' )" .++26) 3 D6 3D ).++261".++26 / ' " ÔÔ Ê Ê

* 3 D" * -+.-

& 0 " *-+.-& &'G& &0%G" ' ")" 3D1 ))06C6.++26)"

*".++26- 06C6)) 6 ( D- 3 " " " - + .++26) 6 E506C6""*" " ".++26 CE - 96 ! " > * E78- =78 - ) " ) " =78-*) =78- >0 96! ) C )" )" ) " + * )) 1* 2" " 0 78 96 ! " * C".++26106C63D. " " * 3 D .++26 - "06C6 + ".++26 * 79E6" )"06C6 )*-) : ( C" 06C6 "3D8 6/&)+% ')) r cë

cë

Ô

^^ cë ^ëë-

-0-^ëc

cc Ô

^c-0

Ô cë-

^^ë- c^ ^- cëc ^ëë-

-^Ô

^ ^

ë

ÔÊ Ê

cc^º Ô cëºc

^ -c ! ?& )#1"))&"%(2"$$8 G7;&)% 67"$$8 <(A&"$7"$)$

Ô Ê Ê

Cases in Negotiable Instruments Law

Recommend Documents