TRIBUNAL FEDERAL DE JUSTICIA FISCAL Y ADMINISTRATIVA

c  c c 
c  cc 

c c

ë

   
         

c
c c c c c c  c c c c c !c !!!" !#c !!c c $c !!%c $c c c &!#c !c c !'()cc!c*ccc+cc
c&!ccc%!c,-ccc!)c.!%cc!c !c!c /!#cccccc0c à
   
  
c c
c c  c  c c   c    c c c       c cc  ccc c  c

 cc ccc c c   c  c  c c c   cc c   c c cc

 c   c   c  c cc c  c c  c c   cc  c  cc  c    c

ë     
     
            +c +c +c

c c $!1c c c'!#c*c$!2ccc2cc c $(1c cc cc3!!cc)+c

ë
      
     
            +c cc +cccccccccc +cccccccc +cc +cccccccccc +cccccccc +cc +cc 5+cc 5+ccc

c

'!cc c $!1c '!cc c'!1c '!c $!cc c'!1c

!c3cc!1c

!c4!cc!ccc !1c

!cc!cc c $!1c

!cc!cc c'!1c !1c 6&c !1c !!c!1c

c

5+cc 5+cc c 5+cc

!c
8!#c6$ !c!c/1c !cc!cc !c!c c cc #c !c2c*c!cc2cc!c!cc$!c9cc '!c!cc
cccc$ !ccc $$!c!(!+c

c

ë
    

       
     
  

       c

c c

c

7c

ë
       
     
           

c
c cc c cc c!!2cc!c4!c*cc $! c!cc!!c& #c!c !cc$!!c *cccc!)0c c +c cc c $!c !c &c &c c !'!c &c )!!#cc*cccc/ccc!')c&#cc &4ccc%*c!ccccc$cc*)1c +c cc *c 'c c  !)c c c '!c c !c '!c $!c c )'!c ccc )#cc$!c$!cc !c!c c !)c$!cc!&!c!ccc&1c +cc c *c $!'c c $!c &)c c c !c  c &1c +cc c *c c c' !c c c &c !c c *c c &c c&!c!1c +cc c*c'c!c(cc$!cc2c$!c!c *c !c c c c & !c c !c !c c 48!#c c c (c 8c c c c c !c !c c c &c !c :!:c !c '!c c c )c c .!c c !c c !c &#c %c !!c c *c (c !'!c c '!c c c c $!#c c !c !c c c *c !!'c :c $!+c !c$c&cccc!c&c*cc!$!c c !c ;!c c 9!c c  !c *c !c !!!c $!c c !c $ #c *c )c c !c !c '!c $!c c *c !'cc!)c$'c!c*cc)ccc c cc*cc&c!!c$!cc %ccc&c!c!cc #c ';c c !1c !c !c c c !c c 4*%#c '<ccc'!c!c$!cc !c#cccc
c c c c c c  c )!c 2c &!c c !c c c )c c c %c c c $)c $c*cc!c$!$!cc!$!#c!cccc$cc $)1c +cc c*cccccc$!c #cc!c'!cc!c &c !c c !c c 'c c  !c !c c !c
4!cc !1c +c cc *c c c c c  c !c $)c c $!c c !!c c !c $;#c *!#c !cc !c!c$!cc $ccc cc)c.;c 1c +cc c*c'cc()c!c*#c$!cc!!#c!c&'cc c c c *c $!'c c !')c c c !c 9!c c $4!c $'!c !c ! !c c c )#c c !c 8!c c c c c c $!c .!c c !c !c c c c  c &c *c !'c c 8'c $c c $!c$!cc !1c

c

-c

5+cc 5+cc 5+cc

5+cc 5+cc

5+cc

5+cc 5+cc

c *c *c c $'!c c '%c c & !c c c )#c c !c #c!c !c!c!c$!#c%c!!cccc $1c c *c c c c 9c c c %!c >=c c c c c !!c /!1c c c $!c c !c  c *c $!'c &c c c $!!c  !#c c c c !c  c c /$#c c !c 8!c c c c c c .!!c  !1c c *c c !c !c  !c c !c c c !!c*ccccc2c&!ccc%!1c c*cc&ccc!c!c!c!c$c cc !c )c !c c c !#c !c $!c 8/!#c !c !c cc:'c c!!c!$!cc$')c*c!cc:c $!ccc& !c'!cc!c&!c!c!c!1c c *c c !&'c $!c ' c &c c c c 9c c c%!#c$!cc!cc$(!c*c9cc)'!c cc c )#c c c c c .!!c  !c !c c $!!c $c !#c c c &!#c c c $(!c c c #c %c !!c c *c 'c c /$)c c c !c c :c !&'!c c !)c $! c &#c !c 8c c c $ c$!ccc*c4cc:c+c !c 2c $c !c $!c c c $2&!c !c c !!c *!c !c c !c*c c $c &c c :!c c c !#c !!!c cc'!c!c!)cc!c 1c c !c c 2c !!c c $!c c !%c $!c cc )#cc8!ccccc ()cc)cc ccc )#cc c9ccc2cc!!c!$cc
+c.c !c &!c c $c $2&!c c c %!#c c !!c c !2c & c !c !c c !c  !c !c !cc$!)cc8cc!$ +c

c
c!!2#c2cc!c4!c*cc$! c!c!c !c !#c!cc!cc2c'#c !c c !c '!#c !c c !$ !c !c !c c !c !c!! c!c! !ccc$c!cc$)+c

c
c cc c cc c!!2cc!c 4!c *c $! c c !c $c *c c c c !!c  c & !c c c $#c $c *c :c !!c c c c c 9c c c &!c !c!!ccc!$+c

c

c
c cc c cc c!!2cc!c4!c*cc $! c !c c !!c & c $!c c *c c $!'c !c  c c !c  !c $;!c c 8!c c c c c c $!c cc!c  !c.;!#c%c!!c!cc*c c!c!c !c$ !cc:!c!!+c c

c

=c

ë
        
     
            !cc:)!cc!c !cc8/!#cc!cccc$c c '!c c !c !!!c  !c c 7?c c !c c @?-#c c c &c &c$!cc')c&ccc8$!c"c$cc&'cc!4!cc

!"#cc*ccc'c!!!ccc!c4%c/#c$!c!c *cc$!!c$!c&cc!!c$!cc $c!cc cc c)#cc!c !!cc$$!cc )cc$!c cccc!%ccc )cc Acc&!cc >7,#c)cc4!c c !$!)c *c c c c !c ('!c c !#c !c c !c c %c'cc!!'!ccc'%cc8c&cc'!cc4)#c c'!#cc$!!c*!c cc&c$2#c2!c c!'cc)c!cc$)ccccc c cc7,cc'!!c c >-B#c 2!c c
c c c c )c c >-,#c c c c '!c $!c ?c '!c *c $!%c c c .!c !c c  8c c !c #c c*cc&!c$!cc'!cc+cc!$c*cc ')cc'!ccccc&+c c9!c$8cc:c!cc '!cccc c #c&c!'c$!c c )'!c c c c )c c -Ac c c c >-@#c ! !c 'c !$c$cc
#c$!8!c cccc!!#c :c *#c c c &!c c %!c A=c c c c 'c c Bc c cc >=Bcc >cc4!cc >B,#c%c!!cc)#cc7>cc4!cc >@,#cc c&)c555"Ccc%!c,-ccc&)c"cc%!c A=#c8c;c*(2c c2c$!cc!+c :!c)'!c #ccc&c c&!c!#c !c 'c:c c - c c (!c c >B,#c !c &c !'!c$!c c $!!c c 7=c c c c 9!c!#c!c*c%cc!!cccc&!)cc 6'()c c !c !c c c !c !c c !!c c *c 2c  )c $c !'c !c c 8c ' #c c 'c c c 'c /#c 2!c 2c c !c  c c c !'()c c
#c*cc!'!cccc6'2cc!c*c&c$cc c!c6&ccc )cc >cc!cc >B,#c2!cc )c '!#c '!c c c c *c c /%#c 2c c .c *c !c '%c #c !c c %c c !c  c c c !$c *c %c '#c ! !c c )'!c c !$!c c $!!#c &!2!c :c c 6'2c c >,@#c $ 8!c c '!()c c
#c 2!c Bc c '!c c c c '!c c c c

$!#c !c c $ 8c c !c c  )#c !c c *c c !!'c c c c

$!c&c$c cccc$!cc c'!+c

c)'!c ccc )cc-Acccc >@ #ccccc '!c :c c Dc c !c c >@-#c ! )c 2c c !c $!c c !c !c 8!+c .!!c c c c c !!c c $!!c  c c c *4#c $c !'c c !c $!c c c c #c

c

?c

cc&!cc >@@cc)'!c ccccc6'2cc
#c!cc !4!c c $!! c c $&)c  #c c $)c c !$c *c :cc!c!!'ccc$c*cc c $!c cc!!c cc c'!cc 8cc!cc )+c

c !c 9!c 'c $c  c $!!c *c !!'c !$c c
#c $c !!c c 4!c c c !!c %c $!c c !c c  !)c $ !c !c c c c c !!c /!c !!c c c c c .!!c !c#c$c >>Bccc '!cc cc6'2cc
c c c c )#c ! !c c !c c c !$#c $!c !&!cc')ccc c $!cc c'!cc!#c%c!!c c&!cc!$)cc 8cc.!c!c !+c

c 

   
         

c c &c c 9!c 7AAAc !c c !'!c c c )c $c c &!c c c c $c c
#c !!c !0c c $c 'c c !c c !cccc6'2ccc!ccc)#c$!ccc
c c c c cc #c&4!c!c!cc!$c*cc 8cc !ccB?c9!cc/ccc:c!c'!#c%c!!cc*c!cc $!$!c!cc&!cc!!'c9!c!$c$c!!cc!c4!c *cc$! c!cc!!cc$!cc!c*c$!'c&c cc$!!c !#cccc!c cc/$cc!c 8!c c c c c c .!!c  !+c !c c c $!$!!c&cc.!c$ccc'!ccc;!cccc c #c%c!!cc&!cc'c4$cc! c!!cc c!!ccc !c!ccc c'!#c&2!c2ccc

c $!#c $c c c 4)c !c c c c '!#c %c !!cc;!ccc#c$!c;!#cc!&)cc!$c!cccc '!#cc!c*c:!c2c!$c$c!!cc4!#c*cc !ccccccc!c+c c c c c c c c c c

c

Bc


c c 
c  c c

c c.6 c c c


6c c 36c c

ë
   
    
              
    !
  c c c c  c c c !c c '!c c $2c $!c c
c c c c c  c c .!c c c !#c !c 4)c c !!c c !!c c c !c c !$c c !'()c *c ccccc c cc cc !cc'!+c
cc&!ccc 
 "    # $   !
 1ccc%!c,#cccccc0c à  pc   cc c   c cccc c c c c ccc c ccc c  c! cc c 
cc "c  c " c c #c c   c c p  c c $   c %  c c &   c cc$   c c" ccc ccc c !  c c  c   c c c  c !c    c c c c c c    c  c   c c c   c c c &   c  c c  c   
c

ë  
 
          
    !
 

c
c c c c c  c c .!c c c

!c&!2cc.!c!cc +cc

c
c c c c c  c c .!c c c

!c 2c '!c $!c c c !c c c c c 2c c c

$!#c c '!c c .c c
c c !c c 6#c .c c

'cc'!ccc!cc!c'!ccc2c!2c!c c'!c$!#c8!c;!c$2cc!c$!$!ccc !cc*c&!c'!+c



c

,c

ë
  
 
          
    !
  +cc +cc +cc +cc

c !c3cc!1cc c!c !1cc

!cc!cc 1cc

!cc !ccccc;!c*c*cc '!c$cc!)c$!cc/$cc!c4!1cc +cc !1cc +cc 6&cc.1ccc +cc c2c$!c8!cc !c!c*cc c$ !ccc$$!cc'!cc
+cc

cc ë
       
    
           
    !
 

c
cc c cc cc.!c cc !#c2c !$c$c!!cc! cc!c4!0cc c +c cEcc c$!cc!! c*cccc)c!c c '#c $)#c $!c c &!c c !#c $!!c c !!c c (c  c !c &c *c c c !c #c $c c 6'!c .;!c(!cc)c&cc&c4%cc !c$1cc +cc Ecc$c!c!ccc c!c&#c*c !&'c ' c &c c c !c c !#c c !c $!ccc!c6'!c.;!c(!1cc +cc c #c!cc$!! !c$!cc!1cc +cc c!c*ccc$!c$!#c!4 ccc c !#c c !c $!c !c c c 6'!c .;!c (!1cc +cc Ec c $!'c c !c c c !!c & c c cc$!c c$cc!c !c $;!cc*cc&cc%!c Bccc!)c.!%cc

!ccc !!cc'!1cc +cc Ec c &c c c $)c c $!c c !!#c ! !cc!!c!cc(c cc*cc $c c !#c !c $!c c c 6'!c .;!c (!1c +cc Ecc$! ccc&c!cc!4!cc*cccc !&')ccc.! c cc*ccc!cc

!#c c $!c !c c c 6'!c .;!c (!#c !c c &'c 'c c $ c c c c $1cc

c

@c

+cc Ecccc!c8!ccc&)ccc$c%!cc *c c #c !#c 4c !c c c4c $!c $!c !c !c*c&4c!!c!c c!c&c cc)c&cc&c4%cc!c$1cc 5+cc Ec 'c c  !)c c c '!#c c !c '!c $!c !c )'!c c c !c !c c !c $!c c $c $!c c !c c $!c !c c  !)c $!c c !&!c!ccc&1cc 5+cc !c*cc$! cc!ccc!!cc$!cc !c  #c c !c $c c ! c c !cc
%!c.!ccc$c1cc 5+cc c *c c $! c c !c c c !!c &c c !c 2!c c c $c c ! c !c !c !c c ccc'!c$ !1ccc 5+cc Ecc9c!ccc'!+cc

ë
    

      
   
           
    !
  

 

c

>c

6 6

c 

c 
     
           c c 8/!#c c c cc!c!!!" !#c!!cc$c!!%c$cc c&!#c'!cccc!! c4%c*ccccc )c.;c cc!c$#cc'!#c!c&!c$cc .!c c c c )#c $!c $$c c 4 !c #c )c *c :c !c c c c 9!#c c c !!c !!!cc$$!cc )cc$!#c;ccc$cc*#ccc$2#c c
c:c!c!c$! !#c!c$c!!!ccc !c 4%!c /!#c !!c !'!c 'c c 'c c c  c c &#c !c c c c c !c
c #c $!c c %c c $!c !c c !c
c !'!c c !+c $c4c&cc ccc!c&c!c$c!!%#c :!#ccc&#cc !ccc!#c*c'cc!c !c c c 4#c $'!c c !c $$!c c 'c c 'c 4%#c c c$!#c!$#c$cc'#c$c!cc&!!c c !cc:!#cc!!cc$%cccc$(c!+c

c c
c !!!c  !c c /#c !c !!%c 4!cc$$#c*c$c4c!c$c4)cc$!#c c  8c c $!!c 2'c c !#c c c c c 'c c $!!c c  c !)'!c $c c !)c c !! c !c  c!!c! c

c 
   
              
       !
 % ccccc!!#ccc c$!cc %c 4!c !c !&!c 4%!c *c c 'c !c c $!c !!c !c !c c c !c  c c !c c '!#c *c $$c$ccc' !cc!c'!!+c c$&!c%cc'!!#c$c!$c$!cc#c!c c 8ccc!c0cc +c 7+c -+c =+c

ccc!c!c!)c*c!c'+c Eccc!ccc!'cc!cc$)c+c Ecccccc'!ccc:!cc&!+cc Ecc!'ccc!ccc$'cccccc!c !c!c!!c*cc!cccc4!ccc&!+c

c c

Ac



63 Fc c

&''((()
  ) )*'   '!+,-./' '!.//! 01)2 &''((()22 ) )*' &'')( 3  )'( 3 '
 4  44
  4  44      5
 4  44 4   )6)76 &''((() 
 ) )*'#7  '2'#/  )2 &''((()
 ) )*'#'8)!  &''((()
 ) )*'   ) &''((()
 ) )*'#'2  4  )2    c c

c

c