Banco Atlantico v. Auditor General and Santos v. Reyes - NegoLaw

c
 
    
  


   !" c#$ %&' (#'))(#')%&'*&(+(,,('-. (/0(0 $&-## ( '1%(%'0$(%&c# %+%(##&'#2  ++'1'0+'0 '0%&'.%&''-.  %&' '## ( %&' .2-0'%&',-'%)%&'#&'#2 %$(%& %0(1%&')#%%&%%&' 0$''.2& %'%#+''0%&'#&'#2 )#++'#%( &(  $ ,'-( '0%&')(0(1%&%c#&0 ,'#(+'+%(  $(%&%&''-,+'' )%&'.2  0%&%,,' '%-'%%%&' 0$''.2%&'#&'#2 $''0( &'00'%##',%#' ++'1'0+%&'10%&%%&'0$'& 0''0%&' %,,1'),-'% &( ,-,%'0c# %+%(#%#++'#% )-%&'*&(+(,,('-. )%&')0 '+' '0%c#.%%&' +%%'') '0 &( ''%+++'0%)(+(1)-'#+(-)%&' .2$(%&%&' 0(%''+    '"3
c# %+%(#$ &+0'(0'# ' 
  4 " Ô| ++)#0(%( '-'%'00'!'# 5
- %## .')'&+0'#.'# (0''0 &+0'(0'# ' &' . '#')(+'%#-,+$(%&)%&'#0(%(  '%)%& 0'%&(  '#%($(++-2''6 %(%+'%%&'( %-'%0')'#%('  Ô| &'#&'#2)!78888 88$ 0'-0%' 3&'/( c# %&','')%&( #&'#2'1%(%'0%&' -'.0', (%(1(%(&' ##%%%&' -'%(-'()-(1%&'.2($(%(1%&%(%.'% ,' '%'0)#++'#%(%(++%'0%'  Ô| c# %+%(#%&1&(% 1'%%'++'# &(' &+0&'.'' ,%10%&%%&''$  -'%&(1$1$(%&%&'#&'#2  Ô| &')#%%&%%&'-%(+'0$ 9(%'.(10(%$ %&','' &' '+)$&-0'%&''9' %%&%%&' -'%.',' '%'0) #++'#%(%(+)(:'00%'(%&')%'$ ,))1+(1 ()(-(%0')'#%(%&'( %-'%  Ô| %+0+,#+(- ;2'-'%( 2 ;&'(%'' %)%&','' $ %&'(--'0(%',( &-'%)%&'#&'#2)$&(#& &'$ %&' .'')(#(0%%&'0')'-'%)%&',' '%-'%)#++'#%( )%&' -'%%&'0$''.2  Ô| &( .'(1%&'# 'c# %+%(#$ %&+0'(0'# '  0')('0.!'#%(5)%&'
  .'# '(%$ .( %&%(% &02$+'01')%&'()(-(%0')'#%)%&'#&'#2 &')#%%&% %&'#&'#2$ &'0.#+(-%.2$ ,)%+)%&'( 1 '1+(1'#'.%)%&'-()' %%()%&' ,'#(+%'%-'% %&'$''##0(1/( c#  Ô| ('$)%&')'1(1%&''-.  %&'0$')%&' #&'#2 (9' %(#%.'&'+0+(.+' %( ,,'%%&%%&' (0 #&'#2 $''<)0+'%++%''0=.c# %%&'(##%  0%&'')'$&++(,'%('<%'" &+0.'>(0'0?=     

! !
!    @! 


 58'5A  #% " Ô| 4'-1'' /'0B,,+('0)0.%('0+)-%&' c')0  Ô|  '#'%&',-'%%&'')&'# %(%%'0-%11' ' (0'%(++% Ô| /'0B&0.'',(1%&'(%'' %%&'+%1'%&'$(%&%&' +0%:  Ô| &'%&'-%11'-%'0.%/'0B ##''0'0(&(1%&' ,'(0),-'%':%'0'0 4$''%&'%''0.%&'c') 0 $(%&)'#+ ')%&'-%11'/'0B 2'0)&'+, )- % ''  Ô| /'0B':'#%'0%(+( %-'%()) %0 '+(*  '' %-2'(%,,'%&%&' +00% )''0%&' ,#'+)+0(9' %(% '' .%&' 0+ -0'%,,' ( (00#-'%%&%%&'+0$  .C'#%%-%11'+('( ))%&'c')0 % '#'%&',-'%)0'.%)*88 $&(#&.+(1%($  -'0.%&',#& '  ,%)%&' ,#& ',(#'  Ô| 4$'' (00''0) +'$ %,' '%'0%%&'c') 0 %%&''1( %)0''0 )'1( %%(  %*  ''  + ( '0,-( %'())4'-1'' /'0B $&''.)+''#'('0&',-( '0%,%&'+%%'0' %&' -)*88.')' ,(+5 (2'$( '%&' -' 0%' ,(+5 %0 '+(*  '' ':'#%'0%&' ,-( %'()) (0/'0B#2$+'01(1%&%%&' $''(0'.%'0%%&'+%%'0,-( (1%,C(%+0 ''++ (/,C+# (B+%&' -)*.')'#%.' 55  Ô| !(#'%&','(0)%&',-'%)%&'-%11'0'.%&0':,('0 $(%&%&(1.'',(0%&'-%11'' ('#%)0 ( %(%%'0 # '1( %/'0B+')%&')'#+ ')%&'-%11' 0C01-'%$ '0''01( %&(-  Ô|  /'0B''0'0-'1'%+&'':'#%'00#-'% $&''.(# (0'%()%&' -)*888&'% )''0%  (0! !% ++&( (1&% (%'' %0,%(#(,%((%&'%$ ,-( %'    '"3
 (0!% ( &+0'(0'# ' 
   4'+0" Ô| 3&' (00#-'% $''% )''0% (0!% ,-'% %&'')$ +'0'''0'0&'$ $')(%  Ô|  ,(%')%&( &'.1&% (0,-( %' $(%&%)( % (9((1(%%&' +'#)%&'-2' %&'')%&'&''( 0')'0% #%'0(1&(- '+)$(%&%&'(0'%&%%&'$''2$ %&(-  Ô| &',-( %' &'%.'''0 '0%&(-.%&'&+0' /'0B  Ô|  (0!%#+(-'0%&' 2'0%&' '' .%&' $&'%&' % (00')'0% $''(0'.%'0%/'0B0%&'  $''0(%&''  Ô| &''( 0.%%&% %&',+(%())&0,#& '0%&'%$ ,-( %' $(%&%%&''#' '0 '-'%%&',%) %&'&+0')%',-'%%&'')&0+'0.'''''0' 0$(%&%&(1-0'(9((' .%%&' +'#)%&'( -2' &'#%.'# (0''0&+0'(0'# '(

##0#'$(%&%&',( ( ) '#%(5)%&'
'1%(.+'  %-'% $< #%
 58= Ô| & %&' '' .%&' &',')'#%(1&%% '%,1( % (0 !% %&'0')' '%&% (0,-( %' +#2+.+' # (0'%(0')(#%(%( $&(#&0')' '%&'#+0+  '% ,1( %(1(+&+0'/'0B()&'0'-0'0,-'%) %&'-