CIR vs. Procter in Gamble Digest

CIR V. PROCTER AND GAMBLE 204 SCRA 378 FACTS: PMC paid a 2535! "a# $% $ % i"& i%'$() *$+ a +),)-a%" )a+. T/)+)a*")+ d)+i-i%1 a" i"& %)" i%'$() i" d)',a+)d di-id)%d& *$+ "/) )%)*i" $* PMCSA. F+$( "/i& d)',a+)d di-id)%d& i" paid a 25! "a# a& p)+ "a#a"i$% ,a&. T/) '$(pa% did "/) &a() *$+ "/) %)#" *) 6a+")+&. T/)% '$%")%di%1 "/a" i" i& "/) i"//$,di%1 a1)%" *$+ "/) "a# paid $% "/) di-id)%d& paid "$ PMCSA i" +)6)&")d *$+ "/) +)*6%d $* i"& a,,)1)d $-)+pa()%"& $* "a#)&. T/) '$(pa% a& d)%i)d "/) +)*6%d a%d '$6+&i%1 "/+$61/ "/) CTA "/) ,a"")+ +6,)d i% i"& *a-$+. ELD: T/) &6(i&&i$% $* "/) C$((i&&i$%)+ $* I%")+%a, R)-)%6) "/a" PMCP/i,. i& 6" a i"//$,di%1 a1)%" $* "/) 1$-)+%()%" a%d "/)+)*$+) 'a%%$" ',ai( +)i(6+&)()%" $* "/) a,,)1)d $-)+ paid "a#)& i& '$(p,)"), ()+i"$+i$6&. T/) +)a, pa+" i% i%")+)&" )i%1 "/) ($"/)+ '$+p$+a"i$% i% "/) %i")d S"a")& i" *$,,$& "/a"  A()+i'a% )%"i" i& "/) +)a, pa+" i% i%")+)&" a%d &/$6,d /a-) ))% "/) ',ai(a%" ',ai(a%" i% "/i& 'a&). C,$&), i%")+"i%)d i"/ "/) *i+&" a&&i1%()%" $* )++$+ i& "/) i&&6) $* /)"/)+ $+ %$" PMC .S.A. i& a %$%+)&id)%" *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% 6%d)+ S)'"i$% 2499 $* "/) Ta# Ta# C$d) "/) &6&idia+ $* a% A()+i'a%9 a d$()&"i' '$+p$+a"i$% d$(i'i,)d i% "/) %i")d S"a")& i& )%"i",)d 6%d)+ "/) .S. Ta# Ta# C$d) "$ a %i")d S"a")& F$+)i1% Ta# C+)di" )6i-a,)%" "$ a" ,)a&" "/) 20 p)+')%"a1) paid p$+"i$% $* "/) 35! di-id)%d "a#9 &pa+)d $+ ai-)d a& $"/)+i&) '$%&id)+)d $+ d))()d paid  "/) 1$-)+%()%". T/) ,a p)+"i%)%" "$ "/) i&&6) i& S)'"i$% ;02 $* "/) .S. I%")+%a, R)-)%6) C$d) a& a()%d)d    P6,i' La 87834 "/) ,a 1$-)+%i%1 "a# '+)di"& 1+a%")d "$ .S. '$+p$+a"i$%& $% di-id)%d& +)')i-)d *+$( *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$%& /i'/ "$ "/) )#")%" app,i'a,) +)ad&: SEC. ;02 CREDIT FOR CORPORATE CORPORATE STOC<OLDERS IN FOREIGN CORPORATION. a9 T+)a"()%" $* Ta#)& Ta#)& Paid  F$+)i1% C$+p$+a"i$%  F$+ p6+p$&)& $* "/i& &6=)'" a d$()&"i' '$+p$+a"i$% /i'/ $%& a" ,)a&" 0 p)+')%" $* "/) -$"i%1 &"$'> $* a *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% *+$( /i'/ i" +)')i-)& di-id)%d& i% a% "a#a,) )a+ &/a,,9 "$ "/) )#")%" &6'/ di-id)%d& a+) paid   &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% $6" $* a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& ?a& d)*i%)d i% &6&)'"i$% '9 9 a9@ $* a )a+ *$+ /i'/ &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% i& %$" a ,)&& d)-),$p)d '$6%"+ '$+p$+a"i$% ) d))()d "$ /a-) paid "/) &a() p+$p$+"i$% $* a% i%'$() a+ p+$*i"& $+ )#')&& p+$*i"& "a#)& paid $+ d))()d "$ ) paid  &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% "$ a% *$+)i1% '$6%"+ $+ "$ a% a%  p$&&)&&i$% $* "/) %i")d S"a")& $% $+ i"/ +)&p)'" "$ &6'/ a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& /i'/ "/) a($6%" $* &6'/ di-id)%d& d)")+(i%)d i"/$6" +)1a+d "$ S)'"i$% 789 )a+& "$ "/) a($6%" $* &6'/ a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& i% )#')&& $* &6'/ i%'$() a+ p+$*i"& a%d )#')&& p+$*i"& "a#)& $"/)+ "/a% "/$&) d))()d paid9a%d 29"$ "/) )#")%" &6'/ di-id)%d& a+) paid  &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% $6" $* a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& ?a& d)*i%)d i% &6&)'"i$% '9 9 9@ $* a )a+ *$+ /i'/ &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% i& a ,)&&d)-),$p)d '$6%"+ '$+p$+a"i$% ) d))()d "$ /a-) paid "/) &a() p+$p$+  "i$% $* a% i%'$() a+ p+$*i"& $+ )#')&& p+$*i"& "a#)& paid $+ d))()d "$ ) paid   &6'/ *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$% "$ a% *$+)i1% '$6%"+ $+ "$ a% p$&&)&&i$% $* "/) %i")d S"a")& $% $+ i"/ +)&p)'" "$ &6'/ a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& /i'/ "/) a($6%" $* &6'/ di-id)%d& )a+& "$ "/) a($6%" $* &6'/ a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"&.

### ### ### '9 App,i'a,) R6,)& 9  A''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& d)*i%)d F$+ p6+p$&) $* "/i& &)'"i$% "/) ")+( a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& ()a%& i"/ +)&p)'" "$ a% *$+)i1% '$+p$+a"i$%. A9 *$+ p6+p$&)& $* &6&)'"i$%& a9 9 a%d 9 9 "/) a($6%" $* i"& 1ai%& p+$*i"& $+ i%'$() '$(p6")d i"/$6" +)d6'"i$%  "/) a($6%" $* "/) i%'$() a+ p+$*i"& a%d )#')&& p+$*i"& "a#)& i(p$&)d $% $+ i"/ +)&p)'" "$ &6'/ p+$*i"& $+ i%'$()  a% *$+)i1% '$6%"+....  a%d B9 *$+ p6+p$&)& $* &6&)'"i$%& a9 29 a%d 9 29 "/) a($6%" $* i"& 1ai%& p+$*i"& $+ i%'$() i% )#')&& $* "/) i%'$() a& p+$*i"& a%d )#')&& p+$*i"& "a#)& i(p$&)d $% $+ i"/ +)&p)'" "$ &6'/ p+$*i"& $+ i%'$(). T/) S)'+)"a+ $+ /i& d),)1a") &/a ,, /a-) *6,, p$)+ "$ d)")+(i%) *+$( "/) a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& $* /a" )a+ $+ )a+& &6'/ di-id)%d& )+) paid "+)a"i%1 di-id)%d& paid i% "/) *i+&" 20 da& $* a% )a+ a& /a-i%1 ))% paid *+$( "/) a''6(6,a")d p+$*i"& $* "/) p+)')di%1 )a+ $+ )a+& 6%,)&& "$ /i& &a"i&*a'"i$% &/$& $"/)+i&)9 a%d i% $"/)+ +)&p)'"& "+)a"i%1 di-id)%d& a& /a-i%1 ))% paid *+$( "/) ($&" +)')%", a''6(6,a")d 1ai%& p+$*i"& $+ )a+%i%1&. T/)+) i& %$"/i%1 i% "/) a*$+)'i")d p+$-i&i$% "/a" $6,d =6&"i* "a# +)"6+% $* "/) di&p6")d 5! "$ "/) p+i-a") +)&p$%d)%". F6+"/)+($+) a& a, a+16)d  "/) p)"i"i$%)+ "/) p+i-a") +)&p$%d)%" *ai,)d "$ ())" ')+"ai% '$%di"i$%& %)')&&a+ i% $+d)+ "/a" "/) di-id)%d& +)')i-)d  "/) %$%+)&id)%" pa+)%" '$(pa% i% "/) %i")d S"a")& (a ) &6=)'" "$ " /) p+)*)+)%"ia, 5! "a# i%&")ad $* 35!. A($%1 $"/)+ "/i%1& "/) p+i-a") +)&p$%d)%" *ai,)d: 9 "$ &/$ "/) a'"6a, a($6%" '+)di")d  "/) .S. 1$-)+%()%" a1ai%&" "/) i%'$() "a# d6) *+$( PMC.S.A. $% "/) di-id)%d& +)')i-)d *+$( p+i-a") +)&p$%d)%" 29 "$ p+)&)%" "/) i%'$() "a# +)"6+% $* i"& ($"/)+ '$(pa% *$+ ;75 /)% "/) di-id)%d& )+) +)')i-)d a%d 39 "$ &6(i" a% d6, a6"/)%"i'a")d d$'6()%" &/$i%1 "/a" "/) .S. 1$-)+%()%" '+)di")d "/) 20! "a# d))()d paid i% "/) P/i,ippi%)&.