REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES FIRST JUDICIAL REGION REGIONAL TRIAL COURT BRANCH 03 DUMAGUETE, NEGROS ORIENTAL
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES , NO. 8722 - 08 Plaintif , IMPRUDENCE WITH HOMICIDE - versus JUAN DELA CRU, PEDRO PENDUCO, AND PABLO PANDA! , Accused . x-----------------------------------------------x
CRIMINAL CASE FOR: RECKLESS
PRE-TRIAL BRIEF FOR THE PLAINTIFF
ACCUSED, through the undersigned prosecutor, unto this Honorable Court, most respectull! submit this "re-#rial $rie, and hereb! alleges b! %a! o&
PLEA BARGAINING
#he "rosecution "rosecution and the complainant %ill %ill not entertain plea bargaining bargaining that ma! be proposed b! the deense.
PROPOSED STIPULATION ST IPULATION OF FACTS
'. #hat the complai complainant, nant, (ario (ario (a)iling, (a)iling, *+ !ears !ears old, married, married, %or)s %or)s as an Algebra proessor at Negros riental Seaside Universit! NSU/ or '0 !ears1 0. #hat the accused, accused, (aria (a)iling, 2uan Dela Cru3, "edro "edro "enduco, "enduco, and "ablo "ablo "anda!, all '4 !ears old, single, students o Negros riental Seaside Universit! NSU/1 +. #hat (aria (aria (a)iling (a)iling is the girlrien girlriend d o "ablo "ablo "anda! "anda! or or one '/ month, and and the daughter o (ario (a)iling1 *. #hat the accused accused %ere %ere absent or 5ve */ */ consecutive consecutive classes classes on Algebra, Algebra, dated August 6, 7, 8, '0, 09'0, %ith Algebra classes on (onda!s, :ednesda!s, and ;rida!s1
6. #hat on August '*, 09'0 at around *&99 in the aternoon, (r. (a)iling as)ed or their excuse letters and exam permits as that %as their midterm exam da!1 <. #hat on the exam da!, the accused have not produced both excuse letters and examination permits, and the! %ere sent to the principal=s o>ce as accompanied b! the complainant (ario (a)iling, and that the accused %ere sent home1 7. #hat on August '<, 09'0 around 7&99 in the morning, "ablo "anda! %ent to etch (aria (a)iling at the (a)iling=s residence to drive her to her morning classes1 4. #hat on August '<, 09'0, the accused and (aria (a)iling %ere absent rom their Algebra class1 8. #hat in the evening o August '<, 09'0, the accused and (aria (a)iling %ent to a raternit! part! at the house o 2uan dela Cru31 '9.#hat the accused "ablo "anda! drove his car ater the part! around ''&99 in the evening together %ith 2uan dela Cru3, "edro "enduco and dropping o? (aria (a)iling t%o 0/ bloc)s a%a! rom her house at '*+ $aguio St., Seaside Heights @illage, Dumaguete Cit!1 ''.#hat the accused "ablo "anda!, 2uan dela Cru3 and "edro "enduco agreed to drive around the neighborhood o (aria (a)iling at ''&99 in the evening %ith headlights o?1 '0.#hat around''&+9 in the same evening o August '<, 09'0, (aria (a)iling %as rushed to Negros riental Seaside Hospital or loss o consciousness, and the accused 2uan dela Cru3 and "edro "enduco %ere %ith (aria (a)iling at the hospital1 '+.#hat (aria (a)iling %as unconscious since August '<, 09'0 up to her death on September 6, 09'0.
ISSUE&
:hether or not the accused are guilt! be!ond reasonable doubt o the crime charged in the complaint or inormation.
DOCUMENTAR! AND OBJECT E"IDENCE &
#he "rosecution %ill present the ollo%ing& EHB$B # A
DCU(EN# $2EC# (EDBC EFA E"#
"U"SE #o prove the extent and impact o the ph!sical inGuries leading to the death o (aria (a)iling.
.
WITNESSES
NA(ES '. (ario (a)iling
DESBFNA#BN Complainant ;ather o @ictim
0. "ido Dido
Neighbor o the @ictim and #o testi! to the events he esident o Seaside %itnessed. Heights @illage Co accused ;riend o #o testi! on the events "ablo "anda! that happened leading to the loss o consciousness o (aria (a)iling. #o urther testi! on the strained relationship bet%een "ablo "anda! and (aria (a)iling, and among the three accused against (r. (ario (a)iling their proessor %ho un)ed them/. "olice o>cer investigator #o testi! to the circumstances together %ith her expertise on the events o the case. Emergenc! "h!sician #o testi! and explain the ph!sicial inGuries su?ered b! the victim. Neurologist #o testi! and explain the condition o the victim %hile in the hospital until her death.
+. 2uan dela Cru3
*. S"' Nharra (olave
6. Dr. $ e!es
<. Dr. De eon
"U"SE #o identi! and establish the relationship o his daughter and the "ablo "anda!, as %ell as the 2uan dela Cru3 and "edro "enduco.
#he "rosecution reserves the %itnesses as the need arises.
ES"EC#;UI SU$(B##ED. Dumaguete Cit!, "hilippines, September +9, 09'0 Cit! "rosecutor Asst. "rosecutor
C#$% F&'()*+: P/# P(%
'' o%er $agaca! Dumaguete Cit! J&( C'&1
'77 A$C St., Dumaguete Cit! P'# P(&#
9+ Drive #hrough Apt., Dumaguete Cit!
A%. J&*))# B#4/ A%. C') B#4/
$A#($ACA AND ASSCBA#ES 'st ;loor #riple Arcade "la3a Dumaguete Cit!, "hilippines Counsel or accused "ablo "anda!, 2uan dela Cru3, and "edro "enduco
eceived b!
& JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ Signature over "rinted Name /
Date#ime eceived e. Code
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ &
"re-#rial $rie CC 4700 - 94" vs. "anda!
