Family+Law+Notes - AWESOME

c
   



 



 `

``
 
  

`

 



 


 


`
 
` 
!
 

 

" 
#
$
%
$%
&
$
'
  


 
(
) 
*

 
 *
+
)

,
-
** 





 
 *    
  |Y           
 |Y c       
 


    |Y º   |Y º 
     



  

  è! " 
   " 
  #
  |Y " 
    $ %" $& mY $  '$ |Y " 
 (   $ %"!$& |Y " 
 (    
 $ %"!$& |Y $!)     c
    |Y c   #
 mY )  * )  $   c
           
+      |Y   |Y 
    |Y ,     , |Y 
 , |Y          |Y            
  |Y    

c
   

|Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y



 



mY                  !   O            O
   

 '          

 |Y   ) mY !    .      |Y ) mY !     
 
     |Y  #      /   
   mY ˜   
                           +  |Y  
     ˜ ˜    

 
$0Y    $    0Y     0Y 1º 
 2+ !  0Y 
 0Y    1 ˜         O    $
  0Y   0Y      0Y
  0Y ˜  0Y ˜  0Y    -0Y ! 
    0Y 1º 
 2+ !  0Y !
    0Y    1 ˜         O    $
  0Y    ˜  0Y
  0Y º

-

c
   



 



30Y ˜   ˜    0Y 1º 
 2+ !  0Y  
 )
  0Y    1 ˜         O    $
  0Y ˜      ˜  0Y
  0Y c
    0Y $ 0Y    0Y  2   0Y '      `
. 


 */  , 4445
 6
 
    .       O |Y 5
          
7 
  8 

      
 
   
  0 !-6668   
      
7   0 !  |Y    
          9:  |Y †           
7 
 
     

 0 |Y  c   |Y 
7            
     |Y 5
      / 

         $   
 4;4< 
 
       O

3

c
   



 



|Y $  
       


          7 
       >
  ?   0 |Y c          mY   ?        mY  
  ?  


  mY O       
       ) 
 |Y       
       
0  )  
     0 !  |Y !  
            
 8 ,,            
 9:  c   |Y          
 8  8
    8       +  @ /  5     " 4A=-; º     2 
   O |Y "                >      
   
        
     0 !  |Y !     
      9:  c   |Y $           7
         8      8       8 
 7    0  
 # mY 2 
        8    8 
 8    ,        ,  8          0 $ 
            %-&    ,        ,           8    8 
   
      
0   )  

$ O   
     ˜  
  , %     & O

=

c
   



 



|Y  0  
    
  B          
 

0 7 
       
? 0 7   8  0 7  ,8     0 7 !  #     7    8 
 0  7
        0    # |Y         

  %   8 & |Y           8     8  

     c   |Y 
   ?+           
    B 
        
    .  0    º   5   4463=  º O
 , =


 #   O |Y           
    >  .
  
     
             >  C  C  C
C        C   .    
0 ˜    |Y      
     
  D  ,     D           8         ,D 
   

 ,    
                  D      D      
      

        º     0 c   |Y )       =    (the ordinance was looking for predictability) |Y 8
          |Y 
                        º  4E<"  ˜  ) %    >     
   &

<

c
   



 



O |Y 
   ,            
      -663-=3

,  
   2  O , O |Y $       
         
              
    = 

 

%
(
) 
"

" *
 
 #0
 <c    c
  |Y )   > 
 
   
  >  |Y c   mY º      
  |Y $  %    & |Y   mY   
          
  8       > 
  ,        lY 00 .   

  
  
          
  
D         8          8
,   
   
      |Y   mY          8  
   8              mY   .       
           
, 
     mY 00  $/                
 %   
        & |Y  
         mY  
 8   8
 8    mY O '      

E

c
   



 



mY   

           mY O2'9 

 
 ,   lY   8   
8 8
F |Y  
      )    mY     mY O2'9c
 ,   
 
    lY 
 >   8    8    lY ˜     ,    lY ) >      O   $
 9 |Y ˜ >         mY           |Y ˜            mY 
     mY    
       mY 
8    8
8    $ ,#!   9                

    
    


``
1`,2)

!'0
!            8                  9 |Y !
+     8             8    
       |Y !
  8    
               
    mY º   ,   
        lY      $!8          
    , |Y c
       mY
        
   
        mY 2  8        /               O  )  #
  

A

c
   



 



|Y º 
   c   $  c   |Y ˜.        |Y 2         |Y !      8   

 |Y º                   
  +
    
     " 
- 
 
0  |Y -;   > |Y , @    / |Y     #       
      
 mY 2                        |Y            
,                 4E33<4  #    O |Y (         ,      D
    ,    |Y  B           ? B              0 !     9 |Y !     0          

      
   8     0 |Y )      0 |Y
    D 

, 0      0 c   |Y $ -6   
 8      0   0 0   
     
 

         
 0 0          ,         0  ;

c
   



 



O O 4AE3E6   O |Y '       0 |Y          c   |Y '          # mY O         0 mY O  0 mY O      0    


    8 
  
    # 0  $                ?    
  

    D 0$     

    0
$  $  44A3E O |Y " 
   
 8    



 c   |Y O '
36  8   8    |Y               
 |Y     
     !

1
  4;33E3 O |Y                    )   
8   /  ,      c   |Y 5          
       

  
          +         
    

4

c
   

|Y



 



 D     .  
 
            .      )

 4onstructive desertion |Y $           
 
 mY 44-5$         |Y '       +   D    O  8 8
     1

" 
- 
1

 3

4 
|Y c    
        |Y º                8  8 
  8 /  
   

 %  8 2&8         


* 
1
) 
 
1
|Y !        
 
   8          
 
  |Y              ˜ ,˜ ,4
   0  
) 
|Y '                 /  

   
    mY !               mY )      
   lY $           F 6

c
   



 



    4-63EA     O |Y    0         C  C        0 |Y $   
                 

    8       0 c   |Y                   0         
   

     0˜        lY     >       O        
     
       8


    8     lY           !
) 
1
|Y !   ,             ,    
                   .      |Y !     8   |Y    
 |Y         
       ' ' 4E63E; O |Y   0$  B       0 |Y c 
D       0 |Y     G      0 c   |Y            
        0             0 |Y B  #          
0 |Y   # 

  0   

c
   



 



#
)1 |Y '                


       |Y          |Y 2
         c c 4=E3A6 ˜       O |Y      8       0        


  0 c   |Y            0        
         0  8     
          0 |Y $    +
           ?       0   D   ,             0  V4" 
1
 O      |Y       

      %       & 
    +      9O   


 9 mY               
  8

  
    mY    

      7       |Y  ,   º  /  

        *   8                  
    
  mY         mY )3A;$     |Y ÿ*
  

1


!05
|Y " $H36-%3A4& mY (. 


-

c
   



 



mY  
    ,%! & lY ;6     2˜ lY   
        

      mY !    !  lY     ,          8  
          |Y  
,   !               

           |Y !   G              


6 
V
 
1

!    0*,4;4             O |Y               
 D          
    
   c   |Y )             |Y              
                 
 |Y    " $ D  )  
1

!7


         D




   D
     7     % >  8 8   & |Y    
        |Y $            
        |Y ˜       3

c
   

mY mY mY mY mY



 



 
              ,    

    -      8  c  %  8 8   
 8   &



 44<3;;      O |Y $
   , 7       c   |Y '    
   O        7          -    %            
& mY     mY ˜   

 mY )   /   8   .  lY !    8 8     
           -66-34 5$))#          7     O |Y       . 
     >  D            $  7      8            
          |Y  7               ,      c   |Y c    
 8'   O    |Y       ,         |Y     #2   c  |Y . 
       |Y '                <6*            è           8 8       8    /         8        $/   

=

c
   



 



(
) *
) 
2#   # 7      
   

443343 !!     8  /    O |Y                         
       8  !    >    0 |Y O 8                     
                      0 |Y '                 8              
              



     
  0 !  |Y  !!     9:  c   |Y !  


 8  
 I<8666      
    0 |Y O    '
   
             
           8      
  
               ,    
 0 '       %2$&           |Y '
         
 ! mY   /       ! ! mY J 
    
           2$ ! mY          lY !    8, 8 
      8 8 |Y ˜ >!!   |Y O   mY !!               mY (
 
,                          

     è)       
  $     =63 <

c
   



 



   


1
$  $  44E=6;  / 
      O |Y ' ,     
           
         (      ,   C 8C          B        0 c   |Y O        @º /       +   %       O '    
  & |Y O    D/   %  &  
  |Y           
     (   |Y       /    O     (          $    %=6& mY )        8     /             mY  
         mY   
        mY O         0     mY 2 


  
    lY               º    '                         (
. 

) 
 
  


1
    4A=<  /         !  |Y '   
 
                    O# |Y !           
            
  >    
      

E

c
   



 



   8        
8              8           8      8 , +       
      %=A& |Y " ) = 8
 ˜ ˜8  
  % ,       & c   |Y       mY )        IE6 lY =< ,8<   )    |Y '
        
     
      |Y             8  /  ,         
 |Y "     /   D'    
 8
    
D   , OD   
      

  |Y            mY !   @ /   lY '    /   9 lY :     
      |Y èè    5 8
    !   
    9      8           0  
        
      0       +           0      
  8   .         !  4A<=;     .
    !   D 
E,  -   O |Y " .
    |Y $   ˜ ˜%@!$  /      
/& |Y     c˜  8  /   
 ˜      
 

A

c
   



 



|Y          
       ,  !  |Y  
              

  c   |Y  !8:8   :8'
 !$  , 8'  !$8   
 0!$       .
 8     
     !      
 
  .
 9 |Y $        |Y    
  .
  



)  
*

#5
      |Y    7      8 /  |Y       
    
  |Y c   +
 
,8
       

     
 |Y $
        
       


 

      ,  |Y             8+    8     |Y c  
  
D    
     > =-            $
=-< ,        0˜.    ```
$ V(`V

- (
`V(  (
2"
)`1
(V11

''
;

c
   



 



 " $ !2=6-# !=3E       $     8# |Y     /   % &     |Y           |Y                     
      /     |Y 
          |Y        %,  &    -E0-E˜'" 
      )
1
|Y  (   |Y )     mY )   lY )        |Y (     #  ,      
     mY   lY ˜      
,        /   lY   8 8
   |Y 5      mY         lY  
          

-`)
  8
, 
" 
 

$*
9
(
: 
1
V

 

*
 
º) 
      
 B C   C %    =&0 0  O  #        
     0  '9 ?

B 

 0 0-6  05#  
      
0 0 #    +       # K #)  %$ 
4E&

4

c
   



 



KO#   
         0%2 -      
     0& 0!     # K: 0 %&       ?   
   0 %-&!       

 0 %3&     
  ,  0 %=&!   

    II   0  K  0 %& 
  
       0 %-&  !           
      ?
      0  



"

-`)
 !
   4A4<-<    !   O |Y                         
  0% 0   ,   
 & |Y                 $ ! $ !!:    
                 
     
 . 0 |Y )   
      , 0 |Y   
  
   0 |Y , B      
  
0 c   |Y O   0    
0  0      
           B       C    C    0    0(
 B0 |Y  !

. 

" 

-`)

'!
 O O -66

-6

c
   



 



         O |Y                 8        8                     |Y O
        c           |Y /  8     mY   
   
%     &3   |Y  
                  mY O   8  8            
   |Y '         , 8           
  mY    |Y 
 
           
 
  mY
        |Y      
    |Y     mY      mY O
   8      
 mY '  
            |Y O
8   

    mY    |Y     #

 



-`)

'!7
 ) 
  4;<"  ˜      O |Y  0         0 c   |Y !   
        -  0 |Y '          
    9  ' 

        9 |Y     08          
 C   
>  C          0      0  0   0 -

c
   



 



 (  (  44E<=6       % $
 &  
      O |Y $  O      8    ) 
     /    
  !  |Y                       9 c   |Y O  $
  >         , D  8  ,  
         
  
D    
            

 <=3 |Y ˜ ,) 
 
        
'

 

-`)

'#;



          # L$        
0            B  c  $

              B                    
  0 L˜ ,  
0    
       B  c  $

             B        
   


  0 L  
.0       B                    0 !        +          B        8  B      #             B   0 !   #

--

c
   



 



|Y "         B           ?  % * &8          
       0  * * 44A )        +        O |Y $ B            8          2    (        8           c $

     0 |Y      
      8 8               

 ,   +  
   (         
 
       |Y $  7          B     77

    B     %    
    2    ( 
 &          
      C
   C77  
  
   


  ! 

  ˜ |Y    . 
  C C    

   B         C     +8    
  8  M N    ,  
   

  0C '    +B                D                  0 c   |Y   (                     C
   C  C     0C |Y        ,    (       C     0C   -66E 0)0< !1 1    O

-3

c
   



 



|Y    
 
     /       D |Y     8  .   
  
    8                    
                
    |Y c     8      
     
      88   8       
0 O 8      : 8  
                           +  >

   
        8              0     
        8              /       
      / 2      c /  0   8              77        /  2           
77  
  c   |Y  
 
 
  |Y 

    
 |Y º   

     

/   ,  
 
   |Y c     
  D       /         
 
  |Y     # O      /      
    /    8 
 /    8    

0P  E0/ )  ! 

                         H=6- " $0O 8       


  /      
     
 

  
 0        0 

   44-<<=   O

-=

c
   



 



|Y        /                

       |Y   /         D " $=6=

           c   |Y º$        
    /        0Y |Y !º$8      8=                  0Y |Y     8   8   /      0Y |Y      ,     0Y |Y                      0Y |Y                     0Y |Y !    8     
     /       8

               0 Y



0

 

 
 


-`)
 *0(0 00 0 04;4<
   O |Y       
           |Y       , 
     ! 

   |Y      D        +
           c   |Y O    

      
                 -<

c
   



 



|Y )            |Y c       +     |Y )           /        
  


   |Y $                   ,        D    D

  D              
    
         7
)


)

-`)
    44A
 O |Y         8       D   ,  

     
º$ |Y '       

 º$        8 

  
        
º$           
         !  
           |Y           
,    
             !  |Y   

    
                                 º$9          ˜)    


        º$ c   |Y       
  8        
   
 |Y O
  D 
8 
8  
' |Y      

D '     D ,    ,    
   

 '  ,  
$  8

 
 

'++
 
(
: 
$*
 -E

c
   



 



) ) 4;E
 #c        
  D "  7    0c   # K) ?  
   K 8
?  K) 8 ?     K   % ?    0& K$    7           K$  7 

0   K  K  K 
  , 80 8  Y †     )
  ,Y |Y '       
     9Y |Y )    Y

-A

c
   



 



|Y !   
               
   ,9Y |Y O   
  

9Y  `
$

$* 
)  <



';54
|Y ) mY )            mY "   
       lY ˜                   lY ˜       .              |Y $! mY   /   
      lY !
    º  ,   4;
c
   



 



      (    |Y $     |Y   $  |Y 2     .  . 443
      8 +   
 0       8     
               
   0 !  |Y !      
  (92 c   |Y         


#
$ 
1

$  
3
 : O 444 
      ,  mY c    ,c ,    |Y     
   ,8

 .       >   D    ,  
  ,       3   D       % 8 F&

-4

c
   



 



!  |Y '   
  ,      9
 |Y  ,      

 mY    8    
  mY    
  %=A-664& c   |Y O  ,  , 8
 ,8 

  

  |Y O       |Y   
      ,D ,  ,8           ,  D        ,     |Y O  ,  ,    
 |Y
  
   |Y O    
   ,            |Y º$

 

  8      '

`
$


 

" *
1

'77
 H-06;$      ˜     "       
      8                          
             
         
         
   ,                8             /  

 F            
      +   |Y % & 
            8              
                          
 
       
      
       |Y %&  

   
                  8      
       |Y   ,                       

36

c
   



 



|Y                         
 
                  /            
8   8   
 8       8             8  8          |Y          
  
    `
>
5;8$         
,    <46  `
$

)
|Y !    mY       
  lY "      lY '  
  H-06%&% &?%& |Y !      mY                    ,             lY ˜        
   |Y    
           `
$


  <
|Y ˜

     mY )    
  mY /  mY  ,     mY O 
  /    
  


           /         
   /   mY $   
       
  mY $       /                 H-06;%&% &7%&  `

$2`-`(

*

|Y º    -0-%&%& |Y ˜    8  8  

     |Y ˜           
  

3

c
   



 



       
                 
   |Y ˜       |Y

 `
8

 

  
1
* <
3

>
5;

';5
|Y *8    8     8 
      
 8   8 ,8     8       |Y       
 8  |Y !c  
       mY ) 
         +     
,                      ! lY   
%
 8  8  !& mY '    
9 lY $           lY )       
, lY '      lY $                
,  +

 *
8
<

';




|Y c         
       

      
 +   , |Y   ( ! . D    /     ,# .  8   8     9 
V
(* 
3
)
|Y 2#5      |Y #   8     8      
$ V(`V 8
21`"`)(`2V
#&;&55;
'  
,      
  8  ,   ! 0 %E66' &0    
  8  ,      0   0 

3-

c
   



 





 
9
)  

)* 

ÿ1
>
#5;
 

)  

)* 
|Y   
   
  |Y 2 
 # mY 2        lY $    lY ",       
 mY  
    $ mY       ! |Y ˜  "  mY      
   mY           
        2˜  
 @     /$ 
, lY )  8
 8
 8
     |Y è     %

 <4<& mY   

>             mY     -    lY "  
 
     lY 

 #       8    mY ˜       
  
   
        ,    
 
       lY 

 #  @      /   
 
       8     7       

  /      O  O  44A<4E

  1      1    


  $               $ ,#! 
 9! 8     !D O |Y      
 

33

c
   



 



|Y           


    A                      |Y O     * 0*8--0A-=83;6 0'0- 366 %4;E&8         
  8    
     
                      
 0 mY `      8         
00 0    
   0 0 0                   000  
            
0'              



  8                       


   
       !  c   |Y O    , 

D
     D


  

   A     D    D      
 O/     
  ' ' 44<<44

  1  
  '       9 O |Y !        
                               
  8     
      8 7         |Y               


    D                             |Y    
          !  !  |Y                      /           

44=+
 9:  c   |Y   Dc    3=

c
   



 



|Y 2  
           /   
           
 D 
   

      |Y    
 Dc/ ,  D 
   mY
         
     E6
    c   mY 
   D        |Y   
         |Y c      +                
     ˜ ˜ ˜ #     )   E6- 4;4
      
 O |Y           ! ˜    |Y 
           0 |Y !     ,    
 ,?   

? 0%           

 0˜ & |Y      
0    B   7 
 
  ,   ( 0  !  c   |Y         

D=             |Y )              , 8      
0 |Y 3        mY   mY )    mY (  º  #        7        0 %)            & lY  # lY 0˜ 8( % , &       0     
  B 0  3<

c
   



 



 

 
9
 

º   
            -66E6<           %(&     ˜           +        O |Y ˜
0 
        
    , /  
 |Y 
        
,  
            O         
         
 P0 |Y            
                 0 |Y      
     8  8   

             

           
   0 |Y  
   8  8                        7                 8         +8   
  
 
 0 mY !   
           
       
          
 .  
   
       0 c      |Y        
D %-&            D%3&        
D%=&      8           .       D %<&           . 

       

      .              D %E&        

          

3E

c
   



 



       
            D%A&  ,                   /          7       
    D %;&     
   
         D%4&    8   D%6&                     
                 D %&     7              D%-&       /   0 !  c   |Y $   ,8  /       

  (    
    D   
      
 |Y  8   
       |Y ,/    ,         |Y 
 #         8    ,      
F
 

  

-66E E3

  1   1(        O |Y ˜ 0    0 |Y     +      
 D             |Y $      +          
       
   
       / 8             
   ! .     
        0  
    0 |Y   
,  
   |Y    
    ! c   |Y O       
 
 c           40 0 |Y       8 ! 3A

c
   



 



|Y )   +          8
 c   E64 |Y  
   ,        /    
            D=   
  |Y             /              |Y c 
  
  8 

         !

 
9
  
 
  º " -666E-              ,  O |Y                    
, ,     |Y                     8 ,   '                            +   0

    |Y            , 
    |Y $   
       8        c   |Y '$  8              
1    !2  #

 
9
ÿ* 
$ 




" 


!  " 4A-E3; "
      
 
   )          , O

3;

c
   



 



|Y $                                       
 ,    0 |Y !       .       
 
                          B     
   
   
 
     B   0 |Y 

                  .                             
         
       
      0 !  c   |Y ! 8       


    
   ;  0    
0!    
 
          0 |Y $            8    8     0  8  8       8  8                8         0 |Y  B        
         

 8     B  
     8 
 
 
         B     . 0  ˜  " 4;3E= c               ,       
   
   ,           O |Y   8   
%,   7   &     
8                 B     0 |Y  )    mY          
      B     0O  
      0  B        .
            >   0   

34

c
   



 



        D      
     
      !  |Y '  / )                   9  c   |Y $      
 
   0  


   
0C C       0          0  0 ,    B  
0 |Y c    
: ,B C   8C     
          |Y $           
               8              0

3
ÿ* 
)&$  
$ 
 3&1
 

$ 
3


1
 
 8


 *


?
-`)
|Y ! 
  
   
8        /   8      @                      /       @        8    /    8  
   
               0 |Y          /   

   / 
0    8          
        8  
       ,             0    /     8       
   8     8       
  % $!& |Y ˜                   /    .        
  8  
  
        /       7        
                    
   
0  (                    /      

=6

c
   



 



`
 5! 3 8
$ 
3

|Y        mY )           8     
              7   
    /      % &       8            8 ! lY $
 
    )˜!2˜ /  D  

    
  `
 5!  8
1
" 
$ 
|Y          mY    -   |Y $ mY c     
       
  8   
           
    7    2˜
            
   ,    lY ˜  

+     ,     lY ˜  
           

 |Y 

 # mY ˜.
  @  8                                mY $
      
        8       
       |Y         
 
  

  
  .     7    |Y J0     
      /           .
     mY                           8  8   `
>
 7
1
 %
%
 
 
3
 
                     8      8         
            J)O$ |Y       
+                  +           

=

c
   



 



mY "                   
           2˜ mY $       
   

`
* 

 
 
|Y -063%&% &      100  8    8
  
  
       500 0(0 0-666(E=4         '    
    
   0 è 
          58  8  8    
  $!-063% &%&)     O |Y $
   +   8        |Y ˜   B  
8 
+     500B              D  8      +
   500B             
           0 |Y   B     C             8              8  ,                   0C )) |Y        
         +      8  8      .           8500       0(0 0       

 500 ,  
,    0 c   |Y       C  
            B   
  +             
 
    B      8   
     
  

    
  
            0C |Y 500            
8 0(0 08      
       +  |Y    8  8         


=-

c
   



 



|Y   8 
8  
 
 

8        >8         |Y   8     8   
      ,

    (
3

$  
$ %

*
8
%&                   8   8     B   
     
      7,      

 D %-&               
    D%3&       
         

,            B   8      
 8          B    8          
  M    B       B        
 ND  %=&                     
          8       0      44A5E
 0 
  % &              0 $          8            0 $               +          
                   0  
     5
  

 0 |Y 5
                        7       0 7    8 8

=3

c
   



 



   .           0  `
$ 
3

 5!
$! 
,    /   3  /                                  
                  0  ",       8                 8    

                   0     $!  
             
                   0   $0O0 0)0 -66E A= )         general parenting     %     8 

  & caretaking functions%    & O;  |Y                      D          |Y !  +        8                   D   7   
                  
D    
                  /               |Y $! -063%&                     A;  
 )) |Y                   
D            D  +    )     
       D     )        .   .  .              

        ) |Y $      
          ! 

==

c
   



 



|Y                          
  
                   9 |Y !              >              
                   
           |Y                 
       8                  
        
          /      c   |Y
          
 
  02                 D           8      ,8  |Y     ,      8 ,        D        ,       |Y          ,  
8                           7    |Y   , ;
    '
 8

=
`

++!4;'


7477



ÿ))=
;+7
|Y 4;=8 
 
  |Y -   + mY O
  mY  #            |Y $  +* 


   
  mY !     
$ lY !  !      
+           /  
 D       
         mY $  
       ; |Y ÿ))=

7

6 
lY c  
     +           (       ,

=<

c
   



 




 2  %            2   & lY c   "  2
 2    


, 
+      lY       
3
*
 
6 
ÿ))=


|Y                E
       2˜ |Y   
 
   
     E
   $         |Y ! /     
 +


         |Y 
# mY (  

  $ A  8    8  ( 

   0
   $ 
 +( 
 
  E
   $       
  
)
= 
ÿ))=
|Y               $                      %    & |Y 
 mY (    2  <  0  8( 

    '       
  8  !     8  c$   0     c$        (

,    0   2 0 mY         +         2   


 E
     /       mY   ,          c  |Y !  (/    

/  +  
 9       |Y !          c                   7  
  |Y          2                   ÿ))= 
ÿ*
)
)
= 

*


;;0


=E

c
   



 



|Y O    +    8
         |Y ádopted by all states |Y )      court with home state jxn has priority        +                   |Y  8       +              
8  ,     
    
0 |Y !  / 8    |Y +  |Y  /       +    
     ;      +         ,

  %    & 
  
  2   
   ,  
   $ 
@ 
$

$@$

|Y      cc       8     

   D        
    
    8   +   |Y      mY )
   D
       mY   /       
 
+8  

     
     /   cc  cull faith and credit clause .              
   +
      |Y             +
         + 
  !   ;  

` 


  ,   44; O
 +        O |Y 5$+
   0c   /  +0        8 5$+
      ,   0 =A

c
   



 



|Y $    "($8  c    
               8   
      c 8  
                 +      
   "($ |Y !       
         +       .  8 
       !  |Y '  +9   

                   9 2 '            +92 c   |Y  
  ,(0       +         ,8    
  

 |Y     ,    

  ,8      ,  

/   8 /   8   0 5     8  0
 c 0   

 

 5            +0    c       0         
 
 4;; )  ,               

             D  /             D     +
         O |Y  )*)$         
               
             0 |Y !       +    
  +    8   
              

      )*)$ |Y )  /        ,     
   
        |Y         )*)$      77     +       , 
               
       ,  77       Bprincipal aim was to extend the requirements of the cull caith and 4redit 4lause to custody determinations, and not to create an entirely new cause of action.

=;

c
   



 



|Y       
    $         8 

   $     
 8             
     8            8  $ B      Cc             
   8C 8 ,                   8 $        

   0 |Y  8           +     
                      B    +         
     8  )*)$B                                  
   0 )) |Y     
   , )(  (D 
  !  |Y    )  * )  $  4;6                    9 c   |Y )*)$                      %      
 +    (& |Y " )  * )  $  4;6%)*)$ $ &8

  .            
        B   0 |Y $   +    8    '    
      D              B    |Y 
               

            8        8     B   8          |Y c  
                       $  |Y '    


           8         c        ,                8  +    
         0     
   
         $   
  

=4

c
   



 



                
        0  ÿ))= 
;;0
ÿ*
)
)
= 

*

|Y      "($ mY c   )*)$   
          +  
            
    |Y *      "($           )*)$     
        + 
        |Y ,  )*$8
             
       
              

   
      
"($ 


`  
)
1
O     |Y         <6    |Y $  , E |Y 
   #             
        mY º  ,       
       / mY  + 
  !)*$ |Y "        
           O     %" $
& !$˜$ |Y !    $  ˜
 $  |Y "       

    O      " %$ > & "($ |Y !                 8     
 


    ) "($

<6

c
   



 



|Y   8        

 
)


)


`  
)
3


+0+
|Y $  , E |Y        

   |Y                   
    O      
.                0  
)  
                0DO     
                   .                O     C   
    
         D  MN                                         0C O    8$ 00   2 0  44Ac00)EA- O     /         +    !     .  8   
9 O |Y          D
     
        "   D       
  |Y           

/ 
  
   O                 
   

, D             ,    

 

+
   |Y          
/  
    
 "     D   O        8       ,  / 
      c   |Y c  ,  
   "  %" &    

/  
  

<

c
   



 



|Y
 O     , B     

 
      
  |Y  ,    ,                
  |Y    O         

"   0 |Y
 
         |Y       8  
 8   .    B   "    |Y     $                    
   
         
B    
         
  8  
           0  
 
-663EAA O        O  
   O |Y C    C  
   !    
      !   C>   0C |Y 

            !   
 /    

   |Y                   
    O      
.                0 !  )) |Y c              (  ˜  B  O       
8         C     C    8   8     !    

      8          ,      !   $ 3%&       0 ˜    0 |Y ˜            
D     c   |Y  
   !  8
  

D    D     
  !  D 
8    
8     +   8
      D   D  ,  <-

c
   

|Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y

|Y |Y



 



   , D 
  , 
       !                   %    &  ,     , 


        D        "    ,            D          , !   *  !    8   O!           ' , ,      @   / ,  
             ˜     !    C˜.    ˜   $  C                   % &8     O    0 '
    ,     c        !      $   ˜
  $ %!$˜$&

 
+
*

)
                    /        |Y 
   %' & mY c  8     |Y   %O, & |Y 
    %$
& mY       $8$Q8$ |Y            mY  / ,    %c 
&   ' ' -66<!  E;-             
  %         
 & O |Y $
   
8( 8 ,   
                  
    <3

c
   



 




    %    
      
   & |Y '    
   8       |Y          !  |Y   O                

         9  :  ! 8    
    9  :  %'    &            ' 
  9 8           

     -<* c   |Y 
 (   

 $ %    & |Y          (  
  +       
    (  |Y 
  D       !   |Y $ 
 $>   (  |Y 
          $   ,   
        , $Q |Y (      $Q             !     + |Y (    !$        $       D     
  !$   8     ,

$Q |Y          
 |Y 
            D  +  /      

  
 
      
   %&  $ >   -66A;-  O            O |Y    , O  R0c    , 
 ,    0 |Y " O 8 
              0        /                    0  
   
     
   |Y O                          
   
    
   <=

c
   



 



      

   
  /     % ,            & |Y    #%     & mY       lY        ,   /     O          
             lY 2           


   
      "         
  
 
 mY          lY          

             

"  lY c                

 
    R8  lY    +        

     
           

,     0 !  |Y '               O     
 
   , 

92%

 /  

 ,    & c   |Y O         $    !      $     !         
    %!$˜$&1 

    "  |Y c         O  8      

D    O    >     +              

      |Y
  " 8    -  0*  

/    0          O   |Y    ,   

  D

 ,     D       ,          D  ,      8

 ,  |Y        O       " $
E;<c0044A

<<

c
   



 



!     )   *  
  $      O        O |Y  !)*$           
                    O      % 


& |Y  !)*$ 
 >   
                         0            ,   
  "         0 2    8  !)*$        CM  !)*$N      
 O    0C !  |Y       !)*$     
  O       9  %28    /       !)*$     
          &    
    
          B     O       "    |Y O/                 O     %    
& |Y           ,                 %     , & |Y O
,       D'  :D O , ,   , D      !)*$DO         
               .            c   |Y !     )   *  
 $  !)*$       
 
  
 "          "              /    |Y $
 $
                      |Y O      "0 0  8     
   c ! |Y " $
/    "   8             ,     !)*$ |Y '$
      
8      |Y   "   
c
   



 



|Y O     
              
    O        
   
          /   


 ! 
  O, O, -666E46 c           

     O |Y c                
      8  
 
       8 8                           /    
                   

 /      8      8  
            |Y       
    # mY O        
          9%   .                        &0 lY       8          8   
 mY ! 8       
  
  .          9 !  |Y        
 

            9:  c   |Y O  '   (
 0  '      = , 0 O      ,      8       ,  ,      0 |Y    <   |Y           ,   


 

    (
      

      
      |Y '  /  

 O    ,      I-6*D     .    D |Y     ,         
  

 


c
   



 



|Y      /      , D  º      
                    
            ,       ,   c 
c 
-666E43  /          O |Y 5                       

 |Y                   
,     !  |Y                  8        92 )) |Y    

          
       c   |Y       3   D

    D      
     /     D   
   $!H-063 |Y       
  
   O  $ 
3

|Y  7   
     mY     mY c 
         mY ' ! 
    |Y  7       1
" 
$ 
|Y !  / .       8      |Y ˜.  mY :        -              
  $ mY O      
         
       82˜

<;

c
   



 



mY !                   
   ,    lY ˜  

+     ,     $2$ (:
1`,``2V



A 3
3

+;0
 "  
*

1
|Y )   mY  
    
    mY " $ $!    mY    |Y $
 mY       mY    |Y        $     |Y 3  
 mY )     mY .     lY $  =   mY )
ÿ1

+;0

!50
1

$8


$  $      |Y $ $ mY O     
    lY .      |Y )      mY        8    . mY '     
   lY $ 00 88! lY c      .     
  %      +& |Y    
 

<4

c
   



|Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y |Y

 



) 
  $    
  $8  8  8    $
    
 5     ,               !    
   c  .      


|Y $ $   mY      lY )     
 
     `
>
# 5!
4
  

$

+;7
|Y !) +  |Y  )   mY $. 
 8     
 3        mY             
    
       |Y ) mY  
  mY 
  lY º 8   |Y 

  $#       
                                  
      
        `
>
# 5'
 *

$
3
  
 3
|Y !    )
   
    |Y !      
 G mY ,   .  
  mY ,     
  mY            mY 

 E44 |Y 5  
   $! mY 5            E6

c
   



 



|Y †  

    mY 5  
     
    8 
      
1 
  
$
$
*
$

055

$     8          8    
             0 $      
       8 ,         8  
    0 $         8
,    8           8,       8
      0  !! -666

       7
    %!    8  A63        & O |Y $
 .    
   D           /      
 8           +     
   
        I= DI-0<    !  c   |Y    ) # .
    |Y       

|Y $       
        2      
     8    <S  
 8 =4S    ,  |Y O    
   
     |Y 


º$4;4A6E )  )     %.        & O |Y c          )  )8   )
  8  . 8 .  |Y          c $ 

E

c
   



 



mY $       )         

    )
    )   )
      D  
         > 
       /      +   .     D   8      , 
           
  !  |Y $   '  
 

      ,   8     ) c   |Y )  
  
%
 &  , 
  O ,D  / 
8     
 D
   
  D , 
    ,     O    
 D ,        
 )
 
 )
  !     -66;2˜;4  )  )     D+     D 
    O |Y )  %  & /          D                        D     @+    /       O ' mY O   '      + D       /    
      
 8     

 
  mY '         >  )8     

  
               .  

 .         
 8      8      
   @+    /      .  |Y   8       8
     |Y è         
    
8      
     .     D        
 @   .      / !  |Y             O/     )   =66
 
          9            9:  c  

E-

c
   



 



|Y O    
 +
     '         
 O/    -
   O/    
 |Y  -=  D  D    

 D O                
 D          %    3& |Y  T-O/   
     |Y O '   /     
D         

 
       D    /  ,c 
D |Y O '              
D O     D'/    D
         /   D      .   +    D   
D    D'    !

1
$
A 
 c c  !44=A64 c   .     O |Y                        .  
   |Y             (        'D 
  +  .         |Y .             ,    
               .     !  |Y                         9  c   |Y '                      D
           |Y c     A |Y  
 8     D =      D '   

,    D      D |Y '     8  8   8 
  
8    O/    8    
       # |Y ) 
   
 
  E3

c
   



 



|Y ,      
  |Y  
   
=-664  E  ) 
) 
 !44A3        %
     
 
  
D     
   &    >    
 
      |Y    ,  mY !   
    +          mY !        
 mY O  
           8 
         
  
     
    O |Y      ˜       %                                 


     |Y c  .      /        
                  
   mY    
        ,       8     , 
       8    8   
         8   8   |Y ) 
   ,  ˜)       
 
 
   !  |Y            )9 c   |Y  3   D 
  O                   D '   )         ˜D 
 8O  D    D |Y '  ˜+ D 
, 
   5    $ 

   # |Y $  S                  2˜ |Y ˜     E=

c
   



 



|Y c 8     8   8          7       


   |Y  8  
  
    
     
     # mY    % 
         
 & mY c        lY !) 
;6S       lY 2     ) lY 2  |Y '      8 O               , , :44A4         %    & O |Y : 0    cB            

  )B  8           
     8 8  8
     +   .    0 |Y                  D                 
            
     ˜    |Y                    

   8            
             .   8          .    0˜ 8        
        
        /         !  |Y ":   8         8 
  
         
    
         8       
  
 9:  )) |Y !    8 )0) c  
   8          )/         8                  
      

E<

c
   



 



  0˜     8 
 ,     

     
  .    0 c   |Y )   

   A  0(     8

           0  ) 
 
   
 0  c  
    )/        6     
 8  
  
 8            
 
            
         |Y ) ,     
 8      +
             .        /   0 |Y $   8)/    -A< 
  
  
 0
2/ 2/ A-
 )     
    O |Y $                        ) 
                    7  7    8 
   7
      
  
 
  #

"  


1 
 |Y $             
              |Y '          |Y ˜
 Y mY        .    A-3 mY !         
   D  
       )   mY             (446A-     
   
 O |Y º
   
 

 @ /

EE

c
   



 



c   |Y (            )     .      |Y O8    
  º 
º 
-66;4E  '       9 O |Y      
          .    
     
   8               
  8       
 0) 
    8 
 8          0  '

$

2
1
`*
|Y )    
     
   
 0   0c     |Y * #     
   9 |Y ! # mY       lY              
 lY !     mY    lY c
    
   
     lY   / 
      lY  
   
  
, 3 
|Y 5  mY '    /      |Y  7  mY       
 
  |Y  mY '    
              
 

EA

c
   



 



|Y  7
  5  )   # |Y $  mY )  5 %)5& mY               @      /    mY c            
            mY T       
           mY                   7 

    mY ˜ejected by 4ourt as unfair |Y $ -1   % & mY ˜ +     

mY           0  4;;0A-A $   

        ) O |Y      
 
    |Y              

              
        
    H;7-6%& |Y           

      

        

 |Y               B       )   
      

    0 !  |Y $      

                
           
 8

)9  c   |Y O      

          
  |Y !    8    
 
     8 +         % 
&

E;

c
   



 



|Y                |Y $     

                  
    
                    
         
        
            B         

                       

    
     $ , 4;AA-=  7    O |Y             +         7       
   0 |Y "    , ‘Y  Y YY Y  

   
,           
   0 |Y ˜ 8        +      Y  Y Y   Y  Y 
 Y  Y
‘Y Y‘Y  YY  Y 8   

             
    |Y %c
 8  /       8           / ,      & 








*
9
  
9
 

|Y      
         |Y          mY c      7     mY     .   ÿ1
!57
  

0!


E4

c
   



 



|Y ) 
      
%    =-6& |Y álimony only if: mY 0      ,                 D$ mY -0 !        
            ,   
 |Y )  mY $ %H 36A/         &    encourage use of property division rather than alimony 
             |Y !            
   
8 ,          8 +     
     8 
 
          " $   =     %   A373-& mY c        ,
   mY 
    .            
 
  mY   
  mY     mY $  
          ,D  mY $     


      
    
         ,
    `
' 5'
 
)* 

ðrimary 4aretaker¶s
 


 
)  
mY       
            
   
       mY )
   /     
  %  
    
 8      
  /          ,   &   # mY ) 
     
  

   
  /              mY O2'2$"$ mY 6 
 8'/  , A , mY $ ,   
    mY '      
 mY '          lY     $!D        
0  O 
606- A6

c
   



 



mY    lY                 '   
      lY     
 |Y %06-&%A&G60= |Y %60=&%-666&GI-;6
  |Y c   9$!  /  0     0  `
' 5#
))

ÿ)
. (` 
$2ÿ

0!;
mY ) 
 
  @              
        
       . .  mY $ 
     ;  .       mY   # mY c  #
  E8EEA-<66
  lY  =8EA mY c   -#        G % 
 &% 0        & lY      - lY %=8EA&%%;&%606&&  *
8

#
 

  
*


mY ˜
 
                    %) 
&   . mY º     
  
                 %, & . mY 
           .            $!<06< mY !
         
        %$!<06=& $!  @   
  
 & 



*
$& &(


0+#
mY  mY   mY ˜    mY      mY ˜     mY 
   c  2     A

c
   



 



mY ˜  
  mY )      *8
) 

!   ' $4;;A3-       D      O mY          


           D  
       
  mY O            $     %   A33&         in any amount and for any period just and reasonable,              
   A33 %º2 O˜" O!  $$: !  2 J$  ) : )& mY        mY     mY 2        mY     mY $               
 
    
      mY $       mY       D  mY 2       
+  .  mY è%
     ,   8    & !  mY              
   
    

          
   9  20  '       
      A67
 
 0 )) mY              
 8       8     0  c   mY  
A6
  D       
  <;
      D  
  
  -        D   
  ,D /    
D  D    G   
0 mY    
 8 , 8        A-

c
   



 



   544=A3=      ˜   $
 

   )
 $
%  
    & "   
   
  
     O mY O         
 . >  /       !
     mY . >
    mY O  ,    

  mY $   /      
  &      .                                  %  15 0044=& &   
   

,          
 7     >      % &D      '    
  &    #  )   
     
    
 
, .   7            0  !  mY         0'   9 c   mY -6  DO   -*
 0O  /      
 D  O     ' 
          mY      # mY %&c    
 
  mY % &             
8 
                   

   
 0 mY %& $ 
            
 

,               mY %&   8               8     
 8 
  
     mY %&$' 8             0   
             

  
 8              0

A3

c
   



 



mY %&   8 
   
 


         
      8                        ÿ1
!+
*
 

0'!
mY O   mY   
            
, 
Y‘  A<3 mY           
   
  ÿ1
!+
$
1
mY   , 
  mY    +    +
   mY 0c  mY 
      2˜
    
   mY "        º 
º 
0044A<3 $
   
  # 
 O mY $
    %O
   &      
                       /          
  mY         
 !  mY            7    /   

          
     
    +      9:  )) mY          
8  8     


         c   mY -6  
 D   E-<,
D   
 


 -<<*   /$   /$   44EA
c
   



 



     

      O mY   
    
     7 # 8 
  
           
            8 
  
         
         
               0 mY O8   
  8                           8     


   
                   0  ˜
   +
      /  , 
       
 0%    3<6       66& !  mY )      
            +  
0      9 0˜ 0 )) mY     /  
   
  mY $        mY                 mY c .     
  E66 lY              66,   I3<6 lY $      8  8 
         


   


   
                0// c   mY             
        8   8  
    
  O  
        
                 2    O       %&Y          >       
                      0 
 0
 8;=4)0-64A%2, 0$044-&%         
   B        A<

c
   



 



    8 
      &D !     8 ;-< )0- 6; %  0 $0 44& %            
    8          &D  0  8=;$0-=6 % 04;6&%   B                 &0  `V( VV) 8

ÿV` 1
$(V 
$
0+;


 

 $ 4AE  AE4  
,) 
 1"
8    %$
  
         =-& O mY 0  
                 

    8               
                
       
       0 mY -0!       
 8   
  ,        
            B      0 mY 2#    
                      ˜    L  
     
                .    0  L$      
        

                

          
        0  L $    .     
    C C C  
  C  
         , 8        
     
         C C
       
        8   C  
 C          0 L$    
      B                   8    

      

      0 |Y $                     
   

AE

c
   



 



                     0 !  mY '            9 2 )) mY        I6=8666       C      C     

      
   7  

 I30E
 8                   c   mY    7 
   %         
&0      
8     
   
               B  
 

     0 mY $  8    
   8 7,               
  0 $       I;33
         

  
       0 '  
  ,  8   
0 mY O      0    
    

,    3

$ *
 *
mY $                          /   mY )   / 
     +     /               mY    
           
       mY  8                     
  mY !  5$))9  mY !
        9     9        ,   
       
      mY              .      `
+ 5!
1*
$ 

00;
AA

c
   



 



mY  +   *     > 
 mY    

  
 $!
,      mY 

 A; mY            
    *  mY O     
  
 
              lY    *        mY   .  
     mY
      mY !     
 lY  
 $ lY      E063%& |Y 3     
%A& lY   

        

      
   
%-& |Y   %=& %<&  `
+ 5+
)* 
$ *

1*
$ 

07

*

$ *
) 
   O  ˜!-663AAE )
               % 
      & O mY            
 0                        0       
         0  )       
 
       >     
   
         0 !  mY $  
  )
  ˜!
 9 mY '     
  
 9 lY  0  O   ,       8      
      8 + 
0 mY ˜   +     
  lY O   
    D ,  
      
  , D

A;

c
   



 



,        D      
  
  
   mY  
  
       
  lY         
 
        

       lY '        c   mY -3    D    D     
      mY º )
  O  0 O    0 0O,      0   0O   0O 0     0  )`1
ÿ$$2(
 " 



;7#


" *

1
)
  *
mY             
     
          $c       
      
       mY   

 
        
  mY ( 
       

     
  .  

)


 3*

$ 

;0#
mY ˜     mY      !                      mY 2+   mY ˜     mY O
           mY 
          
 ,  !

)

*
**
mY    
,         $c mY     
         +   

 
    #

" *


;77
mY ˜.         mY ˜

 
  

A4

c
   



 



mY $     
       
3
A 3
'

(



mY 0!
    mY 33  '$A;3 mY )           S
 mY   lY *    
          
  

    mY       lY $
) ) lY  
S        lY $   
   lY )   
      S     mY -0)  !
 mY =   A;= mY )  )
  lY 5 
,  |Y 
-6S  ,8<6S UE |Y !   A467 - mY 30    c 
 %   =-& mY 3  A;= mY º  lY     /   
   lY ,     
  lY )    
         `
 
mY          

 
  
               mY         lY 0  )        =S    
 
 2 lY ) A6S ) ==S lY )  A6S=S8 ES  
 lY )   ==S=S 34S  
 mY c   
        

S  
     ,       
  
  4;4A;= ;6

c
   



 



           ,   !
 
 $ $  ! O mY                 /           ( 8       /      O  mY 

  
    8  
       
   !  mY O        /  !   ,  

     

8              9 c   mY  
    mY          mY    ,                   
,     .  mY O  ) 3, 8c 
  mY c  ,8      -,  mY              ,8          O mY O  ( 
8   8(      mY O 
 8  8  O         

  mY O    
  

  

 D    (         

8   

   

0   0 mY             D   

   
       (    O  

         mY           O 8  
   ,8        8   8  8     8      0  !     !4;4A;;   5       ˜!O " $H364%3&A;= O

;

c
   



 



mY     7      -6    B  
 I368666   8     7 7     C
     
 
 $
  8C 
            
    
 0 ˜    mY !    8        8      

       
    
  

        BD ,    

           D      +    Y ‘Y  Y Y  Y  ‘   Y Y 

 Y   Y‘
 Y Y  Y YY  Y  Y   ‘  mY $   .
         B     8        .  
                 
 0C  
c$Q44A4

    /  .      8            
  O mY                  

     
 D              mY $                               %        
       & !  mY ! $>                        92     
  9 c   mY c%&  % 
& 
 +       mY !$Q
       ;     
  8   4      *)44<A4=    .
           O

;-

c
   



 



mY                                  )    0                         
   0 mY  #
  .        mY ˜ ˜#            
    !  mY                   

        .              
        )

 
ÿ1
!+

0'4!
mY              
,  
      mY           
   
   mY 
 
  mY   
  
                )

*
 
3
 
mY !
    mY ) 
    
               mY  
    mY (       . 8         $   $   5446A4;    
       . 
           O mY   
  # 8    8       
 %  /    & mY  ,      ,   / 
, %         D   =-3& mY         8       >     7      
 
 mY º  .  mY !     ;3

c
   



 



mY =econdary family obligations are voluntary and generally not considered in establishing child support in this state.$
                                0$           
                
 
     %    /  
  /        8             0        & mY                 /           
     D          /                
  
 D
            0 !  mY '         
    7       . 
  0:  mY =tate statute  A44      @ 8    8        
  c   mY !   8  . 
 70Y mY                           #  8  O
 8    , 8 5
 0 0   O  $      9 mY (            
   
                         
  mY ˜        
  
         
          
  D 

   8,     .         mY +   ,            mY    ,       ,           
,        

 mY c    .    /  
  +          mY   
          mY $             
            ;=

c
   



 



mY $   #   
     lY       /  
          8   
    . D


      
   



$Q444;6= 5  
 
    è
      9 O mY º               8           
   ! mY $   
      
        
   
                     
 D       
D mY     
             
 ;6<   !  mY '             
   )/         , 
c  9%         
 &          
        
       9=ee factors considered on pg 806 balancing   ,        8   ,      
 
    /         0 )) mY      
                        
      $Q  D           +      
                , D      D                     D
, 
(* 

**

mY º     #     8     mY    #     mY ! 
   #                    )$4;-;6A )          
   ;<

c
   



 



     %     ,  ,& O mY        0 /            
      


 


 
     D 

     .      
                .     ,       D     @    /      +       8    /    
     mY cactors considered mY $ 
   mY $     .        mY $.          mY )           
 !  mY      
      
 ,       , 
               7      9 )) mY $       /        4    D   
  8       DD     ;
         
8      E ,  D     


Dtrial court said she had a right to be a stay at home mother  

 (4;=;64

             .  %         & O mY : 8       
      D               !  mY        .    
             
  7,            9       
   9 mY ! 8 
  
                 9 )) ;E

c
   



 



mY $    .    
      D           D 
    c   mY  
 8 ,  '        
 A  0O    
D  (     !$-66-;< "
        O mY       
D      .             mY        ˜$!2$ !  mY       
      ,   ;D          
        
  D     )        
        /        9 )) mY        
              D      D c   mY   ,     
 D   ' "       E D-66A8 6 "
  D  ,
    D   9 O mY =                         D 
          
      ˜$!2$ $ !      DD    /          
                !  mY !   !)  $       )  = 9 )) mY    
   c˜)-E8     
D 
"  c   mY '          $  00  D             D !   D mY )        
      D ;A

c
   



 



 5  5  " 4
 D    cc  5/        

12 (`)
,`2 V)

;

).
+ '5 55
 


*

       !/     
$
2

.
 

#&#
mY     mY $ 
          
 %       & mY 
   mY ˜   .
  mY c  
.
  mY          ;;

c
   



 



lY )   2 )2 lY  $  $ mY $  
  mY      .
  mY 5    mY
  E6  
   
                7
       


     mY  
   mY     %
 & mY ˜  .
 8      .
      mY ˜   %   & .

 3/
mY E  8        mY                8      8         (  
`**

*
1

` 
(
`**
|Y   
  %
    )8˜ ˜& mY      mY  
   
     mY  
 

   mY 5  
 -;3 mY  
   -;- |Y   ˜ 
    mY º      mY ˜ ˜ |Y 5 '  |Y $
     mY    mY c   
     lY c       
 ' lY 5 D  .

  
 
|Y   /   >            %    , 8     8     +&

;4

c
   



 



|Y      
     3    %  
         &   - 
.*B
*
 ) O
$44E-;4 7  


/  
 )  
            '  -4= O |Y

 '
/  
                 
    7   |Y ˜     8   


 |Y 4ourt distinguishes perfect and imperfect defense mY 
              - 
 lY $          ,  D +    mY !
   lY ˜  
-
 lY $    ,   |Y c       % +   & mY èc 
  

      +8     
 !  |Y ! 


/  
     7  

  
   ,          9 : 8   |Y  O   8      

       7      9 |Y (
   
                  
        
 ,  c   |Y O   '   0  ' , O     D      
   83  8 
   
8  <   |Y O    ˜0 

%   &44;-4<

46

c
   



 



'   ˜)      O mY     

 

    .   
  +     ˜)    7  mY (  +       '        
   
   /      


,

!5#
mY )   2 )236= mY  $  $ mY ) 
  D
     
 .     mY ) $ lY $ 
,          lY      


     


     
  lY $    /        D             mY   $ lY !       
  

 lY   lY $      


    -66<36E )   2   7   O |Y    
            #     ,            
 

 , 
  8 
           ,
 
, |Y    )2       
    
        

           

 
 

        
 !  |Y '            
    
          9 %       

4

c
   



 




 &                92 c   |Y O 'D'     #O
        '        
D     D 6    8 3     D  02 0 0-66= 36 ˜.
                      O mY 2                

                    .   mY è2 
  8 ,     
    , 8

   
 D     
    mY è              mY c                       % .     & mY    
      mY       mY .           mY !         
      8     
     
        mY            

 
     8
        
         0  $8            
    
 @                        > mY      2         .       !  |Y  )   
                 
    8     
       9 |Y '    )         /              
)9 )) mY $ )   2          c   4-

c
   



 



|Y A  < D       D  )2    D   D  
       -663=     $ )   2% ,   & O mY º 
 
   8       8         .           ˜    mY           


  .      
         
      !  mY '                    
     / 
8   8   

 ,   

      0:  c   mY "
   D

     , D   

    ,D
           ,         
 
)`1
ÿ$$2(
V"2)  V(

 
'&#
 )

 
mY $     mY º       % & mY        mY    mY         mY " $3E#             
        mY  . 
 mY "          
   mY "    
         /      .) 4 0-66-8;3 43

c
   



 



          

D˜ ˜ O mY `nternational travel is not a fundamental rightD     D         D   < 

                      D               8% <*& !  mY !           
             ,     9 )) mY              0$
   0 c   mY  .         /         
   %-6*&D    + D      /       8                    mY                OO 8   8                            .        '   2 ,'!-66;3=         
, D     O mY                            D                 D                      D      mY 
            D               8        
> ,  mY !        
  D            
       8  +                  mY    
   D  D      !  4=

c
   



 



mY     /  % &                                , 9 :  )) mY                    



 
          , 8      + 8      c   mY     4 , 8 =

8           D      c2: mY        
        
             D         ,  
     D        O, c ," 4;;;34     "        
   
  O mY $           
                  mY $        8      8              
    
  D                    D      
  
      
           mY O8              

       ,    0  !    8              )    0 5    
   


  !  mY !       
      8         9!   )         

 8     
   
9 mY !    
 999
   
     

        9 )) mY      c ,        , D  8   
  D      D 
        
       
    D     + 8 

   
, 
 D  
 )    D      8    /  D   "  4<

c
   



 



c   mY O        D    D        
   "     844A;=- !   
            %˜ $& O mY $
 
                  
 D mY      
                .                   @  /     

D                            7 
  !  mY !  ˜ $           /    



  8 º$
           !     92 mY   ˜ $   6 

      
  
         92 

   mY    mY $                   

 mY $      
    
        

      

  mY $                8       8  

 mY  #  

                
    
    

 
   
 

    )) mY c               A<*D      +       
º  D ! 

 +    >   
 D  .    +      <66
 D !      366,0O/ 0 mY   "    
        ˜$D             8 <           ,   
  
    + -     4E

c
   



 



mY            D     

            c   mY     ˜  $  % ˜$&                       D

             mY '    ,D    <* 
     mY      
    8     /      
 8    

 mY     ,A<* ,   D    8

'&'

'0



  
. )   $    mY !        mY  
     mY     lY       lY c
    mY           3    )     mY !       mY  
     mY            5 <4

     )

  
 
%  /   & O |Y     )  = 

 D         
  D
  D  
   |Y $       )= 

  !  |Y !    )      
     9  !      
  9: 0!    )   9:  )) |Y       
         D 
   D c   4A

c
   



 



|Y 5$  
   
       
  |Y  5$   
    5$ |Y '     8  -<  8   
     |Y     )       ,        
  
   Q  ,˜ '!4A;E-   /  
           
 

  
 
%  /   & O |Y     
    
   D            
            
,     /     |Y "7   

          
   
 8     |Y )    (
8
|Y '                     
   8                    
            

         E< |Y                    .  
 do not .     c
 << |Y 4lassification here interferes D`˜ 4
 and ==
á
`á with the right to marry

   |Y 

     ˜    |Y      D


      ,     D      |Y )      
    

            
,   
        !  |Y ! .'!          / 
8  )  )   9:  4;

c
   



 



c   |Y '     
,             
8  8  +      
        
      ,       
  |Y 
     
 
     4;A( 2/  A

    ‘
 ‘Y      #     $Q  ,   O |Y c  ! D         |Y                      #       
      D !  8          

  |Y ˜         D
 
       
  
 D !
  
        
D          
 
            
  D |Y 
    
   ,  !  |Y '           
  


   
   9 mY )            %     &      
          
  c   |Y    
   
 
   
 
       D   
   
  !   A= |Y c            mY            mY    
      
 mY '   8       

   
   
  +  >    mY        
   
 

44

c
   



 



 O0º " 4;4   A= O 
      9 O |Y   
     
              D 
          D            |Y O8     .             8  
 
    D                           
   D  
    
  >
                            |Y             .                        |Y      .              @
      
D           8 +  

     %     
 &D             |Y           D          
                  
,  
  
 !  |Y !  $                       
 
  8       9  :            8      8     8        /   |Y                      8   O '    8         c   |Y   8
8
º 828
 $D             |Y        8  O0 |Y O   85  0   / º           8        
  D$   
 |Y º 
  :   D    $ |Y        0
8   ,     |Y     $    

   |Y ! 

    º :8    8  

 

$ 66

c
   



 



|Y         †                  |Y º     
   ,D                      |Y         8  

    |Y   
  , º     
,  |Y º    
         |Y   $       
       
(  


  



`
  446 0;3 O   / 
%'/ 
 O      & O |Y O 7        D |Y )      ,             |Y       $              
            |Y                      A6-      !  |Y !                                    92 c   |Y  
  4;3D 
   4;=D          
 +
  |Y O ' 
       %  &D        D  
          |Y                     
 8  
     ,   8  
         |Y  7   7          8             
    , ,46!  ;4 6

c
   



 



˜       
   O |Y  
   
                    !  |Y !  
   ,   /         9   8  9!         9 c   |Y , ,8  8     |Y   
     =,   3
 


, 44- (       =7E    
         
   
   ˜ ˜ O |Y )       .
               /  
         
     ,  8     +
    
, 
    
           .  |Y   
      
         0   
          0  ˜     

    
     |Y                                  |Y   <%     & ˜ ˜ |Y  
    
  !  |Y          ) 9 |Y )            
      
 E1; 
 =1;
         |Y c  = E   +     c   |Y         
D

 / 
          6-

c
   



 



        "-66<66 ) 
      O |Y  
    
                   ,     |Y ˜         

      "  !  |Y !  
        
        $ c   |Y '    ,    |Y "  
   |Y "        .       +     
,  
     44A" 6< ) 
     O |Y       
                           D  !
       D
        !    !  |Y   ,
                       
  c   |Y   ,
 
     |Y '    +     
     8         D         

 *

*  

*
'&0
    


 
     


 9      9     9' /         9  V B
$

.<
`

!5


63

c
   



 



: 8                /  +   
          
          1

  

12
o state, territory or possession of the = or tribes shall be required to give effect to any public act etc respecting a relationship b/w persons of the same sex that is treated as marriage under the laws of other state or right or claim arising from such relationship $            
    '  %
 &  $     c     ,   
 c   .   > 
 D 2 $8  8       c    
         /   >
      , 
    c   

  .   >
 
  
   D 

   
     
              0  ).
+ 5; #!5
 
$ 
 
 
$ )˜ 2 '!O 'O2  O O! ˜ !  $ $(2˜!: 2c O !  O$ 2!c: 5˜: 2O˜ )˜ 2 !! 2 ˜ !!$ !  2˜ 5! !!2 '!O O O! "˜ $ 2"˜2˜˜!cO)˜ 2! 2˜2$  ).
+ 5; #5
(
 
 
%&$ other than a parent
                
 
     8     8 
       
).
+ 5 +5
, 
 



-`)
%3& $  
                   
 8     
  8     0     
              
   !       
  

   "        mY          6=

c
   



 



mY     #                         mY        mY          
 mY    , 
     mY ˜   
   
 

   )   mY O
   ?    %    

  & mY   8  
    +           
        2   mY O       ?       
  
   


        mY ˜  ?      mY       mY    mY )   2   ˜ #!   mY ˜                 
  8  88  ?     mY ˜                      
  mY 2                           †    
 
   º   )O   64-6636E
 
 D˜ ˜% 
    + & 3    
 %     & O mY        %    & .    
  
è     %      .   & mY "8 
         /      
 
  
 
 %   &       mY      
"  6<

c
   



 



mY  "  
    
          

 
        =$  "                      
             
  B      
  0 mY ˜ 
          
       /    mY       
       .   mY 2 è            
     
 
 
 !  mY ' 8            8

  
       8           
        
    
92 )) c   mY =  8<   8   

è    mY  



 ?      ?  
  ?,      !    $-66; 6%=73&

    c˜   /   )                $
57
O mY 0                         +       mY -0           
   
 
     7               
7     
       
7     

 mY 2#ðrop 8 does not disturb that part of the court's holding that gay men and lesbians constitute a =uspect 4lass for purposes of equal protection $ 0!HA !    6E

c
   



 



' $,"  0 0c -66<- 2 $ c˜       @
       8 

        +         D   )     c˜            è         )  
     $ ;         O mY O     
     c˜8           >         
    
 D        D      mY     c˜8        mY ˜ ˜#    
 
 mY
       8 mY      mY $    )    cc  
        
,    D !  mY $ 2 $  c       /  >    
           cc8) ) = 8

)!   

   "  )) c   mY    
   ' cc     2 $9  
    ,0  0º      0
 
      =          8   
  0    
º 0  '  
  ,º 9         8 
  /   "˜ ˜         /) ' ,!0º   0   -66;M 36N  ,      

      
         
  O

6A

c
   



 



mY )              D      

    @ secure the benefits
 00   F  
  
 !  mY '  

                  
7 
    C C   C 
 C 
     
    
     
7      
  0:   `  
$
)  
  
            
    '    
,      0  !          +   ,  0    
    /  ,                       .        !        $ 
 *
  *

 

  
 
mY   #
                 mY 3    
 8008    mY $ 
  mY )    
  mY   ?     
  mY º          

) 
|Y            |Y             
  |Y $ 
 
  
          mY 
  
      lY 00  7 
     |Y $ 
 
        $4*  

$ 
*


6;

c
   



 



|Y )$ ) $    |Y '  
           |Y O      ,                    |Y O                9 |Y !
  
                     %  & 

 
                   /   8     O 8       
    8             /                 0O              *:446-6 ˜         
          %     
 &     O mY $    
    mY =pecial scrutiny .     D 
    
 
   
     mY 

        
 
     !  c   mY A<                  
         ,       
 % 

& mY O8    
     
,  
    
       
          mY  

IA< ,
  
    
  D   
   -    
          |Y !     @    / |Y  ,     
     |Y      A<          >   
  |Y          64

c
   



 



|Y  

         $ O !  c2˜ !  2"ºO8        |Y     
        /                    >   D      .
             
9  
  
 )$446-6=

      O mY        mY !    
V    mY )   / ,     /          +  +  mY "     .   


 % &                      mY    

 
       
     ) $ mY ) $               
   8 +     mY       
               
    77    mY '  
  ) $    mY         %  .  &9 0 mY   %     &9  8       8  

  0 mY 
$)D) $  !  mY ' 
  ) $   '             
    9:  )) mY      
     
    c   mY  %-3&
  %34& mY  
 8 46*   366*   mY $ ,  ) $  D      
      mY     /  ,     ) $       %   
    &  ÿ*
$


'

 

6

c
   



 



mY $                 mY )!!$"O2˜!: mY
   /   ) $     mY
    
 
          
     
 *
mY $
         
   mY     " $36E% & mY )    8 
8   8 8    mY ˜   

  mY )

   mY                mY   
 strictly scrutinize child-related issues under parens patriae mY         mY     
    +       *
$

è$
     è              
      è
          è!008   ?       > è  
         è) #     
          è77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777è     
       %   8 8    &   Don¶t forget predictability as discussed earlier re agreements =ee slide  $
1

  

ÿ1
!5+3
mY           
  9 

c
   



 



mY "      mY $ 
         
   mY "         lY '    9 |Y  ,  
  
 %

 & |Y   
  ,   
 
        
 $ |Y   ,      8  , 
 lY    
      |Y "  

      )
%
)
C
, 
ÿ1

|Y   D     |Y       9 mY '           |Y $" $H364       M

 N |Y ! $      mY     ,        mY         
    HH36A %      &836;%
  & 

         <-     

-