IL
RITORNO
DEGLI
DEI
ANTICHI
&DPSDJQDSHU/H[$UFDQD E\$OHVVDQGUR6DOD 4XHVWDqXQ¶DYYHQWXUDPROWROXQJDSDUWLFUHDWDSHUJLRFDWRULFRQXQDFHUWDHVSHULHQ]DSHUULFUHDUHDOPHQRYDJDPHQWH O¶DWPRVIHUDFXSDHPLVWHULRVDGHL0LWLGL&WKXOKXLQ/H[$UFDQDGDQGRFRVuDOFXQLVSXQWLQXRYL/¶DYYHQWXUDGLSHUVp DFTXLVLVFHDQFRUDPDJJLRUHVSHVVRUHVHJLRFDWDGDSHUVRQHFKHFRQRVFDQRTXDQWRPHQRXQSR¶TXHVWRFLFORFRVD QHFHVVDULDSHULO'HPLXUJR $OFXQLIDWWLFRPHO¶XRPRDOODVFHQDILQDOHVRQRVSLHJDELOLVRORSHU PDQWHQHUHXQDFRQWLQXLWjFRQXQD DYYHQWXUDSHU³,O 5LFKLDPRGL&WKXOKX´JLRFDWDGDOPLRJUXSSR7XWWHTXHVWHFRVHDSSDUHQWHPHQWHLQXWLOLSRWHWHRYYLDPHQWHWRJOLHUOH 1%/HLQIRUPD]LRQLULJXDUGRODFLWWDGL.XWXHTXLQGLOHSULPHSDUWLGHOOD&DPSDJQDVHFRQGDHWHU]DSDUWHVRQRVWDWH SUHVHGD+3/RYHFUDIW³1HFURQRPLFRQ´)DQXFFL(GLWRUH/¶XOWLPHSDUWLULJXDUGDQWLO¶(JLWWRVRQRLQYHFHVWDWH OLEHUDPHQWHWUDWWHGDXQ¶DYYHQWXUDSHU³,O5LFKLDPRGL&KWXOKX´VFULWWDGDOPLR&XVWRGH$OHVVDQGUR)RVVDWL ,QIRQGRDOO¶DYYHQWXUDFLVRQRSDJLQHFRQWHQHWLWXWWHOHPDSSHHLGLVHJQLGDGDUHDL&XVWRGHVDOPRPHQWRRSSRUWXQR 3ULPD3DUWH³,O9LDJJLR´
,3*ULFHYHUDQQRXQDOHWWHUDILUPDWDGDOVHJUHWDULRGHOO¶,PSHUDWRUHFKHFKLHGHORURGLUHFDUVLVXELWRDSDOD]]R 4XLYHUUDQQRIDWWLSDUODUHFRO7ULEXQR$UHOOLR)DOHUQRFKHVSLHJKHUjORURDJUDQGLOLQHHLOORURFRPSLWR GRYUDQQRUHFDUVLLQ6\ULDYLDQDYHHTXLLQFRQWUDUHLO7ULEXQRGL$QWLRFKLD*XJDODQQD4XHVWLGDUjORURLGRFXPHQWL QHFHVVDULSHUUDJJLXQJHUH%DE\ORQLDLQ0HVRSRWDPLDGRYHLO7ULEXQR*LOJDPHVKVSLHJKHUjORURHVDWWDPHQWHTXDOHVLD ODORURPLVVLRQH ,OYLDJJLRYLDQDYHGD5RPDD$QWLRFKLDGXUHUjJLRUQLHGDYYHUUjVXXQDQDYHSDVVHJJHULFKHIDUjVFDORD&RULQWXVHG (SKHVXV SHUQRQGDUHQHOO¶RFFKLRL3*VDUDQQRVRWWRPHQWLWHVSRJOLH LQWHUSUHWHUDQQRODSDUWHGLQRELOLDPDQWLGHL YLDJJLDYUDQQRLGRFXPHQWLHLYHVWLWLQHFHVVDULHQXOO¶DOWURFLRqQLHQWHVROGLDJJLXQWLYL 'XUDQWHLOYLDJJLRQRQDFFDGUjQXOODG¶LQVROLWRPDXQWLUR6HQVLELOLWDVDGLIILFROWjSHUPHWWHUjORURGLDFFRUJHUVLGL HVVHUHVSLDWLPDQRQqLOFDVRGLDJLUH ,QYHFHGD$QWLRFKLDD%DE\ORQLDYLDJJHUDQQRDFDYDOORQRQSLVRWWRPHQWLWHVSRJOLHHLOYLDJJLRGXUHUjJLRUQL GXUDQWHLTXDOLFLVDUjLOGLHVVHUHDWWDFFDWLGDEULJDQWLYHULIDOVL VLWUDWWDLQIDWWLGLDGHSWLGLFXOWLVHJUHWL FKHFHUFDQRGLIHUPDUOL %ULJDQWL YHUL '9 $GHSWL '9 5DWLR 6HQVLELOLWDV 5DWLR 6HQVLELOLWDV 'H%HOOR'H1DWXUD3XQWL9LWD 'H%HOOR'H1DWXUD3XQWL9LWD 'H &RUSRUH 'H &RUSRUH $UPL *ODGLXV $UFXV $UPL *ODGLXV $UFXV $UPDW UPDWX XUD /HY /HYLV LV/ /RU RULF LFD D $UPDW UPDWXU XUDD /H /HY YLV/R V/RUL ULFD FD 6FXGR 3DUPD 6FXGR 3DUPD 1HOFDVRGHJOL$GHSWLXQDSHUT XLVL]LRQH'H6RFLHWDWHGLIIS HUPHWWHUjGLQRWDUHVLPEROLVXLJODGLL DIRUPDGL WHQWDFROR 6HFRQGD3DUWH³.XWX´
$%DE\ORQLDLOWULEXQR*LOJDPHVKSDUOHUjGHOODPRUWHGLVROGDWLHGHOOD&RKRUV$UFDQDDYYHQXWDLQPRGR PLVWHULRVR WXWWLVRQRPRUWLQHOVRQQRLQSUHGDDIRUWLIHEEULHWUHPHQGHVRIIHUHQ]HGXUDWHDOFXQLJLRUQL FRPSLWRGHL 3*VDUjTXHOORGLVFRSULUHODFDXVDGHOODPRUWHLQTXDQWRVHPEUDSRVVLELOHXQDTXDOFKHFDXVDVRSUDQQDWXUDOH ,QGDJDQGRSUHVVRLVROGDWLFKHFRQRVFHYDQRLGHFHGXWLL3*YHUUDQQRDVDSHUHFKHWLUR'H6RFLHWDWHDGLIIXQD LQIRUPD]LRQHSHURJQLJUDGR 3URYHQLYDQRGD]RQHGLYHUVHHQRQVLFRQRVFHYDQRSULPDGLODYRUDUHLQVLHPH (UDQRJHQWHWUDQTXLOODHVFUXSRORVDHVLRFFXSDYDQRGLHVSORUD]LRQL 7XWWLHODYRUDYDQRFRPHJXDUGLHSUHVVRJOLVFDYLGLTXHOODVWDQDFLWWDGLQDVFRSHUWDVRWWRLOOHWWRGLXQILXPH 'DDOFXQLJLRUQLHUDQRXQSR¶DJLWDWLHSDUODYDQRFRQXQPLVWRGLSDXUDHGLFXULRVLWjGLXQDORURVFRSHUWDPDVHPSUH LQPRGRRVFXUR 8QRGLORURDYHYDXQDPDSSDRUDSUHVDGDXQVXRDPLFR,VLGRUR3ROLFOHWR 6HL3*QRQULHVFRQRDSURFXUDUVLWXWWHOHLQIRUPD]LRQLPDDQFKHVHFLULHVFRQRSRWUHEEHHVVHUHXWLOHFRQVXOWDUHOD ELEOLRWHFDGL%DE\ORQLD LQHVVDWURYHUDQQRGRSRDYHUGHFLVRSHUTXDQWRWHPSRFHUFDQRHDYHUIDWWRXQWLUR'H6FLHQWLDD GLIIFKHULFKLHGH¶¶SHURJQLJUDGRGLVXFFHVVR
XQEUDQRVXOODGLVWUX]LRQHGHOODFLWWjGL.XWX ³1HOD&ODFLWWjIXSUHVDGDJOL$VVLULHGLVWUXWWDDGGLULWWXUDIXUDVDDOVXRORHVXOOHVXHFHQHULIXPDQWLIXGHYLDWRXQ ILXPH7XWWRTXHVWRDSSDUHTXDQWRPHQRVWUDQRSHUXQDFLWWjVHQ]DDOFXQDLPSRUWDQ]DSROLWLFDQpVWUDWHJLFRPLOLWDUHFKH LQROWUHQRQHUDTXDVLSHUQXOODSUHVLGLDWDHODFXLXQLWDIXQ]LRQHHUDTXHOODGLRVSLWDUHLOWHPSLRGL.XWXVXPJDOQRWR DQFKHFRPH1HUJDOGLRGHJOLLQIHUL´ XQDVSLHJD]LRQHGHLFXOWLDVVLUREDELORQHVL 'LYLQLWj &RVPLFKH$VWUDOL&WRQLH 'LYLQLWjFRVPLFKH $1 GLRGHO&LHOR (1/,/ GLRGHOOD7HUUD (1., GLRGHOO¶$FTXD (UHVNLJDOPRJOLHGL.XWXVXPJDOqUHJLQDGHJOLLQIHULHVRUHOODGL,QDQQDUHJLQDGHO&LHOR 0DUGXNGLRVXSUHPRqILJOLRGL(QNLGLRPDJRSHUHFFHOOHQ]DGHOODFLWWjGL(ULGXLPSRUWDQWHO¶DFTXDEHQHGHWWDH VFRQILJJHJOLGHL&WRQLHOLSUHFLSLWDQHJOLDELVVL *OLGHLPDOLJQLVRQRFRPDQGDWLGD7LDPDWFKHFRQ$SVXUDSSUHVHQWDO¶DFTXDSULPRUGLDOHGDFXLVRQRQDWLLWUHGHL VXGGHWWLFKHKDQQRDEGLFDWRSHU0DUGXN ,OSDVVRRUDSLORJLFRqTXHOORGLUHFDUVLD.XWXDGLQGDJDUH
4XHVWDqODPDSSDFKHL3*SRWUHEEHURDYHUWURYDWRSDUODQGRFRQ,VLGRUR3ROLFOHWRHUDSSUHVHQWDXQD]RQDGHOOHURYLQH GHOODFLWWjDQWLFDPHQWHVRPPHUVD 7URYDUHLPRQXPHQWLLQWHUHVVDWLWUDODPDVVDGHOOHURYLQHGHJOLDOWULSDOD]]LULFKLHGHXQWLUR'H6FLHQWLDDGLIIR'H 1DWXUDDGLIIRSSXUHEDVWDFKLHGHUHDOOHJXDUGLHGRYHODYRUDYDQRLGHIXQWL 7HU]D3DUWH³/DVHWWDGHJOL'(,$17,&+,´
%
%
6XELWRVRWWRO¶LQJUHVVRFHODWRVLDSUH XQDVWDQ]DG¶LQJUHVVRFRPSOHWDPHQWHYXRWDPDGHFRUDW DDOOHSDUHWLFRQGLVH JQL URYLQDWLGDOO¶XPLGLWj SUREDELOPHQWHUDSSUHVHQWDQR1HUJDOFKHJRYHUQDO¶LQIHUQR'H6RFLHWDWHGLII (¶ODVWDQ]DFRQO¶DOWDUH GL1HUJDO.XWXVXPJDOGLRGHJOL,QIHULDQFKHTXHVWDVWDQ]DHUD ULFFDPHQWHGHFRUDWDFRQ GLVHJQLVREULPDOHGHFRUD]LRQLVRQRPROWRURYLQDWHVRWWRO¶DOWDUHVLWURYDXQDERWRODFRQXQDVFDODDSLROLFKHSRUWD VRWWR SHUWURYDUODVHUYHXQWLUR'H6FLHQWLDDGLII 4XHVWDVWDQ]DqOLHYHPHQWHSLFRQVHUYDW DGHOOHSUHFHGHQWL XQ¶LVFUL]LRQHVXOODSRUWDLQGLFKHUjLQEDELORQHV HFKH ELVRJQDSURQXQFLDUHDSUHQGRODSRUWDODIUDVHPDJLFD ³3K¶QJOXLPJOZ¶QDIK.XWXOXVXPJDO5¶O\HK:JDK¶QDJDO IWKDQ´ DOWULPHQWLVLVYHJOLHUDQQROHPXPPLHGHOODVWDQ]D SHUFDSLUHLOPHVVDJJLRVHUYHXQ'H6RFLHWDWHDGLII
,QTXHVWDVWDQ]DULSRVDQR PXPPLHFKHVLVYHJOLHUDQQRDOO¶DUULYRGH LQHPLFL FRVuIDFHQGRULFKLDPHUDQQR O¶DWWHQ]LRQHGHOOD.HUGHOODVWDQ]DFKHRUDVDUjSURQWDDGDWWHQGHUOL XQWLUR6HQVLELOLWDVGLIISUHSDUHUjL3*DO SHJJLR /DVWDQ]DqPROWREXLDHQHOFHQWURF¶qXQWDSSHWRFRQFDQGHODEULDFFHVL DWWRUQR VXWDSSHWROLDWWHQGHOD.HUFKH OLDWWDFFKHUj VRWWRLOWDSSHWRF¶qXQDERWRODFKHSRUWDDOODVWDQ]D'H6FLHQWLDGLIIOHSDUHWLVRQRULFFDPHQWH GHFRUDWHGLGLVHJQLWHUULELOL WUDWWDQRGHOULWRUQRGHJOL'HL$QWLFKL LGLSLQWLVRQREHQFRQVHUYDWL 4XLVLWURYDQRLQWHQWLDODQFLDUHO¶LQFDQWHVLPR³/¶XUORGL(UHVKNLJDO´VDFHUGRWLH DGHSWL VXOSDYLPHQWRGDYDQWL DOO¶DOWDUHVWUDQDPHQWHRYDOH F¶qXQDSODFFDHQRUPHULF RSHUWDGDOGLVHJQRGLXQJURVVROHRQHF RQWHVWDGLVHUSHQWH VRWWRVXRQDYXRWR ILQRDSHUVRQHSRVVRQRWHQWDUHGLDSULUORVRPPDQGROD9LJRUHSDVVDQGRXQWLURDGLII 6XOO¶DOWDUHFLVRQR'GRVLGLYHOHQRGDSRWHUXVDUHVXOOHDUPLHODVSLHJD]LRQHGHOO¶HIIHWWRGHOO¶LQFDQWHVLPR 'DTXLXVFLUjXQIHWLGRJDVQHURFKH VXELWRVLGLVSHUGHUjLQUHDOW jL3*KDQQROLEHUDWRORVSLULWRGL( UHVKNLJDO VRWWR WURYHUDQQROHRVVDGLIDQFLXOOLHXQWHVWRGHOO¶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³$OODULFHUFDGL,QIRUPD]LRQL´
$TXHVWRSXQWRL3*GRYUHEEHURDYHUFDSLWRFRVDKDSRUWDWRDOODPRUWHLGHOO¶LQL]LRSUREDELOPHQWHOHJJHQGRLEUDQL WURYDWLGRYUHEEHURDQFKHDYHUFDSLWRFRV¶KDQQRFRPELQDWR&RPXQTXHGRSRFLUFDJLRUQLOD]RQDLQL]LDDGLYHQWDUH SHULFRORVDLQTXDQWRPROWDJHQWHLQL]LDDPRULUHDOORVWHVVRPRGRGHL LQIDWWLOLEHUDQGRORVSLULWRGL(UHVKNLJDORGL TXDOFKHVXRVHUYLWRUHKDQQRGDWRLOYLDDOULWRUQRGHJOL'HL$QWLFKLVXOOD7HUUD /DSLDQWLQDSXzHVVHUHLQWHUSUHWDWDGDTXDOFXQRFKHVHQHLQWHQGDqVXIILFLHQWHSRUWDUODDOWULEXQR*LOJDPHVKFRPHXQD SLDQWLQDYDJDHDSSURVVLPDWLYDGL%DE\ORQLD VXGLHVVDqVHJQDWRFRQXQFHUFKLRXQD]RQDIXRULFLWWj 5HFDQGRVLTXLHRULHQWDQGRVLEHQH'H1DWXUDGLIIVLSRWUjWURYDUHO¶LQJUHVVRGLXQDJURWWD
PW PW
6XOIRQGRGHOODJURWWDVLWURYDXQDSLFFRODVWDQ]DFRQWHQHQWHXQD³VFULYDQLD´HXQOHWWR
6XOODVFULYDQLDVLWURYDQRJOLVWUXPHQWLQHFHVVDULSHUSURGXUUHLOYHOHQRPDQFDSHUzODPDWHULDSULPDHLQXQFDVVHWWR DSULELOHFRQ'H6FLHQWLDGLIIR9LJRUGLIIOHPDSSHGL2ULRQHHGHO/HRQHFRQXQEUHYHWUDWWDWRVWUDQDPHQWHLQODWLQR GHOODSURYHQLHQ]DGHJOL'HL$QWLFKLHGHLORURVHUYLWRULGD5HJRORQHO/HRQHFRQWHVWDGLWHQWDFRORHGHLORURQHPLFLJOL 'HL3ULPLJHQLGDOODVWHOOD%HWHOJHXVHLQ2ULRQH LQROWUHVLWURYDXQDSLFFRODVWDWXHWWDUDIILJXUDQWHXQDVRUWDGL6ILQJH FRQWHVWDGLWHQWDFROR ,QILQHWURYDQRLQXQDWDVFDGLXQDYHVWHDSSRJJLDWDVXOOHWWRXQRVWUDQRELJOLHWWRDSSDUHQWHPHQWHLQXWLOHLQTXDQWRVHPEUD XQIRJOLRVWUDFFLRULFRSHUWRGDFRQWL LQUHDOWjVHL3*DIIHUPDQRGLVWXGLDUORFRQXQWLUR'H6FLHQWLDDGLIIVLFDSLVFH FKHVLWUDWWDGLXQFRGLFHFLIUDWRFKHULFKLHGHJLRUQLJLRUQRSHURJQLJUDGRGLVXFFHVVRSHUHVVHUHLQWHUSUHWDWR1HOOD WDVFDWURYDQRDQFKHXQSLFFRORPHGDJOLRQHDIRUPDGLVFDUDEHRSUREDELOPHQWHGLIDWWXUDHJL]LDTXHVWRqLQUHDOWjOD FKLDYHGHOWHPSLRGHJOL 'HL3ULPLJHQLLQ(JLWWRYHGLGRSRFKHLFXOWLVWLKDQQRWUDIXJDWRSHUQRQSHUPHWWHUHFKH YHQLVVHURHYRFDWL ,OPHVVDJJLRGHOFRGLFHFLIUDWRVXRQDSLRPHQRFRVu ³XQDYROWDFKHDYUHPRHYRFDWRORVSLULWRGHOO¶2VFXUD6LJQRUDVDUjLOPRPHQWRGHO0HVVDJJHURFKHDWWHQGHQHOODVXD WRPEDGHWXUSDWDGDLVXSHUVWL]LRVLWRPEDFKHORUDFFKLXGHGDOO¶LQL]LRGHLWHPSL VRORDOORUDVDUjSRVVLELOHULFKLDPDUHLO 6RPPR3DGURQHGDOO¶RVFXULWjGL7LDPDW0DGUH6LOHQWH´ 1HOIUDWWHPSRVHDTXDOFXQRYHQLVVHLQPHQWHSRWUHEEHURFRQWUROODUHJOLDUULYLHOHSDUWHQ]HDOODIURQWLHUDHSDUODQGR FRQJOLXIILFLDOLVFRSULUHEEHURFKHO¶XQLFDVWUDQH]]DqVWDWDODSDUWHQ]DGLXQDGRQQDGLUHWWDLQ(JLWWRDFFRPSDJQDWDGD DOFXQHJXDUGLHPDVHQ]DDOFXQEDJDJOLR LQROWUHOHJXDUGLHHUDQRWXWWHGRQQH 6LWUDWWDGL(UHVKNLJDOFKHKDSUHVRSRVVHVVRGLXQDGRQQDHVLqFLUFRQGDWDGL$UDFQLGLHGL$PD]]RQL 6HDL3*QRQYHQLVVHLQPHQWHSRWUHEEHURSHUFDVRDVVLVWHUHDOGLVFRUVRWUDXQDJXDUGLDHXQVXRVXSHULRUHRTXDOFKH DPLFRDGXQDWDYHUQD ,QWXWWLTXHVWLJLRUQLL3*SRVVRQRIDUVLFUHDUHLOSXJQDOHFRQO¶XQJKLD FRVWHUjORURVHVWHU]LDWHQWDWLYR FRQVLGHUDUHXQDUWLJLDQRFRQ'H6FLHQWLDSDULD 4XLQWD3DUWH³/¶(JLWWR´
$TXHVWRSXQWRL3*GRYUHEEHURFROOHJDUHOHFRVHVFRSHUWHHGHFLGHUHGLSDUWLUHSHUO¶(JLWWRSUHFLVDPHQWHGRYUHEEHUR DQGDUHDOOD6ILQJH,OYLDJJLRPLJOLRUHqWRUQDUHDG$QWLRFKLDHGDTXLDUULYDUHYLDQDYHDG$OH[DQGULD 'XUDQWHLOYLDJJLRILQRDG$QWLRFKLDFKHGXUDFRPHDOO¶DQGDWDOHSUREDELOLWjGLHVVHUHDWWDFFDWLDXPHQWDQRDOHVL WUDWWHUjVHPSUHGLDGHSWL $UULYDWLDG$OH[DQGULDLOYLDJJLRYLDQDYHULFKLHGHJLRUQLHQRQD FFDGUjQXOODL3*GRYUD QQRUHFDUVLD*L]D SRVVRQR IDUORYLDILXPHJLRUQLVHVWHU]LRSSXUHDSLHGLJLRUQLDWWDFFKLFRPHYLVWRSULPD $UULYDWLDOOD6ILQJHGRYUDQQRWURYDUHO¶DFFHVVR ULFRUGDQGRVLGHOODFRVWHOOD]LRQHGHO/HRQHFDSLUHEEHURFKHO¶DFFHVVRq LQFRUULVSRQGHQ]DGL5HJRORF LRqVXOOD]DPSDGHOOD6ILQJH2YYLDPHQWHQRQSRWUDQQRDFFH GHUYLGLJLRUQRDFDXVD GHL ³WXULVWL´HGRYUDQQRIDUORGLQRWWH
1HOO¶LQJUHVVRULFFDPHQWHGHF RUDWRqQDUUDWDODVWRULDGLXQGLR/HRQHFRQWHVWDGLWH QWDFRORVLWUDWWDGL1\XUOQDPWDU LO0HVVDJJHURFKHSXzLQFHUWHRFFDVLRQLWRUQDUHVXOOD7HUUDFKHJRYHUQDVXOO¶(JLWWRSUREDELOPHQWHSULPDDQFRUD GHLIDUDRQLHGHOVXRVDF HUGRWH1HIHUWKRWHSFKHFRPSLYDSDUHFFKLVDF ULILFLXPDQLDOGLR ODVWRULDVLFRQFOXGHFRQOD PRUWHGHOVDFHUGRWHDYYHQXWDSHUPH]]RGLHQWLWjVXSHULRULJOL'HL3ULPLJHQLHFRQODIRQGD]LRQHGHOODVXDWRPED GDYDQWLD%HWHOJHXVHFRVuFKHSRVVDIDUODJXDUGLDDLVXRLQHPLFLFKHQRQWRUQLQRDGLVWXUEDUHLOVXRVLJQRUH&LVRQR DGHSWLGLJXDUGLD GHYRQRHVVHUHXFFLVLHQWURWHPSRUDRGDUDQQRO¶DOODUPH /DVWDQ]DVHPEUDYXRWD LQUHDOWjUDFFKLXGHXQDWUD SSRODFKHLQIOLJJHUj'GDQQLSHUIUHFF H qSRVVLELOHVFRYDUH ODWUDSSRODFRQXQ'H6FLHQWLDDGLIIHDOO¶LQL]LRXQ6HQVLELOLWDVDGLIISHUPHWWHUjGLPHWWHUVLLQDOODUPH ,QTXHVWDVWDQ]DYXRWDVLWURYHUjXQDPDSSDGLSLQWDVXOPXURGHOOHYDULHSLUD PLGL
8QWLUR'H6RFLHWDWHSHUPHWWHUjGLFROOHJDUHOHFRVH(JLWWR2ULRQH ,QTXHVWDVWDQ]DVRQRULPDVWHD JXDUGLDOH$PD]]RQLHOH$UDFQLGL6RWWRO¶DOWDUH F¶qXQDERWRODFKHSXzHVVHU H WURYDWDFRQXQ'H6FLHQWLDDGLII 4XLL3*DUULYHUDQQRDSS HQDLQWHPSRSHUDVVLVWHUHD OODFRQFOXVLRQHGHOO¶HYRFD]LRQH GDOSRUWDOHHQRUPHVXOPXUR XVFLUjXQDVRUWDGLIXPRLQIRUPHFKHHQWUHUjQHOODER FFDGHOVDFHUGRWHSUHVHQWHDVVLHPHDOODGRQQD DTXHVWRSXQWRL VHQRQGLVWXUEDWLDFFHQQHUDQQRDOIDWWRGLGRYHUULVYHJOLDUHLOVHUYR1HIHUWKRWHSHVFRPSDULUDQQRQHOQXOOD $PD]]RQL '9 3XWL9LWD'H%HOORKWK 'H%HOORIXRFR'H&RUSRUH $UPL *ODGLXV7R[RQ $UPDWXUD /HYLV/RULFD 3RWHUL 7LUR GHO )DWR
$UDFQLGL '9 3XQWL 9LWDX 'H &RUSRUHX 'H %HOORX 'DQQL 'H%HOOR3XQWL9LWD 'H6RFLHWDWHX'H&RUSRUH $UPL 9HOHQRGDGL $UPDWXUD 3HOOHFRUD]]DWD 3RWHUL 0HWDPRUIRVL
6HVWD3DUWH ³1HIHUWKRWHS´
6HL3*VRQRULXVFLWLDGDVFROWDUHLOGLVFRUVRGRYUHEEHURFHUFDUHGLFROOHJDUHOHLQIRUPD]LRQLDORURGLVSRVL]LRQH 4XHVWLFHUFDQR1HIHUWKRWHSFKHqVHSROWRDJXDUGLDGHOO¶DFFHVVRGHJOL'HL3ULPLJHQL *OL'HL3ULPLJHQLSURYHQJRQRGDOODVWHOOD%HWHOJHXVHGL2ULRQH &¶qXQDQRWHYROHVRPLJOLDQ]D WUDODGLVSRVL]LRQHGHOOHSLUDPLGLHODFRVWHOOD]LRQHGL2ULRQH 8QEXRQPRGRSHUIHUPDUHJOL$QWLFKLqGLULVYHJOLDUHL3ULPLJHQLSULPDSHUz ELVRJQDLPSHGLUHFKH1HIHUWKRWHS WRUQLDOODYLWDDQFKHSHUF KpHJOLYHJOLDLQPRGRGDQRQSRWHUIDUULFKLDPDUHL 3ULPLJHQL $TXHVWRSXQWRLOSULPRSDVVRGDIDUHqDQGDUHDFHUFDUHODWRPEDGL1HIHUWKRWHS %LVRJQDUDJJLXQJHUH³%HWHOJHXVH´FLRq ODSLUDPLGHLQDOWRDVLQLVWUDGH OODSLDQWD TXLVLSRWUjIDFLOPHQWHQRWDUH'H 6FLHQWLDDGLIIFKHODSLUDPLGHVHPEUD QRQDYHUHLQJUHVVL6HVLFHUFDODWRPEDGL1HIHUWKRWHSELVRJQDFHUFDUHQHOOD VDEELDSDVVDQGRWLUL'H6FLHQWLDDGLIIqSRVVLELOHIDUQHDOJLRUQR HFFRFRPHVLSUHVHQWDOD]RQD
6RWWRODFROOLQDLQEDVVRSRWUDQQRWURYDUHO¶LQJUHVVRGHOODWRPEDGL1HIHUWKRWHS
3LUDPLGH
F
E
E
D
(¶O¶DQWLFDPHUDGHOODWRPEDVXOOHSDU HWLFLVRQRDOFXQLDIIUHVFKLEHQFRQVHU YDWLUDIILJXUDQWLVDFULILFLXPDQL XQDFRVD SXzHVVHUHQRWDWDDXWRPDWLFRVHVLRVVHUYDQREHQHJOLDIIUHVFKL 1HIHUWKRWHSXVDVHPSUHXQDVWUDQDVSDGDFKH VHPEUDPROWRGHFRUDWD (¶ODFDPHUDPRUWXDULD LOVDUFRIDJRqULFFD PHQWHGHFRUDWRFRQO¶LPPDJLQHGLXQ/HRQHFRQWHVWDGL WHQWDFROR DSUHQGRLOVDUFRIDJRVLYHGHFKHqYXRWR$OOHSDUHWLVLYHGRQRLVFUL]LRQLLQFRPSUHQVLELOLHVWUDQLGLVHJQL FRQXQWLUR'H6RFLHWDWHDGLIIVLSXzFDSLUHFKHLOVDUFRIDJRqXQDVSHFLHGLSRUWDOHSHUXQ¶DOWURPRQGRLQUHDOWj XQ¶DOWUDVWDQ]D FKLFLVLVGUDLDGHQWURLQIDWWLHSDVVDXQWLUR'H0DJLDDGLIIVLULWURYDQHOSXQWR³D´GHOODVWDQ]D SHUWURYDUHLOSDVVDJJLRVHJUHWRELVRJQDSDVVDUHXQWLUR'H6FLHQWLDDGLII ,QTXHVWDVWDQ]DUDJJLXQJLELOHVRORFRQXQDFRUGD YLVWRFKHLOFRUULGRLRqLQIRUWHGLVF HVDVLWURYDXQSHQWDFRORLQFLVR SHUWHUUDHVFRQVDFUDWR'H0DJLDDGLIISHUFDSLUORFRQDOFHQWURXQDOWDUHFRSHUWRGLVDQJXHUDJJUXPDWRHFRQ VRSUDODVSDGDGL1HIHUWKRWHS6HL3*DFFHQQDQRDYROHUODWRFFDUHTXHOORFRQ'H0DJLDSLDOWDDYUjXQDYLVLRQH GHOO¶LQWHURFHUFKLRFHOHVWHLUDWRVFDJOLDUVLFRQWURGLORURSHUWUDVSRUWDUQHO¶DQLPDDO7DUWDUR FLzGRYUHEEHGLVVXDGHUOL GDOSUHQGHUHODVSDGDPDOHGHWWD6XOOHSDUHWLFLVRQRVFHQHGLVDFULILFLXPDQLWUDQQHFKHVXOODSDUHWHLQIRQGRGLSLQWD DIRUPDGLSRUWDFRQDOFHQWURXQEXFRRYDOH qODSRVL]LRQHGRYHLQVHULUHLOPHGDJOLRQHDIRUPDGLVFDUDEHRFKHDSUH ODSLUDPLGH GRSRDYHULQVHULWRLOPHGDJOLRQHELVRJQDOHJJHUHDGDOWDYRFHO¶LVFUL]LRQHSRVWDVRSUDODSRUWDHG HIIHWWXDUHXQ'H0DJLDDGLIISHUSRWHUDSULUHLOSRUWDOH 4XDQGRXQ3*DUULYDTXLSHUGH 39DFDXVDGHOORVKRFGH OWHOHWUDVSRUWR1HOVD UFRIDJRFHQWUDOH³F´VLWURYDLO FRUSRGL1HIHUWKRWHSPXPPLILFDWR XQDEXRQDLGHDqTXHOODGLEUXFLDUQHLOFRUSRFRVuFKHQRQSRVVDHVVHUHULSRUWDWR LQYLWD SHUzSULPDFKHL3*SRVVDQRDSULUHLOVDUFRIDJRVLDSURQRLVDUFRIDJLODVFLDWLLQYHUWLFDOHHGHVFRQR PXPPLHFKHDWWDFFDQR6XXQDGHOOHSDUHWLGHOODVWDQ]DqLQFLVRXQGLVHJQRGHOODVILQJHFRQWHVWDGLWHQWDFRORFRQ DFFDQWRLQFLVRO¶LQFDQWHVLPRGLDSHUWXUDGHOSRUWDOHGHOODVILQJHSHUDFFHGHUHOjGRYHVLWURYD.XWXVXPJDO O¶LQFDQWHVLPRULFKLHGHRUHHGqDGLIIVHVLFRQRVFHLOOLQJXDJJLRFRQFXLqVFULWWRRSSXUHDGLII 0XPPLH'9 'H&RUSRUH'DQQL 3XQWL9LWD 'H%HOOR 3RWHUL 0DOHGL]LRQH7HUURUH 6HWWLPD3DUWH³*OL'HL3ULPLJHQL´
'LVWUXWWRLOFRUSRGL1HIHUWKRWHSHSRVVLELOPHQWHFRSLDWRO¶LQFDQWHVLPRGLDSHUWXUDGHOSRUWDOHL3*SRVVRQRRUD DFFHGHUHDOODSLUDPLGHGHJOL'HL3ULPLJHQL
/HVWDQ]HVRQRWXWWHGHFRUDWHPDOHGHFRUD]LRQLVRQRPROWRURYLQDWHTXDVLFRPHVHTXDOFXQRYLFLIRVVHDFFDQLWRFRQWUR /HVWDQ]HLQGLFDWHFRQ³´FRQWHQJRQRXQDWUDSSRODFKHVFDWWDDOO¶LQJUHVVRGHL3*QHOODVWDQ]DDPHQRFKHQRQGLFDQR GLFHUFDUHWUDSSROHDOORUDqFRQFHVVRXQ'H6FLHQWLDDGLIISHUWURYDUOHHXQRSHUGLVLQQHVFDUOHVHQ]DIDUOHVFDWWDUHH DJLVFHFRPHULODVFLRGLXQJDVWRVVLFRFKHqXQYHOHQREODQGRGLXQ' 4XHOOHFRQ³´FRQWHQJRQRPXPPLHFKHGLIHQGRQRLOOXRJR VHYLHQHPRVWUDWRORURLOPHGDJOLRQHVLDOORQWDQDQR ODVFLDQGRSDVVDUHL3* 3HUWURYDUHLOSDVVDJJLRVHJUHWRVHUYHXQ'H6FLHQWLDDGLII /D6WDQ]DFRQ³´SUHVHQWDXQVDUFRIDJRFRPSOHWDPHQWHG¶RURFKLXVRGDXQDODVWUDFRSHUWDGDJHURJOLILFL LQFRPSUHQVLELOL3HUDSULUORILQRDS HUVRQHSRVVRQRFROODERUD UHVRPPDQGROD9LJRUHSDVVDQGRXQ WLURDGLII $SHUWRLOVDUFRIDJRVLYHGUjXQDJURVVD QHEELDELDQFDVWUDH GDHVVDXVFLUDQQRXRPLQL VRQR$Q(QOLOHG(QNLL 3ULPLJHQL TXHVWLGLUDQQRFKHQRQF¶qWHPSRGDSHUGHUHHELVRJQDUDJJLXQJHUHVXELWRLOSRUWDOHGHOODVILQJH 3DUWH2WWDYD³/¶XOWLPRVFRQWUR´
7RUQDWLDOODVILQJHL3*SRWUDQQRDFFHGHUHIDFLOPHQWHDOODVWDQ]DGHOSRUWDOHHTXLYHGUDQQRL$QWLFKLGDYDQWLDOSRUWDOH FKHVHPEUDXQDSRUWDVXOFLHORVWHOODWR L3ULPLJHQLLQWHUYHUUDQRFRQIUDVLWLSR³6LDPRDOODUHVDGHLFRQWL´ RSSXUH ´6LDPRWRUQDWL´LQVRPPDFRVHPROWRWHDWUDOLHGHSLF KH$TXHVWRSXQWRVFRSSLHUjORVFRQWURPDJLFRWUD JOLGHL WXWWL GHYRQRVRVWHQHUHXQ'H0DJLDDGLIIRXQWLURGL'H&RUSRUHDGLIISHUQRQVYHQLUHDFDXVDGHOJUDQGHVIRU]R PDJLFR'XUDQWHORVFRQWURJOLGHLDVVXPHUDQQROHORURIRUPHSUHIHULWH (UHVKNLJDOÆ6HUSHQWHFRQIDFFLDGLGRQQDHDOLGLSLSLVWUHOOR 1\XUOQDPWDOÆ/HRQHELSHGHFRQWHVWDGLWHQWDFROR $QÆ(QRUPHDTXLODELFLSLWH (QOLOÆ8RPRHOHIDQWHFRQEUDFFLD (QNLÆ3LRYUDJLJDQWHFRQEUDFFLDWHUPLQDQWLFRQGHOOHFKHOH $OODILQHGLXQDOXQJDEDWWDJOLDJOL$QWLFKLYHQJRQRULJHWWDWLQHOSRUWDOHFKHLQL]LDDVXVVXOWDUH GRSRDOFXQLPLQXWLHVFH GDOSRUWDOHXQXRPRFKHGRSRDYHUWUDFFLDWRXQSHQWDFRORVXOSDYLPHQWRVHPSOLFHPHQWHDO]DQGRXQDPDQRYLSLD]]DDO FHQWURXQSH]]RGLFHUFKLRG¶RURHULHQWUDQHOSRUWDOHGRSRDYHUVDOXWDWRL3ULPLJHQLHGHVVHUHVWDWRGDORURVDOXWDWRFRPH 0DUFXV$UWXUXV3HUFKLFRQRVFH³,O5LFKLDPRGL&KWXOKX´JGUTXHVWRIDWWRqFLWDWRLQXQDFDPSDJQD 3817, VL SRVVRQRDVVHJDUH'DOODILQHGHOODASDUWHH'DOODILQHGHOO¶DYYHQWXUD 6HL3*VLVRQRFRPSRUWDWLPROWREHQHVLSRVVRQRDVVHJQDUH'