dddPNB vs GATEWAY PROPERTY HOLDINGS, INC. GR NO. 181485; FEBRUARY 15, 212 FACTS! R"s#$%d"%& R"s#$%d"%& GPHI '(s ( s)*s+d+(- $/#(%- $0 G(&"'(- E"&$%+s C$/#(%- GEC3. GEC $*&(+%"d $% &"/ $(%s 0$/ &" L(%d B(%6 $0 &" P++##+%"s LBP3 +% &" (/$)%& $0 P7 /++$% (%d &" $(%s '"" s")"d *- /$&("s "")&"d *- GEC $v" +&s #$#"&+"s. LBP +%v+&"d $&" *(%6s &$ "%d /$%"- &$ GEC. I& +s (""d &(& LBP (""d &$ s)*/+& &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s &$ +& *- GEC (s #(& $0 &" (&&"s (ss"&s &(& '+ *" $v""d *- ( 9$&(" T)s& I%d"%&)" 9TI3, "%s)+% &(& ( #(&++#(&+% *(%6s +% &" $(% s-%d+(&" '+ (v" ":)( s")+&- #$s+&+$%. LBP (%d ( $%s$&+)/ $0 *(%6s "%&""d +%&$ ( 9"/$(%d)/ $0 U%d"s&(%d+% 9OU3, '""*- LBP (""d &$ ""(s" &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s &$ &" $%s$&+)/ $0 *(%6s $% &" *(s+s $0 (% 9TI. T" #(&++#(&+% *(%6s ""(s"d 0)%ds +% 0(v$ $0 GEC. P"&+&+$%" P"&+&+$%" PNB *"(/" #(& $0 &+s $%s$&+)/ $0 "d+&$ *(%6s. GEC &"% ":)"s&"d PNB &$ $%v"& +&s $%&"/ $(%s +%&$ ( C$%v"&+*" O/%+*)s C"d+& L+%" d)" &$ +&s d+<)&- +% #(-+% +&s $*+(&+$%. PNB (##$v"d s) ( $%v"s+$% s)*="& &$ "&(+% $%d+&+$%s GPHI '(s /(d" ( $*$$'" +% &" (""/"%& (""/"%& (%d '(s $*+(&"d &$ "")&" +% 0(v$ $0 PNB ( "( "s&(&" /$&(" $v" &'$ #("s $0 (%d. GEC >"d ( $/#(+%& 0$ s#"+> #"0$/(%" ((+%s& LBP d)" &$ &" (&&"?s "0)s( &$ s(" &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s #$#"&+"s '+& &" $%s$&+)/ $0 "d+&$ *(%6s. PNB d"/(%d"d #(-/"%& 0$/ GEC (%d '"% &" (&&" d+s$v""d d+s$v""d &" 0$/"?s +%&"%& &$ 0$"$s" &" RE9, +& #(-"d &(& ( TRO3 *" +ss)"d &$ "%=$+% PNB 0$/ 0$"$s+% $% &" #$#"&+"s $0 GPHI (%d =)d/"%& *" +ss)"d d"(+% &(& &" "( "s&(&" /$&(" +%v$v+% &" #$#"&+"s $0 GPHI (%d "")&"d +% 0(v$ $0 PNB +s %) (%d v$+d. GPHI $%&"%d"d &(& &" )%d"s&(%d+% *"&'""% GEC (%d PNB +s &(& &" GPHI #$#"&+"s '$)d s&(%d /""/""- (s ( &"/#$(- s")+&- #"%d+% &" $)&$/" $0 (s" >"d *- GEC ((+%s& LBP. S+%" %$ TRO '(s +ss)"d *- &" C$)&, PNB '(s (*" &$ 0$"$s"d &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s. T""(0&", T""(0&", GPHI >"d ( P"&+&+$% P"&+&+$% 0$ A%%)/"%& $0 F$"$s) F$"$s)" " $0 9$&(". GPHI ()"d &(&, +% $%d)&+% &" 0$"$s)" #$""d+%s, &" s"+@ 0(+"d &$ $*s"v" &" ":)+"/"%& $0 S"&+$% 4 $0 A& N$. 15 &(& &" s(" s( *" /(d" (& #)*+ ()&+$%. C$%&"%&+$% $0 PNB!
T"" '(s (%$&" (&+$% #"%d+% *"&'""% &" s(/" #(&+"s 0$ &" s(/" ()s" $0 (&+$%. PNB ()"d &(& GPHI "s$&"d &$ ( s#+&&+% $0 ( ()s" $0 (&+$% *- >s& >+% ( $/#(+%& 0$ &" (%%)/"%& $0 &" $%&(& $0 "( "s&( "s&(&" &" /$& /$&( (" " (%d (%d &"% &"% >+% >+% ( #"&+ #"&+&+ &+$% $% 0$ 0$ &" &" (%%) (%%)/ /"% "%&& $0 &" &" s)*s s) *s": ":)" )"%& %& 0$ 0$"$ "$s) s)" $0 &" &" /$& /$&( (". ". PNB PNB 0)& 0)&" " (" ("" "d d &(& &(& &" &" s)*s":)"%& #"&+&+$% $0 GPHI 0(+"d &$ s&(&" ( ()s" $0 (&+$%. RTC d+s/+ss"d &" (s" (%d )"d &(& *$& &" +v+ (s"s +%v$v"d &" s(/" #(&+"s, s)*s&(%&+(- +d"%&+( ()s"s $0 (&+$% (%d "+"0s #(-"d 0$, &" "+"0s *"+% 0$)%d"d $% &" s(/" 0(&s. W"" ( s+%" ()s" $0 (&+$% (s *""% s#+& (%d #)s)(%& &$ R)" 17, S"&+$% 1"3 $0 &" 1 R)"s $% C+v+ P$"d)", &" 9$&+$% &$ D+s/+ss >"d *- PNB, $% &" $)%d &(& &"" +s (%$&" (&+$% #"%d+% *"&'""% &" s(/" #(&+"s 0$ &" s(/" ()s", $ +&+s #"%d"%&+( +s #$#". O% (##"(, &" CA s"& (s+d" &" d"+s+$% $0 &" RTC RTC (%d )"d &(& &" &+d ":)+s+&" $0 +&+s #"%d"%&+( &" +d"%&+&- +% &" &'$ (s"s s$)d *" s) &(& &" =)d/"%& &(& /(- *" "%d""d +% $%" '$)d, "(d"ss $0 '+ #(&+s s)"ss0), (/$)%& &$ "s (d=)d+(&( &$ &" $&"3 +s %$& #"s"%& ISSUE! W"&" $ %$& &" ":)+s+&"s $0 +&+s #"%d"%&+( "+s& &$ '((%& &" d+s/+ss( $0 C+v+ C(s" 0$ A%%)/"%& $0 &" F$"$s)" F$"$s)" S(" HELD! YES. A &" ":)+s+&"s ":)+s+&"s $0 +&+s #"%d"%&+( "+s&. "+s&. T"" +s +&+s +&+s #"%d"%&+( +0 &" 0$$'+% ":)+s+&"s ":)+s+&"s (" #"s"%&! (3 +d"%&+&+d"%&+&- $0 #(&+"s, $ (& "(s& s) #(&+"s (s "#"s"%& &" s(/" +%&""s&s +%&""s&s +% *$& (&+$%s; *3 +d"%&+&- $0 +&s (ss"&"d (%d "+"0 #(-"d 0$, &" "+"0 *"+% 0$)%d"d $% &" s(/" s (/" 0(&s; (%d 3 &" +d"%&+&- $0 &" &'$ #""d+% #(&+)(s +s s) &(& (%- =)d/"%& "%d""d "%d""d +% &" $&" (&+$%, '+, "(d"ss "(d"ss $0 '+ #(&- +s s)"ss0), (/$)%& &$ "s =)d+(&( +% &" (&+$% )%d" $%s+d"(&+$%. As &$ &" >s& ":)+s+&", ":)+s+&", GPHI +s &" #(+%&+@ +% *$& +v+ (s"s '+" PNB +s &" #(&- ((+%s& '$/ GPHI +s (ss"&+% ( (+/. As &$ &" s"$%d ":)+s+&", ("(&+$%s +% C+v+ 0$ A%%)/"%& $0 &" R"( Es&(&" 9$&(" (%d A%%)/"%& $0 &" F$"$s)" F$"$s)" S(" "v"( &(& &" s(+d (s"s +%v$6" &" s(/" 0)%d(/"%&( +ss)" '+ +s &" &"/#$(- %(&)" $0 &" s")+&- &(& '(s &$ *" #$v+d"d *- &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s $0 GPHI. As &$ &" &+d ":)+s+&", W+" &" (##"( $0 &" d+s/+ss( $0 A%%)/"%& $0 &" F$"$s)" F$"$s)" S(" '(s s&+ #"%d+% '+& &" C$)& $0 A##"(s, GPHI >"d $% ( 9$&+$% 0$ L"(v" &$ A/"%d C$/#(+%& &$ C$%0$/ &$ &" Ev+d"%" +%
C+v+ C(s" A%%)/"%& $0 &" R"( Es&(&" 9$&(". GPHI s&(&"d &""+% &(& (0&" &" #(&+"s #"s"%&"d &"+ "v+d"%", &" 0(& 0( & $0 0$"$s) 0$ "$s)" " (%d &" (:)+s+&+$% $0 &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s *- PNB '"" d)- "s&(*+s"d. I% &" ($/#(%-+% A/"%d"d C$/#(+%& +% A%%)/"%& $0 &" R"( Es&(&" 9$&(", GPHI #(-"d, 0$ &" d"((&+$% $0 &" %)+&- $0 &" 0$"$s)" (%d ()&+$% s(" $0 &" /$&("d #$#"&+"s. As ( $%s":)"%" $0 s) (% (&+$%, &" &'$ (s"s &(& GPHI >"d *"0$" &" $)& ( :)$ "%"0$& $%&(+%"d (% +d"%&+&- $0 +&s (ss"&"d ( ss"&"d (%d "+"0s #(-"d 0$, &" "+"0 *"+% 0$)%d"d $% &" s(/" 0(&)( ("(&+$%s.
