APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
Z. H. SIKDER UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Madhupur,Bhedergonj,Shariatpur ASSIGNMENT ON APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
COURSE CODE COURSE T ITLE
: LAW 232 : CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE ( PART II)
DEPARTMENT OF LAW
SUBMITTED BY
STUDENT’S NAME STUDENT’S ID BATCH DEPARTMENT
: TAWHIDUR RAHMAN MURAD : 140314024 : 8th : LAW
SUBMITTED TO
SUPERVISOR DESIGNATION
: DR. MD. EMRAN PARVEZ KHAN : PHD IN LAW!ANU,USA" ASSOCIATE PROFESOR
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
DEAN
FECULTY OF HUMANITIES AND SOCIAL SCIENCE& CHAIRMAN
DEPARTMENT OF LAW CONTENTS
SN . .2 .3 .5 .6 .8 .9 . .; 2. 2. 2.2 2.3 2.5 2.6 2.8 2.9 2. 2.; 3. 3. 3.2 3.3 3.5 3.6 3.8 3.9 3.
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
3.; 5. 5. 5.2 5.3 5.5 5.6 5.8
R@'"$!$#/7!%7!"$,77$#/!%7* S"/+ <+ A--00/" C$#" S'#"+ ! '/* $, $#%# ,$# ?'"$! $, %'# /--/0% ,#$7 P#$'%# H/#!4 /" A##$%& %'( R$)*$+ A--/0 /!% R,#!' A--/0 /!% R=*$! C$!'0*$!
PAGE NO. 12 2 2 3 315 5 516 618 8 819 1; ;1 12 2 3 3 3 5 516 6 6 8 8 8 9 91 ; ; 2 212 2
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
11 I't-(./t*-'
A!+ -#*$! $ ,0* /44#=% <+ /!+ %'# $# $#%# $, " '$#" 7/+ -#,# /! /--/0 ! " *-#$# '$#" , " /--/0 * -#$=%% /4/!*" "/" %'# $# $#%#. A #4" "$ /--/0 * !$" / !/"#/0 $# /! !#!" #4". A! /--/0 * / '#/"# $, " *"/"" /!% "# * !$ #4" $, /--/0 !0** " * 4=! '0/#0+ /!% ! ?-#** "#7*. I" * / =*"% #4" /!% /''#* "$ " 0"4/!" /!% ?*"* /* $! /!% ,#$7 " %/" " 0* '$77!'*. T ?-#**$! /--/0 /* !$" <! %,!% ! " '$% <" " 7/+ < %,!% /* " @%'/0 ?/7!/"$! $, " %'*$! <+ / 4# '$#" $, " %'*$! $, /! !,#$# '$#"
. I" 7/!* #7$=/0 $, / '/* ,#$7 /! !,#$# "$ / *-#$#
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
Thakker, C.K., Civil Procedure Code, 3rd Edition, Eastern book Company, p - 26 2 !"#3"-32$ %# &' 2(3 ) '&* "#32 PC "6% 3 'kbar vs +. ( * !PC$ "# 5 Paul u Plessis, orko/ski0s Te1tbook on *oman a/ (2 !2"%$.
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
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th$ t%t.t- &%+ - B%'&%($h
S'"$!* ;812 /!% O#%#* 5 "$ 56 $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0* " /--/0
F#*" /--/0*: S*. ;81;;A 9 /!% O#%# JLI. S'$!% A--/0*: S*. 13 /!% O#%# JLII. A--/0* ,#$7 $#%#*: S*. 5 1 /!% O#%# JLIII. A--/0* "$ " S-#7 C$#": S'"$!* ; 2 /!% O#%# JLV. A--/0* <+ !%4!" -$-0: O#%# JLIV.
I" * ! "
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
A--/0* "$ S-#7 C$#" /# 4$=#!% <+ " P#$=*$!* $, A#"'0* 3 5 /!% 6 $, " C$!*"""$! $, B/!40/%* " #4/#% "$ '=0 7/""#*. S<@'" "$ " -#$=*$!* $, " C$!*"""$! /! /--/0 */00 0 "$ " S-#7 C$#" ,#$7 /!+ @%47!" %'# $# ,!/0 $#%# ! / '=0 -#$'%!4 $, / H4 C$#" , " H4 C$#" '#",* "/"
(/) T '/* !=$0=* / *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/ $, 4!#/0 7-$#"/!' /!% (<) I! " $-!$! $, " H4 C$#" " */% *"$! !%* "$ < %'%% <+ " S-#7 C$#".
1 A##$%& t- th$ S.#$5$ C-.t - B%'&%($h
S'"$!* 3 /!% 5 #/% " O#%# JLV $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0 " /--/0* "$ " S-#7 C$#". A! /--/0 $0% 0 "$ " S-#7 C$#" !%# S'"$! 3 $, " C$% $!0+ , " ,$00$!4 '$!%"$!* /# ,0,00%: /. A @%47!" %'# $# ,!/0 $#%# 7*" /= <! -/**% <+ " H4 C$#" <. A *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/ $, 4!#/0 7-$#"/!' 7*" /= <! I!=$0=% ! " C/*. '. I! " $- !$! $, " H4 C$ #" " */% *"$! !%* "$ < %' %% <+ " S- #7 C$#". 16
M$%'*' - A##$%&
T ?-#**$! /--/0 /* !$" <! %,!% ! " C$%. A''$#%!4 "$ " %'"$!/#+ 7/!!4 /--/0 * " @%'/0 ?/7!/"$! $, " %'*$! <+ / 4# '$#" $, " %'*$! $, /! !,#$# '$#" . S"/"% *7-0+ /--/0 * / -#$'%!4 <+ ' " %,/"% -/#"+ /--#$/'* / 4# /"$#"+ $# '$#" #=#*%. I! aendra ath ey v. 4uresh Chandra ey 6 , *-/!4 ,$# " @%'/0 C$77"" $, P#=+ C$!'0 4ir insha 5ulla *"/"%: 6 rder 78 o9 the Code o9 Civil Procedure,"#( 8 !"#3"-32$ %# &' 2(3 ) '&* "#32 PC "6%
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
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
<! #$!4% <+ " %'*$! $, " '$#". A! /--/0 * /0/+* -#,##% ! / 4# '$#" $, 0/. I! '/* /! /--/0 ,/0* / *'$!% /--/0 '/! < ,0%. A! /--/0 * /0/+* ,0% <+ $! $, " '$!'#!% -/#"*. 17
E$'t*%& $&$5$'t - %##$%&9
E=#+ /--/0 /* "#
A -#*$! /4 4#=% ($ * $,"! " $4 !$ " !'**/#0+ / -/#"+ "$ " $# 4!/0
-#$'%!4) /!% 9 'ttorney :eneral v. 4illem,!"(6;$ " <C =; at p.="%)"" E* "2 at "2# Tak/ani C. K., Civil Procedure, =th ed., Eastern ook Company, 2";,P,2%% ; i&
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
3. 18
A #=!4 <$%+ #/%+ /!% 00!4 "$ !"#"/! /! /--/0. P-/$(.$ R$&%t$( t- A##$%&10
T /--/0 <!4 " '$!"!/"$! $, " *" * 0% !$" "$" /!+ #/*$! " 7/+ < ?/7!% ! " 04" $, " ,$00$!4 -#$-$*"$!*: .T /--00/" '$#" /* /00 " -$#* /!% /* "$ %$ /00 "$* "!4* !'**/#+ "/" / "#/0 '$#" /* /!% /* "$ %$. I! "* *!* =! ! " '/* 4$* $! /--/0 " * @*" " !/7 "/" /* !%#4$! / '/!4 " ,$#7 /!% *<*"/!' *"00 #7/! " */7. 2.
I! " */7 =! /* /<$= " /--00/" '$#" /* "$ %$ /00 "/" /* <! %$! <+ " "#/0
'$#" ! "/" -/#"'0/# '/* /!% "! "# /4# $# %*/4# ,#$7 " "#/0 '$#". 3.
H!' =! " /--00/" '$#" /* "$ #" / @%47!" /!% -/** / %'#. I! " =!"
$, " '$#" -$0%!4 " 0$# '$#"’* %'*$! " /--00/" '$#" 7/+ #" %$! " */7 %'# "$" '/!4!4 " /!% " %'# 00 !$ < %7% "$ /= <! "/" $, " /--00/" '$#". 5. F!/00+ " *" * !$" %7% "$ < ,!/00+ '$!'0%% ,$# 7/""#* $, #* @%'/"/ "00 " /--/0* /# $=#. T* 7-0* "/" " * %7% "/" " */7 *" * -#$4#** =! 0 " /--/0* /# $!. I" * $!0+ ! " '$#"* /= ,!/00+ '$7 "$ / '$!'0*$! /,"# /00 -$**<0 /--/0* /= <! *% /!% "#% <+ " /--00/!" "/" " *" * */% "$ /= <! '$!'0*=0+ %'%%. T /<$= */% -#$-$*"$!* -$!" $" ! **!' /" * 7-0% ! " * */% "/" " /--/0 * / '$!"!/"$! $, " *". T =/#$* -#$=*$!* #0/"!4 "$ " /--/0* /= /0#/%+ <! *"/"% ! " !"#$%'"$! "$ "* $#. A %"/0% 0$$ !"$ "* -#$=*$!* /" "* @!'"# <'$7* -#"!!". 11
19
R*ht - A##$%&
rder 7& o9 the Code o9 Civil Procedure,"#( :ana ai v. 8i>ay Kumar, !"#=;$
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
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nant 5ills Co. td. v. 4tate o9 :u>arat *-/!4 ,$# " S-#7 C$#" K/!!/ . */%: I" * 001*""0% <+ *=#/0 %'*$!* $, "* '$#" "/" " #4"* $, /--/0 * / '#/"# $, / *"/"" /!% "# * !$ #/*$! + " 04*0/"# 0 4#/!"!4 " #4" '/!!$" 7-$* '$!%"$!* ,$# " ?#'* $, *' #4" *$ 0$!4 /* " '$!%"$!* /# !$" *$ $!#$* /* "$ /7$!" "$ !#/*$!/<0 #*"#'"$!* #!%#!4 " #4" /07$*" 00*$#+. 2
C-5#%$ $t+$$' R*ht t- .*t %'( *ht t- %##$%&13
T# * / ,!%/7!"/0 %,,#!' <"! *" /!% /--/0 /!% " */7 * <!4 ?-0/!% -#$-#0+ <+ ?. Chandrachud ! :ana ai v. 8i>ay Kumar ! " ,$00$!4 $#%*: T# * /
2 :ana ai v. 8i>ay Kumar, !"#=;$ 2 4CC 3#3 at p. 3#= 3 aya/ati v. &nder>it
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
$--$*". T #4" $, /--/0 !#* ! !$ $! /!% "#,$# /! /--/0 ,$# "* 7/!"/!/<0"+ 7*" /= " '0/# /"$#"+ $, 0/. 21
A##$%& * % C-'t*'.%t*-' - S.*t
A! /--/0 * / '$!"!/"$! $, *" /!% !' %'# -/**% <+ /! /--00/" '$#" $0% < '$!*"#% /* %'# -/**% <+ " C$#" $, ,#*" !*"/!'. A! /--/0 * =#"/00+ / #/#!4 $, " 7/""#. T /--00/" '$#" -$***** " */7 -$#* /!% %"* /* " $#4!/0 '$#". O!' /4/! " !"# -#$'%!4* /# <,$# " /--00/" '$#" ' '/! #= " =%!' /* / $0 *<@'" "$ *"/""$#+ 07"/"$!* , /!+ /!% '/! '$7 "$ "* $! '$!'0*$! $, *' =%!'. I! aya/ati v. &nder>it *-/!4 ,$# " S-#7 C$#"
I" 7/+ 7$%,+ "/" $#%# /!%
3.
I" 7/+ 7#0+ %*7** " /--/0 /!% "* '$!,#7 " $#%# $, " 0$# '$#" "$"
/!+ 7$%,'/"$!. I! /00 "# '/** /,"# %*-$*/0 $, " /--/0 <+ " /--00/" /"$#"+ " $#%# *$ -/**% <+ " /"$#"+ 00 < $-#/"= ##*-'"= $, " ,/'" "/" "* $#%# /* #=#*% 7$%,% $# '$!,#7% " %'*$! $, " 0$# '$#". I! ,/'" " * " /--00/" %'*$! /0$! ' *<**"* /!% $-#/"= /* 00 /* '/-/<0 $, !,$#'7!".
5 *amankutty v. 'vara, !"##;$ 2 4CC 6;2 at p. 6;%
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
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
/''#* "$ "
/0"$4 " 7/+ < /'"/00+
?#'*% ! " /%=#* @%47!" * -#$!$!'% *' #4" "$ < 4$=#!% <+ " 0/ -#=/0!4 /" " %/" $, " !*"""$! $, " *" $# -#$'%!4 /!% !$" <+ " 0/ "/" -#=/0* /" " %/" $, "* %'*$! $# /" " %/" $, ,0!4 $, " /--/0. 6. T* =*"% #4" $, /--/0 '/! < "/! //+ $!0+ <+ / *<*!" !/'"7!"
, " * *$
-#$=%% ?-#**0+ $# <+ !'**/#+ !"!%7!" /!% !$" $"#*. 22 A##$%& %'( R$)**-'
T #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! $, / H4 C$#" * / -/#" /!% -/#'0 $, " /--00/" @#*%'"$! $, " H4 C$#". W! " /% $, " H4 C$#" * !=$% $! " #=*$!/0 *% " * %$! <'/* " * / *-#$# '$#" /!% " '/! !"#,# ,$# " -#-$* $, #'",+!4 " ##$# $, " '$#" <0$. I" * $!0+ $! $, " 7$%* $, ?#'*!4 -$# '$!,##% <+ " S"/""
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
R=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! * !$" % !$4 "$ 7/ " H4 C$#" / *'$!% '$#" $, ,#*" /--/0. T H4 C$#" '/!!$" ! ?#'* $, #=*$!/0 -$#* *<*""" "* $! = ,$# " = "/! <+ / *<$#%!/" '$#". I! 4tate o9 Kerala v. K.5. Charia 'bdullah @ Co . C$#" /* 404"% " %,,#!' <"! " "$ @#*%'"$!* ! " ,$00$!4 $#%*: T# * /! **!"/0 %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$!. T %*"!'"$! *
:irdhari al Cho/dhury 0/% %$! '$##'" 0/ $! " -$!". S-/!4 ,$# " 7/@$#"+ H* L$#%*- '$!'0%%: T %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$! * / #/0 $!. A #4" $, /--/0 '/##* " " / #4" $, #/#!4 $! 0/ /* 00 /* ,/'" !0** " *"/"" '$!,##!4 " #4" $, /--/0 07"* " #/#!4 ! *$7 /+ /* ,!% /* <! %$! * *'$!% /--/0* /#*!4 !%# " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#. T -$# "$ /# / #=*$! * 4!#/00+ 4=! "$ / *-#$# C$#" *$ "/" " 7/+ */"*,+ "*0, "/" / -/#"'0/# '/* /* <! %'%% /''$#%!4 "$ 0/. U!%# *. 6 $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#. " H4 C$#"* -$# /# 07"% "$ * "# ! / '/* %'%%
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
"# /* <! /! /**7-"$! $, @#*%'"$! # !$! ?*"% $# / #,*/0 $, @#*%'"$! # " %% $# "# /* <! 7/"#/0 ##40/#"+ $# 004/0"+ ! " ?#'* $, "/" @#*%'"$!. T #4" "# * '$!,!% "$ @#*%'"$! /!% @#*%'"$! /0$!. I! $"# /'"* " -$# * !$" *$ 07"% /!% " H4 C$#" * !/<0% "$ '/00 ,$# " #'$#% $, / '/* "$ */"*,+ "*0, "/" " %'*$! "#! * /''$#%!4 "$ 0/ /!% "$ -/** *' $#%#* ! #0/"$! "$ " '/* /* " "!* ,".6 23 F*t A##$%& %'( S$/-'( A##$%&16
T F#*" A--/0 '/! < /%7""% $! " 4#$!%* () *"$! $, ,/'" /!% /0*$ (2) *"$! $, 0/. T S'$!% A--/0 '/! < /%7""% $!0+ $! " -$!" $, *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/’. T F#*" A--/0 '/! < !"#"/!% <+ *<$#%!/" C$#"* "$ D*"#'" %4’* C$#" /!% "$ H4 C$#"*. E?/7-0: A! /--/0 ,#$7 " D*"#'" M!*,, M/4*"#/" * C$#" $# S<$#%!/" %4’* C$#" "$ " D*"#'" %4. T S'$!% A--/0 '/! $!0+ < !"#"/!% <+ " H4 C$#". S'"$!* ;8 "$ ;;1A 9 /!% O#%# JLI %/0* " F#*" A--/0*. S'"$!* "$ 3 /!% O#%# JLII %/0 " S'$!% A--/0. T M7$#/!%7 $, ,#*" /--/0 7*" *" $" " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* "$ " %'# /--/0% ,#$7. S!' " *'$!% /--/0 * 7/!"/!/<0 $!0+ ! " !=$0=* / *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/ / 77$#/!%7 $, *'$!% /--/0 7*" -#'*0+ *"/" *' *"$!. I" !% !$" *" $" " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* "$ " %'# /--/0% ,#$7.9 24
C-')$*-' - A##$%& *'t- R$)**-'18
I, /! /--/0 * -#,##% ! / '/* ! ' !$ /--/0 0* " '$#" 7/+ "#/" " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * / #=*$! $# =' =#*/. S!' "# * !$ *-',' -#$=*$! ,$# *' '$!=#*$! " '$#" $0% < @*",% ! !=$!4 " !#!" -$#* !%# S'"$! 6 /!% ! -/**!4 6 5d. 'bdul
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
/--#$-#/" $#%#* /* 7/+ < !'**/#+ ! " !"#*"* $, @*"'. T# * !$"!4 0 / -#$% $, 07"/"$! ,$# 7/!4 /! /--0'/"$! ,$# '$!=#*$! $, /! /--/0 !"$ #=*$! $# =' =#*/. A00 "/" * ##% "$ < *! * , " /--/0 $# " #=*$! /% <! ,0% "! " "7 -#*'#<% ,$# " ,0!4 $, " /--/0 $# " #=*$! /* " '/* 7/+ <.; 2
R*ht - A##$%&20
T #4" $, /--/0 * / =*"% #4" /!% *' / #4" "$ !"# " *-#$# '$#" /''#* "$ " 0"4/!" /!% ?*"* /* $! /!% ,#$7 " %/" " 0* '$77!'* /!% /0"$4 " 7/+ < /'"/00+ ?#'*% ! " /%=#* @%47!" * -#$!$!'% *' #4" * "$ < 4$=#!% <+ " 0/ -#=/0!4 /" " %/" $, " !*"""$! $, " *" $# -#$'%!4 /!% !$" <+ " 0/ "/" -#=/0* /" " %/" $, "* %'*$! $# /" " %/" $, " ,0!4 $, " /--/0.
26
A##$%& -5 O**'%& ($/$$21
S'"$! ;8 $, " '$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0* " A--/0 ,#$7 O#4!/0 %'# () S/= # $"#* ?-#**0+ -#$=%% ! " <$%+ $, "* C$% $# <+ /!+ $"# 0/ ,$# " "7 <!4 ! ,$#' /! /--/0 */00 0 ,#$7 =#+ %'# -/**% <+ /!+ C$#" ?#'*!4 $#4!/0 @#*%'"$! " C$#" /"$#% "$ /# /--/0* ,#$7 " %'*$!* $, *' C$#". (2) A! /--/0 7/+ 0 ,#$7 /! $#4!/0 %'# -/**% ? -/#". (3) N$ /--/0 */00 0 ,#$7 / %'# -/**% <+ " C$#" " " '$!*!" $, -/#"*.
; ahori v. 8idya *am, '&* "#=( 'll 2## 2 4ection #6 2 4ection #6
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
(5) N$ /--/0 */00 0 ?'-" $! / *"$! $, 0/ ,#$7 / %'# ! /!+ *" $, " !/"# '$4!*/<0 <+ C$#"* $, S7/00 C/** ! " /7$!" $# =/0 $, " *<@'"17/""# $, " $#4!/0 *" %$* !$" ?'% "! "$*/!% #-*. 27 Wh- 5% A##$%&
S'"$! ;8 $, " C$% #'$4!* " #4" $, /--/0 ,#$7 =#+ %'# -/**% <+ /!+ '$#" ?#'*!4 $#4!/0 @#*%'"$!. I" %$* !$" #,# "$ $# !7#/" " -#*$!* $ 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0. B" <,$# /! /--/0 '/! < ,0% !%# "* *'"$! "$ '$!%"$!* 7*" < */"*,%: .T *<@'"17/""# $, " /--/0 7*" < / %'#’ "/" * / '$!'0*= %"#7!/"$! $, " #4"* $, " -/#"* " #4/#% "$ /00 $# /!+ $, " 7/""#* ! '$!"#$=#*+ ! " *" /!% 2.
T -/#"+ /--/0!4 7*" /= <! /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ *' %"#7!/"$!.
T $#%!/#+ #0 * "/" $!0+ / -/#"+ "$ / *" /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# $# /!+ $, * #-#*!"/"=*1!1!"#*" 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0. B" / -#*$! $ * !$" / -/#"+ "$ / %'# $# $#%# 7/+ " " 0/= $, " '$#" -#,# /! /--/0 ,#$7 *' %'# $# $#%# , * "# <$!% <+ " $#%# $# * /44#=% <+ " $# * -#@%'/00+ /,,'"% <+ ".22 I" /* $<*#=% ! " '/* $, Krishna Chandra :older v. 5ahesh Chandra 4ahu " *"$! $ 7/+ /--/0 * %"#7!/<0 <+ " '$77$! *!* $, '$!*%#/"$! "/" "# '/! < !$ /--/0 # "# * !$"!4 "$ /--/0 /<$".23 F#$7 " /<$= 4!#/0 -#!'-0* " ,$00$!4 -#*$!* /# !""0% "$ /--/0 !%# "* *'"$!: .A!+ -/#"+ "$ " *" $ * /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# $# " "#/!*,# $, !"#*" $, *' -/#"+ /* <! /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# -#$=%% * !/7 /* !"#% !"$ #'$#% $, *".
22 iscttits vs Prince
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
2.
A -#*$! '0/7!4 !%# / -/#"+ "$ " *" $# / " #/!*,# $, " !"#*"* $, *' -/#"+
$ *$ ,/# /* *' !"#*" * '$!'#!% * <$!% <+ " %'# -#$=%% * !/7 * !"#% $! " #'$#% $, " *". 3.
A 4/#%/! /% 0"7 /--$!"% <+ " '$#" ! / *" <+ $# /4/!*" / 7!$#.
5.
A!+ $"# -#*$! " " 0/= $, " '$#" , * /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'#.
28
Wh- C%''-t A##$%&24
I, / -/#"+ /4#* !$" "$ /--/0 $# /=* * #4" "$ /--/0 '/!!$" ,0 /! /--/0 /!% 00 < <$!% <+ /! /4#7!" , $"#* *' /4#7!" * =/0%. 26 S' /! /4#7!" 7*" < '0/# /!% !/7<4$*. W"# / -/#"+ /* $# /* !$" /=% * #4" $, /--/0 %-!%* -$! " ,/'"* /!% '#'7*"/!'* $, /' '/*.28 S70/#0+ # / -/#"+ /* /''-"% " <!,"* !%# / %'# $, " '$#" '/! < *"$--% ,#$7 *"$!!4 " 04/0"+ $, " %'#.29 A* 4crutton, .?. $<*#=% I" *"/#"0* 7 "/" / -#*$! '/! */+ "/" @%47!" * #$!4 /!% /" " */7 "7 /''-" " -/+7!" !%# " @%47!" /* <!4 #4"Q.I! 7+ $-!$! +$ '/!!$" "/ " <!," $, / @%47!" /* <!4 4$$% /!% "! /--/0 /4/!*" " /* <!4
A##$%& -'$ P&%*'t* %%*'t %'-th$ P&%*'t*28
25 ibid 26 'mir 'li v. &nder>eet 4inh, !"(="$ "; 5&' 23 !PC$ 28 Protap Chunder v. 'rathoon, &* !"((2$ ( Cal ;%% 29 e1ters td. v.
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
A* / 4!#/0 #0 $! -0/!",, '/!!$" ,0 /! /--/0 /4/!*" / '$1-0/!",,. B" # " 7/""# ! '$!"#$=#*+ ! " *" ,$#7* *<@'"17/""# $, %*-" <"! -0/!",,* !"# * /! /--/0 '/! < ,0% <+ $! -0/!",, /4/!*" /!$"# -0/!",,.2; 3
30 A##$%& -'$ D$$'(%'t %%*'t %'-th$ D$$'(%'t
T -#!'-0 ' /--0* "$ ,0!4 $, /--/0 <+ $! -0/!",, /4/!*" /!$"# -0/!",, /00+ 3
/--0* "$ /! /--/0 <+ $! %,!%/!" /4/!*" /!$"# %,!%/!". I" * $!0+ # " %*-" * !$" $!0+ <"! -0/!",,* /!% " %,!%/!"* <" <"! %,!%/!"* !"# * /!% *' %'*$! /%=#*0+ /,,'"* $! %,!%/!" /4/!*" " $"# "/" *' /--/0 $0% < '$7-"!". 32 31
A$$5$'t '-t t- A##$%&33
A #4" $, /--/0 * / *"/""$#+ #4". I, / *"/"" %$* !$" '$!,# *' #4" !$ /--/0 '/! < ,0% =! " " '$!*!" $# /4#7!" <"! " -/#"*. B" /! /4#7!" <"! " -/#"* !$" "$ ,0 /! /--/0 * =/0% , " *
-#@%'%. 'bduvs TaAlu. ;( * 36"
2; 8ithu v. hima, &* !"(#"$ "% om ";% 3l3 * "% 3 irmala ala v. alai Chand, '&* "#6% 4C "(=; 32 ?oy vs 4ita. ; * ; 33 ibid 352( * !4C$ 36 'bduvs TaAlu. ;( * 36"
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
32 A##$%& A%*'t E: P%t$ D$/$$36
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
N- A##$%& %%*'t C-'$'t D$/$$39
36 Anwara vs Shahttnetrctz.43 DLR (AD) 156
39 4ection #6!2$ 3 '>udhia Prasad v. almukund, &* !"(66$ ( 'll 3%; !B$ 3; 4ection #6!3$
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
S'"$! ;8(3) %'0/#* "/" !$ /--/0 */00 0 /4/!*" / '$!*!" %'#. T* -#$=*$! *
A##$%& %%*'t P$&*5*'% D$/$$42
A! /--/0 0* /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'#. A -#07!/#+ %'# * /* 7' / ,!/0 %'#. I! ,/'" / ,!/0 %'# * <" 7/'!#+ ,$# " 7-07!"/"$! $, / -#07!/#+ %'#. F/0# "$ /--/0 /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'# !' -#0%* " /44#=% -/#"+ ,#$7 '/00!4!4 " ,!/0 %'#. W# /! /--/0 * ,0% /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'# /!% * /00$% /!% " %'# * *" /*% " ,!/0 %'# ,/00* "$ " 4#$!% /* !,,'"= *!' "# * !$ -#07!/#+ %'# "$ *--$#" " ,!/0 %'#. 53 3
N- A##$%& %%*'t F*'%& D$/$$ +h$$ '- A##$%& %%*'t P$&*5*'% D$/$$
I! *"* ' '$!"7-0/" " 7/!4 $, "$ %'#*1/ -#07!/#+ %'# /!% / ,!/0 %'#1" %'# ' $0% < ?'"/<0 $0% < " ,!/0 %'#. B" " ,!/0"+ $, / %'# $# / 5 Katikara Chintamani ora v. :untreddi 'nnamanaidu, !"#=;$ " 4 CC %6= at pp. %(;-(% 5 Thakur Prasad v. ha/an as, '&* "#(% 5P "=" 52 ibid 53 Phoolchand v. :opal al, '&* "#63 4C ##2 at pp. ##;-#%
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
%'*$! %$* !$" !'**/#0+ %-!% -$! " <!4 ?'"/<0. T 04*0/"# ! "* *%$7 /* "$4" "/" *"* $, '#"/! "+-* *$0% < %'%% ! *"/4* /!% "$4 " *" ! *' '/** '/! < #4/#%% /* ,00+ /!% '$7-0"0+ %'%% $!0+ /,"# / ,!/0 %'# * 7/% " %'*$! $, " '$#" /##=% /" " /#0# *"/4 /0*$ /* / ,!/0"+ /""/'% "$ "
55
. I" $0% < #0=/!" "$
#,# "$ *. ;9 $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%# ' -#$=%* "/" # / -/#"+ /44#=% <+ / -#07!/#+ %'# %$* !$" /--/0 ,#$7 " " * -#'0%% ,#$7 %*-"!4 "*. '$##'"!** ! /!+ /--/0 ' 7/+ < -#,##% ,#$7 " ,!/0 %'#. T* -#$=*$! "* '0/#0+ !%'/"* "/" /* "$ " 7/""#* '$=#% <+ "56 / -#07!/#+ %'# * #4/#%% /* 7<$%+!4 " ,!/0 %'*$! $, " '$#" -/**!4 "/" %'#.58 A##$%& %%*'t ;.(5$'t47
36
T '$% $, '=0 -#$'%# ; -#$=%* /! /--/0 ,#$7 / %'# /!% !$" ,#$7 / @%47!". A! /44#=% -/#"+ $=# 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0 /4/!*" " @%47!" , / %'# * !$" %#/! - <+ " '$#". 37
A##$%& %%*'t ($%( #$-'48
N$ /--/0 '/! < !*"""% /4/!*" / %/% -#*$!. S' /! /--/0 "#,$# '/! < #4/#%% /* / *"00<$#! /--/0. I! *' '/** /! /--0'/"$! '/! < 7/% -#/+!4 ,$# " *<*"""$! $, " 04/0 #-#*!"/"=* $, " %'/*% #*-$!%!" $ %% -#$# "$ " ,0!4 $, " /--/0. I! "/" '/* " /--/0 '/! < "/! "$ /= <! ,0% $! " %/" $, " /--0'/"$! ,$# *<*"""$! $, " 04/0 #-#*!"/"=*. I, <+ "/" "7 " /--/0 * "71
55?obeda vs Kshenta0 ( * 2%( 56 an/ari al v. Chando evi, !"##3$ " 4CC %(" 58 8enkata *eddi and thers v. Pothi *eddi, "#63 '&* ##2, "#63 4C* 4upl. !2$ 6"6 59 ibid 5 ibid
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
38
<-.'( +h*/h 5% $ t%=$' *' %##$%&
T /--00/!" */00 !$" ?'-" <+ 0/= $, " C$#" #4 $# < /#% ! *--$#" $, /!+ 4#$!% $, $<@'"$! *" ,$#" ! " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 <" " A--00/" C$#" ! %'%!4 " /--/0 */00 !$" < '$!,!% "$ " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* *" ,$#" ! " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 $# "/! <+ 0/= $, " C$#" !%# "* #0: P#$=%% "/" " C$#" */00 !$" #*" "* %'*$! $! /!+ $"# 4#$!% !0** " -/#"+ $ 7/+ < /,,'"% "#<+ /* /% / *,,'!" $--$#"!"+ $, '$!"*"!4 " '/* $! "/" 4#$!%. 5; W! / %'# * !"#% ! ,/=$# $, " -0/!",, * !""0% "$ *--$#" " %'# ! * ,/=$# /0*$ $! 4#$!%* ,$!% /4/!*" 7 Probodh vs 'bdu. "2 * ;%#
39
R$;$/t*-' - %5$'(5$'t - 5$5-%'(.5
() W# " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * !$" %#/! - ! " 7/!!# #!<,$# -#*'#<% " 7/+ < #@'"% $# < #"#!% "$ " /--00/!" ,$# " -#-$* $, <!4 /7!%% "! / "7 "$ < ,?% <+ " C$#" $# < /7!%% "! /!% "#. (2) W# " C$#" #@'"* /!+ 77$#/!%7 " */00 #'$#% " #/*$!* ,$# *' #@'"$!. (3) W# / 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * /7!%% " %4 $# *' $,,'# /* /--$!"* ! "* </0, */00 *4! $# !"/0 " /7!%7!". 4
St% A##$&&%t$ C-.t0
() A! /--/0 */00 !$" $-#/" /* / *"/+ $, -#$'%!4* !%# / %'# $# $#%# /--/0% ,#$7 ?'-" *$ ,/# /* " A--00/" C$#" 7/+ $#%# !$# */00 ?'"$! $, / %'# < *"/+% <+ #/*$! $!0+ $, /! /--/0 /=!4 <! -#,##% ,#$7 " %'# <" " A--00/" C$#" 7/+ ,$# *,,'!" '/* $#%# *"/+ $, ?'"$! $, *' %'#.
5; Probodh vs 'bdu. "2 * ;%# 6 'bu vs 4u>ayat. 3l * !'$ 326
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
A! $#%# <+ " A--00/" C$#" ,$# " *"/+ $, ?'"$! $, " %'# */00 < ,,'"= ,#$7 " %/" $, " '$77!'/"$! $, *' $#%# "$ " C$#" $, ,#*" !*"/!' <" /! /,,%/=" *$#! <+ " /--00/!"
41
S$/.*t *' /%$ - -($ - $:$/.t*-' - ($/$$ %##$%&$( -5
6 . ev,an vs analdesh. ;3 * 22" 62appealable . 4hah vs :hulam, "# * !4C$ ";30
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
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
42
P-/$(.$ %t H$%*'3: R0* 812
(/) R4" "$ <4!: R0 8 () O! " %/+ ,?% $# $! /!+ $"# %/+ "$ ' " /#!4 7/+ < /%@$#!% " /--00/!" */00 < /#% ! *--$#" $, " /--/0. (2) T C$#" */00 "! , " %$* !$" %*7** " /--/0 /" $!' /# " #*-$!%!" /4/!*" " /--/0 /!% ! *' '/* " /--00/!" */00 < !""0% "$ #-0+.65 A -/#"/0 %'# * ! ,,'" / %'# ,$# " -0/!",, *$ ,/# /* " -0/!",,* '/* * /''-"% /* 00 /* / %'# ,$# " %,!%/!" *$ ,/# /* " -0/!",,* '/* * %*7**% /!% , " * !$" /""/'% "# ! /--/0 $# <+ /+ $, '#$** $<@'"$! '/!!$" < '/00!4% ! " /--00/" '$#" ?aar vs hirendra. 3 * 2;. 63 4hah vs :olam !5d$ %2 * !'$ "6 65 4k. Pir vs 'minuddin. "" * 3;%
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
R= * / "$$0 "/" * *% <+ /! /44#=% -/#"+ "$ #*" / '$#" $, 0/ "$ "/ / *'$!% 0$$ /" "* %'*$! $# =#%'". R= * *% ! *"/"$!* # "# * !$ -#$=*$! ,$# /! /--/0. R= * !$" / *"/""$#+ #4" $, " -$-0 /!% * '$!*%#% / %*'#"$!/#+ #4" $, / '$#" /* " '/! #@'" " #*" ,$# / #=. R= * *$4" ! " */7 0/ '$#" ,#$7 # " $#4!/0 %'*$! '/7. T# * !$ *+*"7 $, / *'$!% #=. R= '/! < !%#"/! *$ 7$"$ <+ / '$#" $, 0/. 43 A##$%& %'( R$)*$+
R= * 7$*"0+ '$!'#!% " " '$##'"!** $, " 04/0 7/""#* $, / %'*$! #/* /! /--/0 * 7$*"0+ '$!'#!% " " '$##'"!** $, " %'*$! "*0,.
R= * ,0% ! " */7 '$#" #/* /--/0 * ,0% ! / 4# '$#".
A--/0 * / *"/""$#+ #4" $, " !%=%/0 #/* #= * / %*'#"$!/#+ #4" $, " '$#".
44 A##$%& %'( R$$$'/$6
A #4" $, /--/0 * / #4" '$!,##% $! " *"$# 0 " -$# $, #,#!' * =*"%
! " '$#". R,#!' * /0/+* 7/% "$ " H4 C$#" 0 /! /--/0 * -#,##% "$ / *-#$#
'$#" ' !% !$" !'**/#0+ < H4 C$#". T 4#$!%* $, /--/0 /# %# "/! " 4#$!%* $, #,#!'. R,#!' * 7/% ! / -!%!4 *" /--/0 $# ?'"$! -#$'%!4 ! $#%# "$ !/<0 " '$#" "$ /##= /" / '$##'" '$!'0*$! 0 /! /--/0 * -#,##% /,"# " %'# * -/**% $# /! /--/0/<0 $#%# * 7/%.
4
A##$%& %'( R$)**-'7
66 5ulla0s Civil Procedure Code, "3th Edn., 8ol. ", p. "%% 68 ibid
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
A! /--/0 0* "$ / *-#$# '$#" ' 7/+ !$" !'**/#0+ < / H4 C$#" <" /! /--0'/"$! ,$# #=*$! 0* $!0+ " H4 C$#".
A! /--/0 0* $!0+ ,#$7 /--/0/<0 $#%#* /!% %'# <" /! /--0'/"$! ,$# #=*$! '/! < 7/% $!0+ ! " #0, <+ /+ $, /--/0 "$ " H4 C$#" * !$" /=/0/<0.
A #4" $, /--/0 * / *<*"/!"= #4" 4=! <+ *"/"". T# * !$ #4" $, #=*$!. I" * $!0+ / -#=04. A -/#"+ 7/+ 7$= " H4 C$#" "$ !=$ "* #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! $# " H4 C$#" 7/+ $, "* $! 7$"$! ?#'* #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! <" " -$# * %*'#"$!/#+.
A! /--/0 /
T 4#$!%* $, /--/0 /!% #=*$! /# %,,#!". A! /--0'/"$! ! #=*$! '/! 0 $!0+ $! " 4#$!% $, @#*%'"$! /!% " H4 C$#" ! ?#'* $, "* #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! * !$" / '$#" $, /--/0 $! / *"$! $, 0/ $# ,/'". I! /! /--/0 " '$#" /* " -$# "$ %'% <$" *"$!* $, ,/'" /!% 0/.
S'"$! 6 %$* !$" ## "/" "# *$0% < /! /--0'/"$! ! #=*$!. T H4 C$#" '/! 7$= $, "* $! /''$#% ! ?#'*!4 #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$!. I! '/* $, /--/0 "# 7*" < / 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 ,0% <,$# " */7 '/! < '$!*%#% <+ " /--00/" '$#".
A! **!"/0 %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$! *
69 ibid
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
/"=# -$#* " #=*$!/0 /"$#"+ 7/+ $# 7/+ !$" /= " /* !$" " -$# "$ #= " =%!' !0** " *"/"" ?-#**0+ '$!,#* $! " "/" -$#.6 4
C-'/&.*-'
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’" /#* ! /%=#* %'*$! * 4=! <" $! " %/+ *" * !*"""% .. -#$'%!4* '$77!'% #4" "$ /--/0 4" '$!,##%. T* " '/! < */% " R4" "$ /--/0 * /--/0 *<*"/!"= #4" =*"% ! -/#"* ,#$7 " %/" *" !*"""%.
6 4tate o9 Kerala v. K.5. Charia 'bdidla @ Co., '.&.*. "#6% 4.C. "%(%.
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
B--= $$$'/$>
".Tak/ani C. K., Civil Procedure, =th ed., Eastern ook Company, 2"; 2.
5ahmud +aAedd)
3.
5ahbudul &slam) a/ o9 Civil Procedure, ed.2nd , 8olume 2 !or 2"r. 6 to end$
;.
5d. 'bdul
%.
'. 5 5oniruAAaman, Civil Procedure Code, 3rd ed., !haka) 4hams Publications, 2=
6.
5ulla0s Civil Procedure Code, "3th Edn., 8ol. ", p. =%%.
=.
The Code o9 Civil Procedure, "#(
(.
5d. 'bul Kalam 'Aad, The Code o9 Ci vil Procedure, 3rd ed., !haka) ipi a/ ook
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
