complete case along with personal opinion has been discussed here.Full description
Full description
gggggg
Full description
dashman company case solution. Prof. Reena shah EDI Ahmedabad.Full description
Saxonville Company Ltd. case study writeup
Full description
Emerson Electric Company
Company Background • Emerso Emerson n is a diversif diversified ied US US Fortun Fortune e 100 congl conglome omerat rate e consisting of over 50 autonomous divisions • It has has 200 manu manufac factur turing ing loca locatio tion n worldw worldwide ide & 76 76 of them locate in 15 countries outside US • Accord According ing to Forb Forbes es magazi magazine’ ne’s s industr industry y analysis analysis,, 83% of Emerson products held the no. 1 or 2 position in their domestic markets • To implem implement ent its its strategi strategic c move towar towards ds global global produ products cts & markets, Emerson redesign existing product lines & create new products to meet world market requirements while maintaining domestic market dominance • Goal Goal – increas increase e share share of new produc products ts to to 20% 20% of tota totall sales
Company Background • Emerson’s CEO adopts “pay-as-you-go” principle – if a division anticipates a shortfall in its annual sales goal of 15% growth, it has to implement cost-cutting program to protect profitability • He also develops “Best Cost Producer Strategy” – achieving the lowest cost consistent with highest attainable quality & performance • 3 major Emerson’s product categories – industrial & commercial components, consumer products, defense/government components
Air Comfort Products Division • Air Comfort Products (ACP) Division – a small division in consumer products category established in 1895 to provide a variety of ceiling, exhaust and ventilation fans to a network of independent wholesalers & retailes in US Domestic Ceiling Fan Market
• The market surged during the oil shocks of the 1970s as consumers used ceiling fans to circulate air & cool their homes & offices in an energy-efficient manner • At the peak, 18 million fans sold at a price over $75/unit • Due to stabilization of oil prices & raising competition, the market becomes seasonal & mature • The current market demand ranges from 11-13 million at an average retail price of under $40/unit
Air Comfort Products Division Domestic Ceiling Fan Market
• Retailers orders placed in early spring for coming summer months • All ceiling fans sold are partially assembled & require minor on-site assembly ACP Product Line
• ACP markets 2 ceiling fan lines – Northwind & 1985 • All ACP fans are marketed with superior features such as heavy-duty motor for longer life-time, metal hanging system for extra safety • Price range for Emerson’s fans - $100-175
Air Comfort Products Division ACP Product Line
• Northwind – a lower end model assembled by an independent Taiwanese vendor & shipped complete to ACP’s DC – a full-time ACP auditor is assigned to the vendor facility to assure quality & timeliness of shipments • 1895 model – a high end model assembled in US – due to cost pressure, many components purchased from Hong Kong & Taiwan – most of the parts are gathered together & shipped to ACP assembly plant in a kit referred to as “subpack”
Subpack Production • A subpack consists of a polyfoam package containing the fan outer housing, flanges, & hanging system • While many vendors may be involved in supplying various part sin the subpack, the lead vendor is responsible for supplying the subpack in specified quantities • ACP assign an auditor to the lead vendor to monitor quality standards & minimize sourcing disruptions • Typical subpack shipment size – 2000 to 4000 units • Subpack demand for the current year is 30000 units • Given acceptable quality, ACP select the lead vendor based on the delivered cost, which is the sum of purchase cost, shipping & insurance cost & import duties
3 Major Concerns on Current Sourcing Subpack quality
• 4 weeks shipment transit time from Taiwanese vendor to US assembly plant • Occasionally experience missing & defective components in subpacks which cause product delays Sourcing flexibility
• ACP exposes to some degree of political risk in Taiwan as majority of foreign outsourcing concentrated in there Currency exchange rates
• USD has been weakening against Taiwan dollar (NTD) & contracts are paid in NTD • Appreciating NTD - 40-to1 in 84 rose to 31-to1 in 87
Sourcing/Production Alternatives • There are alternatives for sourcing 1895 model fans • All of them involve a vendor switch, ACP need either – to build inventory to a level high enough to last until the alternative source can produce acceptable subpacks, or – to continue orders with the current vendor on asneeded basis • Current seasonal inventory levels sufficient for 6 months wholesalers orders
Sourcing/Production Alternatives 1. Continue with current Taiwanese vendor
• • • • • •
The current vendor is a family owned, controlled & managed company Lack of sophistication & control – manual plating line As a lead vendor purchase parts from other Taiwanese companies to produce the subpacks Transportation mode – shipment sent in containers by sea & then by rail to ACP Quality problems – colour variations, scratches in the painted & plated parts of the housings Quality problems alone not serious enough to justify switching to an unproven vendor
Sourcing/Production Alternatives 2. Change to Alternative Taiwanese vendor
• • • •
Another Taiwanese vendor has shown keen interest in supplying subpacks to ACP It is a much more vertically integrated & centralized company with an automated plating line Currently running well below its capacity - has sufficient capacity for subpack production Its quotation is about 15% lower than that of the current vendor
Sourcing/Production Alternatives 3. Integrate the Assembly Process in America
• •
Unused space available in ACP US plant for production Materials contributed the great majority of cost in the manufacturing of subpacks • Material costs in US & Taiwan are roughly the same • US labour cost is about 3-4 times of Taiwan cost • To estimate the benefits of this option, ACP needs to – Estimate the productivity differences – Determine whether loss of subpack volume change the shipping rate of other ACP imports from Taiwan – Estimate savings on pipe-line inventory, & on inspecting & auditing vendor
Sourcing/Production Alternatives 4. Establish Sourcing in Mexico
• •
• •
• •
ACP has a sister division running assembly operations in a free trade zone along US-Mexico border Mexican sources for subpack materials are either nonexistent or extremely expensive => ACP need to purchase & ship them over to Mexico US labour cost is about 9 times of Mexico’s labour cost Mexico workers paid in peso & ACP has to purchase peso at government-controlled exchange rate which can be very different from the market rate Sharp peso depreciation – drop from 201-to1 in 84 to 1344-to-1 in 87 High inflation rate in Mexico
Case Discussions • Why ACP outsource the subpacks?
• What are the critical issues that ACP needs to consider in its outsourcing decision?