How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Naturally fractured reservoirs
Part 2 - How to Character Characterize ize a Fractured Reservoir?
232, Avenue Napoléon Bonaparte P.O. BOX 213 92502 Rueil-Malmaison son France Phone: Phone : +33 1 47 08 80 00 Fax: Fax: +33 1 47 08 41 85
[email protected]
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @ @
How to characterize fractured fractured reservoirs ? MAIN OUTLINES
METHODOLOGY
BOREHOLE SCALE DATA: - Core Core dat data a - BH BHII data data - Cores to to BHI calibratio calibration n - Statistical Statistical fracture fracture analysis analysis
2
INTERWELL SCALE DATA - Outcr Outcrop ops s - Seismic Seismic analys analysis is - Geomechanic Geomechanical al models models Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
2
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 1
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir?
Methodology to characterize fractured reservoirs Fracture analysis Data integration: conceptual model
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
3
Data Integration for Fracture Network Modelling
Production Tests
Core data
L
0
75
150
225
3845
3846
3847
3848
3849
3850
Mud Losses
Image Logs
Geologic Models l b a Wireline Logs
Outcrops
Seismic At Attributes
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
n a r F p i c i e B @
4
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir?
Methodology to characterize fractured reservoirs Fracture analysis Data integration: conceptual model
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
3
Data Integration for Fracture Network Modelling
Production Tests
Core data
L
0
75
150
225
3845
3846
3847
3848
3849
3850
Mud Losses
Image Logs
Geologic Models l b a Wireline Logs
Outcrops
Seismic At Attributes
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
n a r F p i c i e B @
4
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
FRACA workflow WELL DAT DATA :
Core data, Logs
(GR, NPHI, …), BHI / DSI
Fracture analysis
OUTCROPS GEOLOGIC MODEL facies, porosity, matrix K
Fracture modeling Joints, fault related fractures, sub seismic faults
SEISMIC DATA – GEOMECHANICS Fault map, Seismic horizons, Seismic attribute maps, Stress/Strain maps
MULTI SCENARIO fracture length, fracture conductivity
DYNA DYNAMI MIC C DA DAT TA : PLT, PLT, well well test tests, s, PI, PI, Kh maps maps,, inte interf rfer eren ence ce test,productionhistory test,productionhistor y
Kf c a
b
K fx , K fy , K fz , a, b, c, φ φ f
Model validation Geological data Simulation of synthetic PLT and welltest
Kf Tensor & Matrix Block Size for Each Model Cell Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
5
How to characterize a fractured reservoir?
A. BOREH BOREHOLE OLE SCA SCALE LE DAT DATA B. INTERWEL INTERWELL L SCALE DATA DATA
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
6
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? BOREHOLE SCALE DATA 1. Cores 2. Borehole images - Microresistivity tools (FMS/FMI/STAR) - Acoustic Acoustic logs: UBI UBI / CBIL - OBM combined resistivity resistivity / acoustic logs (Earth) - Television elevision
3. Fluid flow logs - Flowmeter logs, Production Logging Tool Tool (PLT) (PLT) - Mud loggin logging, g,
4. Stress information - 4 arms calipers (breakout (breakout / washout), BHI BHI data (stress orientation) - DSI - DSI (shear wa ves anistropy) - Leak-off Leak-off tests, tests, Minifrac (stress magnitude)
5. Others - Weight on hook, ROP, …
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
7
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? BOREHOLE SCALE DATA 1. FRACTURES FROM CORE OBSERV OBSERVA ATIONS Objective 1: identify the main types of fractures that may or not impact the reservoir performances
• Natural fractures • Induced fractures • Other features
Objective 2: provide fracture morphology (aspect ratio, etc. ), orientations, intensity, aperture b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
8
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Core Quality
1
2
3
4
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
9
Tectonic fractures fractures – joints in quartzitic reservoir reservoir Joints form with a maximum stress oriented parallel to the joint surface
Open fractures
Oil staining staining « open fractures fractures » Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
10
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-O ADM A-OPCO PCO - from 06 to 07 of Januar January y 2008 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part Part 2A - Page Page 5
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Tectonic fractures – Partly open and cemented fractures in tight bed
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
11
Tectonic fractures - Breccia
Sandstone Carbonate Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
12
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 6
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Faults - Evidences of faults in cores
The possible presence of a fault in the red inset is showed by: -The drastic contact between limestones (right) and shaly mudstones (left); -The core in the red inset is highly broken Fault damaged zone / fault core zone -Some pieces in the broken zone show striated surfaces, with slickensides
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
13
Early diagenetic fractures
Compaction « hair-like » fractures
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
14
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 7
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Early diagenetic fractures
The thin planar fractures only affect the central bed (early diagenesis criteria) Facies are shaly limestones Those fractures always exhibit a low aspect ratio (Length/width < 100 )
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
15
Early diagenetic cemented fractures
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
16
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 8
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Early diagenetic features
Cracks associated with dolomitic beds
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
17
Diagenetic features: stylolites Stylolite related fractures observed on cores
Tectonic fractures
Tension gashes Paleo-minimum stress direction
Stylolite peaks Tight zone related to pressuresolution
Stylolite
Fracture
overburden b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
18
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 9
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Diagenetic features: stylolites
1 cm thick Stratigraphic stylolite
Associated tension gashes b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
19
Diagenetic features: stylolites
Associated fracture
20 cm thick Stratigraphic stylolite
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
20
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 10
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Diagenetic features: micro-stylolites
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
21
Stylolite related fractures Tension gashes (indicated by the white arrows) associated to the micro-stilolites.
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
22
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 11
11
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Artefact related breaks Plug induced fracture
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
23
Artefact related breaks
Disking 100% (1 cm)
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
24
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 12
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Artefact related breaks Examples of “not conventional” core disking
This photograph shows that disking is an obvious artifact: the core external surface is not affected by the slicing.
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
25
Artefact related breaks Examples of “not conventional” core disking
comma-shaped disking
Artificial breaks >> core disking
post-slabbing desegregation. Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
26
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 13
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Example of core description sheets
GENERAL
DISKING
C o r e N u m b e r
D e p t h d r i l . T O P
B o x e s
C o r e q u a l i t y
1
2
3
4
V i s u a l S a t .
5
A f f e c t e d t h i c k .
A v e r . d i s k t h i c k n .
%
cm
6a
6b
STYLOLITES S m a l l s t r a t i . S t y l .
C l a s s 5
D a m p e n e d S t y l .
M i c r o s t y l o l i t e s
General information, disking, Stylolite related fractures
A mp . N um . C um . A mp . A ff ect . % C um . A mp . 7
8
9
10
FRACTURE RELATED FEATURES
Fracture information
C E M E N T E D
P A R T . C E M E N T .
U N C E M E N T E D
u mb le ng th n um b l e ng th n um b l e ng th 11
12
D I P
d eg . to c or e axi s
13
14
W I D T H
T I P S
F R A C T U R E T Y P E
m m U /L /B S /X/ Y/ Z 15
16
17
S T A I N I N G
P 18
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
27
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? BOREHOLE SCALE DATA
2. FRACTURES FROM BHI DATA • • • •
Basis of fracture picking Data QC Tool resolution Cores to BHI calibration • Statistical analysis of fractures • Fracture density log • The main types of fractures from BHI • Bed thickness record ? b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
28
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 14
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Principle of fracture picking on BHI images
Fractured zone on acoustic log
Sinusoide on BHI log
Fracture plane Bedding plane
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
29
Tool resolution
Resistivity
Accoustic
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
30
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 15
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The different features on BHI Faults identification
Vertical displacement along the fracture plane
Fault breccia
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
31
The different features on BHI Natural fractures identification
Conductive “open” fractures b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Resistive “closed” fractures Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
32
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 16
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The different features on BHI Induced fractures identification
Induced fractures
Breakouts Induced fractures
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
33
BHI and Maximum horizontal stress
Breakouts
Induced fractures
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
SHmax
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
34
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 17
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Cores to BHI calibration Tectonic stylolite in core and in BHI image
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
35
Cores to BHI calibration
Shaly intervalle
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
36
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 18
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Cores to BHI calibration
Low amplitude fractures
CLOSED FRACTURE Here the fracture is filled with soft material (gypse) Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
37
Cores to BHI calibration Broken zone in the core
The core broken zone correspo nd to a N030E oriented fracture swarm on borehole imagery Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
38
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 19
1
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Cores to BHI calibration Correlation between facies (shaly limestones & tight limestones) and FMI images
Shaly limestones
Tight limestones
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
39
Example of fracture analysis (1/5)
1
Polar projection of fractures
2
Density of points after bias correction
3 b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
40
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 20
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Example of fracture analysis (2/5) Upper fracture zones and FMI image
CLUSTER
1
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
41
Example of fracture analysis (3/5) Validation with cores Fault
CLUSTER
1
Fractures are partially open
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
42
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 21
21
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
xamp e o racture ana ys s Example of sub-horizontal fractures
DIFFUSE
2 Projection polaire des fractures
3 b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
43
Example of fracture analysis (5/5) Validation with cores Fractures are partially open
BRECCIA
2
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
44
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 22
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Statistical fracture analysis (1/3) Statistical analysis of borehole imagery interpretation
Multi-well integrated analysis Fracture set identification / characterisation Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
45
Statistical fracture analysis (2/3) BOREHOLE SCALE DATA
Statistical analysis of borehole imagery interpretation Avg. Spacing
N70E
Avg. Strike
Fisher Strike Avg. Dip
Fisher Dip
0,5m
N70
5,2
85
6,6
N110E
0,49m
N105
3,3
85
4,6
N20E
0,46m
N23
2,6
88
3,7
Multi well integrated analysis Fracture sets identification / characterisation Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
46
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 23
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Statistical fracture analysis (3/3) The fracture density log
4
Mean strike=N081
Well by well integrated analysis Fracture type identification / characterisation Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
47
The fracture density log
The bias correction
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
48
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 24
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Drivers on fracture density
FACIES VARIATION
DEVIATED WELL
BEDDING DIP VARIATION
BEDDING THICKNESS VARIATION
NO-DATA INTERVALS
FRACTURE SWARMS
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
49
The main scales of fractures Cluster analysis: fracture swarm / fault 1
2
1 2 3 3 4
4 b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
50
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 25
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The main scales of fractures Cluster analysis: diffuse fractures / joints
6
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
51
The main scales of fractures Examples of diffuse fractures in outcrops Fractures extension from metric to decametric
Vertical variations of the diffuse fracture distribution are generally due to lithology and bed thickness.
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
52
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 26
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Influence of lithology Testing the relationship between lithology and fracture density
Main fractured intervals are found in tight sandstones
3 sets of fractures: Mean strike N071, mean dip = 82° Mean strike N107, mean dip = 83° Mean strike N032, mean dip = 62°
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
53
Influence of lithology
Shalyness
has a large impact on fracture density Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
54
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 27
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Influence of lithology
Shaly interval Fracture density b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
55
Influence of bed thickness
Diffuse fractures are bed limited Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
56
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 28
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Beds thickness / fracture density relationship 1/2
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
57
Beds thickness / fracture density relationship 2/2 FD = Fracture density
Conceptual model of fracture distribution Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
58
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 29
2
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Strain partitioning in a fold Fractures produced by extension are pure extensional and open fractures Fractures produced by compression are closed, stylolitic and/or partially open.
Present-day geo-structural setting around well A
Well A
Extension
Compression
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
59
Fracture aperture from cores/BHI data Thin section analysis
BHI data
Fracture aperture 35
4000
30
3500 3000
25
3
Poiseuille law
2500
s e 20 l p m a S 15
2000 1500
10
1000
5
500
0
0
-6
C = e / (12*0,98*10 ) C = hydraulic conductivity in mD.m e = fracture aperture
Aperture (microns)
Limitations: questionable fracture aperture estimation that may have a very strong impact on fluid flow computation Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
60
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 30
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? INTERWELL SCALE DATA
Outcrops Seismic data Geomechanical models Others
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
61
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? INTERWELL SCALE DATA
A posteriori fault and fracture detection From outcrop analysis From seismic data • conventional picking • surface attributes • seismic facies analysis • seismic anisotropy
Geomechanical modelling geological times • curvature based approach • geomechanical based b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
62
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 31
31
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Outcrop analogs analysis
SWARMS JOINTS
Usefull observation to determine the type of fractures, the fracture chronology Limitations due to decompaction and weathering: • questionnable fracture densities and fracture length measurements • cannot be used for fracture aperture Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
63
Seismic data analysis
Objectives: • To identify fault AND sub-seismic faults in the reservoir
• To define the geometrical properties of the fault pattern (for extrapolation to lower scale)
• To assess their impact on the reservoir fluid flow behaviour b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
64
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 32
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic data analysis CONVENTIONAL PICKING
Conventional seismic picking • faults and flexures location • fault throw measurement • fault geometry
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
65
Seismic noise Spikes Top 1
Top 1
Seismic cross-section Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
66
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 33
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic data analysis Curvature methodology 1. The deformation (fault) induce a curvature (positive and negative)
2. Smoothing Horizon map
Fault plane
Positive curvature
+
Initial topography
Negative curvature
After n steps of smoothing
3. The second derivative of curvature highlights the deformation
4. The interpretation is computed between positive and negative lineaments
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
67
Impact of smoothing on curvature signal
SM=200 10 Km b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
68
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 34
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Impact of smoothing on curvature signal
SM=100 10 Km b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
69
Impact of smoothing on curvature signal
SM=50 10 Km b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
70
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 35
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Impact of smoothing on curvature signal
SM=30 10 Km b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
71
Impact of smoothing on curvature signal
SM=15 10 Km b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
72
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 36
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Impact of smoothing step on curvature signal SM=200
SM=100
10 Km
SM=50
SM=10
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
73
Seismic data analysis Large scale features interpretation : curvature analysis N Positive curvature
Negative curvature
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
74
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 37
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic data analysis The main types of curvature:
• Principal curvature (maximum of curvature) • Oriented curvature • Minimum curvature
Maximum of curvature N70 oriented curvature N160 oriented curvature Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
75
Curvature analysis
NORTH Curv min = 0
Fold or flexure
EAST Curv min
Curv max
Low curvature
Fault zone Local or regional scale
High curvature
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
76
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 38
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic data analysis
Top of the Reservoir Formation
Maximum curvature processed in Fraca®
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
77
Integration of seismic data: curvature analysis •N130E is the main trend •seismic faults (blue) •sub-seismic lineaments (yellow) •E-W is a minor (only sub-seismic lineaments)
Validation with the other seismic attributes b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
78
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 39
3
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic data analysis SEISMIC ATTRIBUTES ANALYSIS
Red
Amplitude map
Dip map illuminated from NW
Correlation map
= high amplitudes
Yellow = areas dipping toward NW
Red = areas of good correlation
Red = areas dipping away from NW Black = steep dips away from NW
Purple = poor correlation
White = medium Blue = low
“ “
A number of linear features occur on all 3 maps, many of which can be interpreted as faults; generally the shorter the lineament the less confident the interpretation Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
79
Seismic data analysis SEISMIC FACIES ANALYSIS
Objective : Analyze the character of seismic traces and relate, if possible, its variations to geological variations of the reservoir.
Deliverables: Maps or cubes of « seismic facies with the associated interpretation.
Methodology: Statistical methodology based on principal component analysis that includes pattern recognition techniques.
Previous seismic interpretation not required Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
80
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 40
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic facies analysis (1/4) Selection of relevant seismic attributes 1250
1250
1250
N
1250
N
1000
1000
750
High
1250
1250
1250
N
1000
1000
1000
1000
750
750
750
750
500
500
500
500
250
250
250
250
High
1000
1000
750
750
750
500
500
500
500
250
250
250
250
High
Low cdp line
cdp line
150 250 350 450
150 250 350 450
Cur vature
Dissimilarity
1250
N
Low
cdp line
Low
150 250 350 450
cdp line
150 250 350 450
Dip
Edge b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
81
Seismic facies analysis (2/4) Seismic facies definition Statistical segmentation
Seismic facies 3
dip ×
Edge
Dissimilarity
A3
×× ××× × × × ×
× ×× ×× ×× ×
Seismic facies 1
Ap
curvature
A2
×× ××
A1
Seismic facies 2
Attribute space
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
82
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 41
41
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Seismic facies analysis (3/4) Seismic facies definition facies 3
Attribute #3
×× ××× × × × ×
Attribute #p
Attribute #2
× ×× ×× ×× × facies 1
KS1
×× ××
KS3
KS2
Attribute #1
facies 2
Facies 1 Facies 1
Facies 2
Facies 3
Facies 2 Facies 3 Facies 4 Facies 5
Facies 5
Facies 6
Facies Facies 4
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
83
Seismic facies analysis (4/4) Mapping of seismic facies that shows fracture occurrence Seismic facies
5 km Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
84
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 42
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Fault geometry analysis Fault length analysis
T hin li nes sho w the portio ns of the curves which fit li nes wi th slop es of C . Because these data were collected f ro m t wo -d ime nsi on al s amp le s o f t hr ee -d ime nsi on al vo lu mes , e qua ti on ( 1) an d t he d at a i n f ig ur e d es cr ib e t wo dimensional fault populations. The actual (three-dimensional) power-law exponent for small faults is C + 1 (Marrett & Allmendinger 1991) . Also shown are the areas (A) in square kilometers of the maps from which the data were collected.
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
85
Fault geometry analysis
Fault displacement analysis
Results of the combined analysis of nine data sets (lines), with the source data (symbols) b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
86
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 43
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
Fault geometry analysis ILLUSTRATION OF THE FRACTAL DIMENSION ON THE FAULT PATTERN
Fractal dim. = 1.4 Fractal dim. = 1.6 Fractal dim. = 2 High values increase the lateral dispersion Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
87
Fault geometry analysis
2. Compartments analysis - From geometric criteria: comparison of reservoir thickness and fault throws (fault displacement contours ) - From fault surface properties: clay smearing related to throw magnitude and to shalyness of reservoir blocks - Compartmentalization also controlled by geomechanical criteria: (reverse faults are more likely seali ng; controlled by present-day stress)
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
88
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 44
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? INTERWELL SCALE DATA
A posteriori faults and fractures detection From outcrop From seismic • conventional picking • surface attributes • seismic facies analysis • shear waves analysis
Geomechanical modelling geological times • curvature based approach • elastoplastic approach b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
89
Geomechanical modelling
TIME
CURVATURE ANALYSIS
TOTAL DEFORMATION
T5
No deformation
T4
Max. of deformation
T3 T2
Deformation = Curv.(T1) – Curv.(T2)
T1
A coupled back-striping / curvature approach is required b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
90
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 45
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The conceptual fracture model
N
Fractures corridors
Fault
?
?
?
? ?
Diffuse fractures
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
10 m
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
91
The conceptual fracture model
Not fractured well (2) Not fractured well (1)
Fracture swarms
Faulted well
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
92
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 46
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The conceptual fracture model 1. The reservoir unit was fractured by means of large-scale fractures (faultrelated) (Northern Africa)
Fractures were clustered along the main faults and developed in spite of the lithological variations. Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
93
The conceptual fracture model 2. The reservoir unit was intensely fractured by means of diffuse and largescale fractures (Mexico)
Two proven main geological drivers on lateral and vertical distribution of diffuse fold-related fractures: lithology and the structure. Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
94
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 47
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
The conceptual fracture model
Locally connectedfractures
Regionaldiffusefractures
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
95
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? FRACTURE MODELLING Objective:
To integrate fracture characterisation results for reservoir engineering purposes:
1. to predict the distribution of fracture sets properties w ithin the reservoir volume 2. to build 3D models of the fracture network for fluid flow computation: - to calibrate fracture hydraulic properties - to compute large-scale flow properties (input for field-scale flow simulation) b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
96
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 48
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to model a fractured reservoir? Reservoir scale
Simulation cell scale
Well scale 1m 5 km
•Faults [Sub Seismic faults Swarms]
100 m
•Joints •Swarms •Faults b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
97
How to model a fractured reservoir? The choice of the FRACTURE MODELLING APPROACH depends on fracture SCALE :
FAULTS (km ; throw: >10m) Large-scale fractures
sub-seismic faults (100 m-1 km ; throw: 0-20m) and
Global (reservoir-scale) discrete fracture model
fracture swarms (10 m -1 km; no throw) Small-scale fractures Matrix anisotropy
JOINTS (cm - 10 m)
Local discrete fracture model
microfractures (mm - cm) b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
98
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 49
4
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to model a fractured reservoir? FRACTURE MODELLING OF LARGE SCALE FEATURES Procedure: 1. Integration of deterministic information - basic surfaces (geologic horizons, faults) are built from sets of points provided by the seismic - relationships between these surfaces are specified (according to faulting history, …)
2. Extrapolation at lower scales : sub-seismic fault (or fracture swarms) modelling - use of a statistical discrete modelling method based on the fault geometric properties . fault orientation map, . distribution law of fault lengths, . fractal dimension.
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
99
How to model a fractured reservoir? Modelling of sub-seismic faults
3D SEISMIC
Major faults used as deterministic modelling constraints: •2 sets •1 orientation map for each set b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
100
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 50
5
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to model a fractured reservoir? CONDITIONING the sub-seismic fault model From 3D seismic attributes picking
To the map of initiation probability for the stochastic modelling of sub-seismic faults
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
101
How to model a fractured reservoir? MODELLING of sub-seismic faults Seismic-derived (sub-seismic) fault
Fault map
Constrained stochastic modelling
Simulated fault network
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
102
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 51
51
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to model a fractured reservoir? SMALL-SCALE FRACTURES MODELLING Procedure: 1. Analysis and quantification of fractures from wellbore information: - distribution of fracture azimuths fracture sets
and
dips (Schmitt diagram,…)-->identification of
- fracture density (m2/m3) and fracture spacing (measurement depends on the relative orientation of fracture set and wellbore trajectory), in relation with lithology - identification of fracture swarms (versus systematic joints)]
2. Building a RESERVOIR DISTRIBUTION MODEL of f racture properties (orientation, density,..) : the global geocellular fracture model - by interpolation of property values between wells - by indexing fracture density: on lithology (global geocellular facies model) on proximity to faults indexing fracture density and orientation on local curvature. Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
103
How to model a fractured reservoir? Curvature analysis Geomechanics Interpolation between wells
Conventional Geo-cellular model
Maps of fracture properties
Spatial distribution of fractures Discrete model of faults
Local model at cell size
Modeling subseismic faults Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
104
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 52
5
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to model a fractured reservoir? Discrete fracture model Example of stylolite related fractures modelled at cell size
Top View b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Side View Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
105
How to model a fractured reservoir? 3D view of the diffuse fractures generated by Fraca
N150
N140
N080
100x100 m cell Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
106
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 53
5
How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir ?
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? CONCLUSIONS (1) Fracture analysis and fracture modelling Identify the main type of fractures, Identify the geological drivers on fracture distribution Qualitatively asses the role of fractures on fluid flow Prepare upscaling phase through adapted modelling of objects with various scales
All relevant data must be integrated in a rigourous package A transversal expertise to be shared by geologists, geophysicists and reservoir engineers b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
107
How to characterize a fractured reservoir? CONCLUSIONS (2) 1. Borehole scale data • A carefull expertise of cores with BHI data is important to identify the main tectonic features that may have an impact on the reservoir
Discriminate between tectonic fractures, induced fractures, etc...
• BHI data provide essential informations on fractures orientation
- Statistical analysis of the main fracture sets, fracture orientations, fracture dips, fracture density and statistical dispersion - Identification of the fracture types Part 2 - How to Characterize a Fractured Reservoir?
b a l n a r F p i c i e B @
108
BEICIP-FRANLAB
NATURALLY FRACTURED RESERVOIRS ADMA-OPCO - from 06 to 07 of January 2008 Copyright© 2008. Beicip-Franlab - All rights reserved
Part 2A - Page 54
5