ASME VIII Div. 1- 5 External Pressure

External pressure calculations

UG – 28 Thickness of Shells and Tubes Under External Pressure Page 24 Section VIII (a) Rules for the design of shells and tubes under external pressure given in this Division are limited to cylindrical shells, with or without stiffening rings, tubes, and spherical sp herical shells….. (b) The symbols defined below are used in the procedures of this paragraph: factor determined determined from Fig. G in Subpart Sub part 3 of Section II, Part D and used to enter the applicable material chart in Subpart 3 of Section II, Part D…… = factor determined from the applicable material chart in Subpart 3 of Section II, Part Par t D for maximum design metal temperature, psi . Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-E CIC-Egypt.com gypt.com

Eng. Ibrahim Eldesoky

UG – 28 D o o = outside diameter of cylindrical shell course or tube, in. E = Not on exam. L = total length, in. (mm), of a tube between tubesheets, or design length of a vessel section between lines of support (see Fig. UG-28.1). A line of support is: (1) a circumferential line on a head…. Not on exam! (2) a stiffening ring……. Not on exam! (3) a jacket closure ……. Not on exam! (4) a cone-to-cylinder cone-to-cylinder Not Not on exam! P = external design pressure, psi Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-E CIC-Egypt.com gypt.com


UG – 28 P a = calculated value of maximum allowable external working pressure for the assumed value of t, psi R o = outside radius of spherical shell, in. t = minimum required thickness of cylindrical shell or tube, or spherical shell, in. t s = nominal thickness of cylindrical shell or tube, in. Beginning with UG-28(c) there are step by step instructions for working these problems. We will go through these steps one at a time.

Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 (c) Cylindrical Shells and Tubes . The required minimum thickness of a cylindrical shell or tube under external pressure, either seamless or with longitudinal butt joints, shall be……. 1. Cylinders having Do /t values > or = 10: Step 1 Assume a value for t and determine the ratios L/Do and Do /t. * You do not assume a value for thickness (t) on the exam, it will be given in the stated problem for the external pressure shell or tube calculation. As will the (Do) Diameter Outside and the (L) Length in other words all that is needed to solve the problem will be provided. Looking at an example, we can start learning this process. Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28

1. Cylinders having Do /t values > or = 10:

Step 1 Assume a value for t and determine the ratios L/Do and Do /t. Example: The cylinder has corroded to a wall thickness of 0.530”, its length is 120” and the outside diameter is 10”. It operates at 500 oF So then; Temperature = 500 oF t = 0.530” L = 120” Do = 10” Calculate Do/t = 10/.530 = 18.8 call it 19 (no need to be exact) Now we do L/Do = 120/10 = 12 Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 2 Enter Fig. G in Subpart 3 of Section II, Part at the value of L/Do determined in Step 1. For values of L/Do greater than 50, enter the chart at a value of L/Do = 50. For values of L/Do less than 0.05, enter the chart at a value of L/Do = 0.05. In our example problem we must go up the left side of the Fig. G until we reach the value of L/Do of 12. Using the chart we have the following;


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 3 Move horizontally to the line for the value Do /t determined in Step 1.... Which in our case was 19, but we will round this to 20 since these problems are not meant to be extremely precise. So now we have.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 3. Continued. From this point of intersection move vertically downward to determine the value of factor A. Which gives us the following;


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 4 Using the value of A calculated in Step 3, enter the applicable material chart in Subpart 3 of Section II, Part D for the material under consideration. Move vertically to an intersection with the material/temperature line for the desig temperature see UG-20). Interpolation may be made between lines for intermediate temperatures. In cases where the value of A falls to the right of the end of the material /temperature line, assume an intersection with the horizontal projection of the upper end of the material/temperature line. To use the next figure we enter at the bottom at the value Factor A = .0028 and then up to our temperature of 500 oF. Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com


Factor A = .0028 and then up to our temperature of 500 oF.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Factor B is 12,000. Plug it into the formula below and we have our External Pressure allowable, Pa Which will be; 4B Pa = 3( Do ) t

Pa =

4 x 12,000

48,000

3 x 20

60


Www. CIC-Egypt.com

800 psi


UG – 28 All that work just to find Factor B is and plug it into the simple formula below. 4B Pa = 3( Do ) t As regards the final answers to these problems, because of the difficulty of being precise with the Fig. G there will always be some difference from one person to the next in the determination of Factor A. This is allowed for on the exam by listing choices of answers that are in a range of +/- 5%. In our previous problem the answer was 800 psi, on the exam the correct choice would have been offered as 760 to 840 psi, i.e. Answer Range: 760 – 840 psi Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com


To Summarize UG-28 External calculations depart significantly from internal calculations simply because under external pressure the vessel is being crushed. Internal pressure wants to tear the vessel apart. Because of the crushing or buckling load, the Length the Outside Diameter and the Thickness of the vessel are important. External pressure problems are based on the thickness of the shell to the outside diameter ratios. There are two types of external pressure calculations, the type we will use is when the O.D to (Do) thickness ratio (t) is greater than 10 and the other type, not on the test, is when it is less than 10 .


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


To Summarize UG-28 In order to solve these types of problems two charts will be required. The first chart Fig. G is used to find a value called Factor A and then Factor A is used to find a Factor B in the second material specific chart. The value of Factor B found is the number needed to solve the problem using the formula given in paragraph UG-28 (c)(1) step 6. As stated in the API 510 Body of Knowledge, these charts will be provided in the exam body, IF an external calculation is given on the examination. One more problem. Find the allowed external pressure on an existing vessel of a known thickness with a Do/t ratio > 10.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG-28 Problem: A vessel is operating under an external pressure, the operating temperature is 500° F. The outside diameter of the vessel is 40 inches. Its length is 70 inches. The vessel’s wall is 1.25 inches thick and is of SA-515-70 plate. Its specified min. yield is 38,000 psi. What is the maximum external pressure allowed? Givens: Temp = 500° F t = 1.25 L = 70 inches D0 = 40 inches


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28

From UG-28 (c)Cylindrical Shells and Tubes . The required minimum thickness of a shell or a tube under external pressure, either seamless or with longitudinal butt joints, shall be determined by the following procedure. (1) Cylinders having a Do

Testing to see if this paragraph applies: Cairo Inspection Company (CIC)

Www. CIC-Egypt.com

values

10

t


UG – 28• D o t

=

40

= 32

1.25

Step 1 Our value of Do is 40 inches and L is 70 inches. We will use these to determine the ratio of: L 70 =

D o

= 1.75

40

Step 2 Enter the Factor A chart at the value of 1.75 determined above. Step 3 Then move across horizontally to the curve Do/t = 32. Then down from this point to find the value of Factor A which is .0045


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 4. Using our value of Factor A calculated in Step 3, enter the Factor B (CS-2) chart on the bottom. Then vertically to the material temperature line given in the stated problem (in our case 500 o F).


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 5 Then across to find the value of Factor B . We find that Factor B is approximately 13000 . Step 6 Using this value of Factor B , calculate the value of the maximum allowable external pressure P a using the following formula: 4B Pa = 3( Do ) t

Pa =

4x13,000 3(32)

=

52,000 96

= 541.66 psi

Answer Range: 514 – 568 psi


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


Class Quiz UG-28 A vessel under external pressure has been found to a thickness of 1.123 ". The vessel is 8'-2" long and operates at a temperature of 300 oF. The vessel’s outside diameter is 54 inches. It is made of a material with a minimum yield of 30,000 psi. Presently the external working pressure is 350 psi. May this vessel continue to operate in accordance with the Code? Show all work and quote code paragraphs used.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 (1) Cylinders having:

Do

values

10

t

Testing to see if this paragraph applies: D o t

=

54

= 48.08

1.123

Step 1 Our value of Do is 54 inches and L is 98 inches. We will use these to determine the ratio of: L 98 =

D o

= 1.81

54

Step 2 Enter the Factor A chart at the value of 1.8 determined above.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28

Step 3. Then move across horizontally to the curve at approximately Do/t = 48. Then down from this point to find the value of Factor A which is approximately .0022


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


UG – 28 Step 4 Using our value of Factor A calculated in Step 3, enter the Factor B (CS-2) chart on the bottom, then vertically up to the material temperature line given in the stated problem (in our case 300 o F). Step 5 Next step is across to find the value of Factor B . We find that Factor B is approximately 15000 . Note due to the variance in the reading of the charts answers and values may vary, but should be within a 5% range of the solution.


Www. CIC-Egypt.com



Www. CIC-Egypt.com


ASME VIII Div. 1- 5 External Pressure

Recommend Documents