Grey Area

!"#$ &"#& '&(&) *#"*&+&,&- '. .-'/-#0.& /(#1 2&)2&-! ,#0.3 *456478 09:;< &=:>97>?< @>
'.HH#"#-3 *#"0*#I3.J#K '.HH#"#-3 I/-I(@0./-

FL *#-!&-3&" FL 0;5>B?<7 ;7> N767<87>7 8B>7O?<4=7> PB479:47> P7Q7= DL 297>6 P7Q7= S;7= N5TBM M<978 P:SM UL 174:? NB4?<=7P ?BN767< P47=S?< PB4P7Q7=7>

ENTITAS BISNIS

TAX PLANNING

TAX

TAX

POLICY

LAW

TAX ADMNST

!"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$•

•

!"#$ &"#& PB4P7Q7=7> 7;7T7M ?BN:7M =B7;77>K 947>?7=?< 797: =BQ7;<7> C7>6 ; PB4P7Q7=7>K 7=7> 9B97P< S;7= 7;7 79:47> P7Q7= C7>6 NB4T7=: ?B=747>6 C7>6 N 9B4M7;7P M7T 9B4?BN:9L

!4BC &4B7 ;7P79 ; ?BN767< NB4<=:9V

FL !4BC 74B7 ;< ,@* 7L *B>6:4:? W* N7;7> NBT:8 NB4X-*W*K 7?PB= P7Q7= 797? W* P<>;7M ;5867Q:=7> =BNB4797> 97>P7 8B8N7C74 0,*,2 RL +79:M 9B8P5 PB>CB9547>[PBT7P547> P7Q7= ;< M74< 07N9: ;L 17= 797? <8N7T7> N:>67 N76< W*K N7>;<>6 797? =7?:? =BNB4797> C7>6 S;7= 8B8B>:M< ?C7479 O5487T BL -*W* W* 547>6 P46 ?:;7M 8B><>667T ;:><7K PB>6 ;7\74 M7497 N76< W* 547>6 P4
DL !4BC 74B7 ;< *7Q7= *B>6M7? 7L NL RL ;L BL

)7?7T7M 97]7N6M7? YP<>Q78 NB>;B47K ?BT6BT:747> YP4585? 87=7>K P7Q7= ;7B47MK ?7>=?76 P7Q7= ;?NZ 17497 8B>:4:9 P7Q7= A? 7=SA7 8B>:4:9 7=:>97>?6BT58P5==7> M7497 7?PB= P7Q7= 797? 655;^:? =74C7^7> C7>6 ;6 ;74< T7N7 97M:> T7T:K PB>674:M 4:6< ?BT6?:47> **M *7?7T DG )B>B>9:=7> 9B? ^7=9: :>9:= 2@3 Y_?<= 797: =5>947=Z ;?N UL !4BC 74B7 ;< **M *7?7T DF[D` 7L '<4B=?< S;7= ;<67Q< 5TBM PB4:?7M77>K B=?P794<79B ;<67Q< ;< N7^7M ?97>;74 NL !45?? :P **M *7?7T DF C7>6 S;7= =5>?K =74C7^7> ;7B47M ;6 ;< P:?79 Y9B8P79 9B4:97>6Z RL *B8595>67> **M *7?7T DF 9B4M7;7P ?B=:9: _487 ;?N aL !4BC 74B7 ;< **M *7?7T DU[D`[H<>7T 7L !45?? :P **M *7?7T DU ?BP947= N76< M7??:8B> A? _>7>R<7T TB7?<>6 NL *B8595>67> **M *7?7T D` 797? PB>6M7? ;< T:74 *U2K 2@3 7=SA<97? ;7> **M *7?7T D`X>C7 GL !4BC 74B7 ;< **7L *B>6=4B;<97> P7Q7= 87?:=7> 97>66:>6 Q7^7N 4B>9B>6K =4<9B4<7 N747>6 8B47M NL H7=9:4 *7Q7= ;B>67> 8B95;B bbK 8B>R7>9:8=7> M7467 <>RT:;B **- ;< H7=9:4 *7Q7= RL H7=9:4 *7Q7= ;<9:T67>K ?9B8PBT ;< H*K ;[ 8746<> A? =58:?K R7?M ;9 ;L )B8N7C74 **- 8B8N7>6:> ?B>;<4< ;< T:74 T5=7?< N7>6:>7> BL &?PB= **- 797? Q7?7 PB4;767>67>K =5>?<>C7?CB47M7> 7>974 R7N7>6 Y_?<= 797: ;5=:8B>Z OL *B>CB47M7> +,* ;< =7^7?7> NB4<=79[#*3# !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$• • !"#$ &"#& PB4P7Q7=7> 7;7T7M ?BN:7M =B7;77>K 947>?7=?< 797: =BQ7;<7> C7>6 ; PB4P7Q7=7>K 7=7> 9B97P< S;7= 7;7 79:47> P7Q7= C7>6 NB4T7=: ?B=747>6 C7>6 N 9B4M7;7P M7T 9B4?BN:9L H7=954 '"#$ &"#& PB4P7Q7=7> C7>6 9B4Q7;< ;7T78 ?BS7P =5>;9:= 8B>6M7? NBN7> P7Q7= PB>6M7? C7>6 B_?K ;B>67> R747V !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$FL DL UL aL @?7M7=7> PB>6M7? 9B4?BN:9 S;7= 9B487?:= PB>6B4S7> PB>6M7? C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=B>7=7> P7Q7= PB>6M7? 797: PB>6M7? C7>6 =B>7 P7Q7= ;<67>S ;B>67> PB>6M7? C7>6 S;7= =B>7 P7Q7= 797: PB>6B>77> P7Q7=>C7 ;<97>66:M=7>L 3<>66=79=7> N<7C7XN<7C7 C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> 797: N<7C7 9B49B>9: C7>6 S;7= ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> ;74< PB>6M7? =B>7 P7Q7= ;<=:47>6< ;7> ;<7T =B N<7C7XN<7C7 C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7>L *B4P7>Q7>6 Q7>6=7 ^7=9: PB>6B>77> P7Q7= 797? PB>6M7? 797: PB4PB>;B= Q7>6=7 ^7=9: N<7C7XN<7C7 C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7>L *B4S8N7>6=7> 7>9747 >7<=>C7 PB>6M7? ;B>67> NBN7> P7Q7= C7>6 8B><>6=79K 797: >7<=>C7 N<7C7 9B49B>9: ;B>67> NB4=:47>6>C7 NBN7> P7Q7=K ;7> M7?B95Z M74:? 8B8PB4NB?74 T7N7 ?B9BT7M P7Q7= PB>6M7?L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$• • )./01/2 !-.-/01 *30 213456-/01 *4<>? /#/01(&.+# 8B4:P7=7> P4<>? 6 T7c<8 ;R7>77> P7Q7=K C7>6 P7;7 :8:8>C7 8B>6:N7M N<7C7 C7>6 S;7= N5TBM ;<=:47>6=7> 8B>Q7;< N<7C7 C7>6 N5TBM ;<=:47>6=7> ;7> ?BN7T<=>C7 8B>6:N7M PB>6M7? C7>6 8B4:P7=7> 5NQB= P7Q7= 8B>Q7;< PB>6M7? C7>6 N:=7> 5NQB= P7Q7=K ;B>67> =5>?B=:B>?< 9B4Q7;<>C7 PB4:N7M7> P7Q7= 9B4:97>6 7=6:N7M7> 9B4?BN:9L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$• • 0BN767< ;7T78 NB>9:= >79:47 ;7> =B><=8797> =BP7;7 P747 PB67^7 P7?7T a 7C79 YUZ M:4:O ; :>;7>6X :>;7>6 *7Q7= *B>6M7?K PB>6M7? C7>6 N:=7> 8B4:P7=7> 5NQB= P7Q7= N76< =74C7^7>K ?BM<>667 S;7= ;6M7? 9B4?BN:9L 0BN7T<=>C7 ;74< ?:;:9 P7>;7>6 PB4:?7M77> C7>6 8B>6BT:74=7> N<7C7 9B4?BN:9K ?BR747 =58B4?<7T 8B4:P7=7> N<7C7 C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> ;74< PB>6M7?K 9B97P< NB4;7?74=7> P7?7T d 7C79 YFZ M:4:O B @>;7>6X:>;7>6 *7Q7= *B>6M7? 8B4:P7=7> N<7C7 C7>6 S;7= N5TBM ;<=:47>6=7>L &P7N ;7T78 NB>9:= >79:47 ;7> =B><=8797>K ?BPB4S ;5=9B4 ;7> 5N79 8C7K ;<:N7M 8B>Q7;< 9:>Q7>67> =B?BM797>K 87=7 NB4;7?74=7> P7?7T a 7C79 YFZ M:4:O 7 @>;7>6X:>;7>6 *7Q7= *B>6M7?K 9:>Q7>67> =B?BM797> C7>6 ; ;7T78 ;7T78 NB>9:= :7>6 9B?BN:9 8B4:P7=7> PB>6M7? C7>6 7=7> ; ; P P7?7T ` 7C79 YFZ M:4:O 7 N<7C7 9:>Q7>67> 9B?BN:9 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> ;74< PB>6M7? N4:95 PB4:?7M77>L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$4%4$,!'4$5,$- )%-&6#$-&$)B87=?<87T=7> PB>6:47>67> Y2&)-2-3-,' /#/0145,ZK <7T7M PB>67T PB8NB4<7> ;7T78 NB>9:= >79:47 Y 6"-,'# .#,#7( &(&0 *&$2#,( -, 8-/ Z =B NB>9:= 9:>Q7>67>X9:>Q7>67> C7>6 ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> ?BN767< N<7C7 ?B?:7< P4<>? ;7P79 ;<=:47>6=7> Y /#/01(&.+# Z C7>6 ;<7>:9 =B9B>9:7> PB4:>;7>6X:>;7>67> PB4P7Q7=7>L • !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$• •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aL ":87M ;<>7? =74C7^7>K ;B>67> 7T9B4>7SOV 7L *B4:?7M77> 8B>CB;<7=7> 4:87M ;<>7?L NL *B4:?7M77> 8B8NB4<=7> 9:>Q7>67> PB4:87M7>L GL 347>?P5497?< :>9:= =74C7^7>K ;B>67> 7T9B4>7SOV 7L *B4:?7M77> 8B>CB;<7=7> 85N7?L NL *B4:?7M77> 8B8NB4<=7> 9:>Q7>67> 947>?P5497? !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$`L *7=7<7> =B4Q7 =74C7^7>K ;B>67> 7T9B4>7SOV 7L *B=7<7> =B4Q7 ?BM:N:>67> ;B>67> T<>6=:>67> =<>B4Q7K 8C7 ?79P78K ?B47678 PB67^7< M59BTK P T7<>X T7<>L NL ?B47678 =74C7^7> P7;7 :8:8>C7L eL )7=7>K ;B>67> 7T9B4>7SOV 7L *B4:?7M77> 8B8NB4<=7> NB47? 797: 8B>CB;<7=7> =79B4<>6 :>9:= =74C7^7>L NL 3:>Q7>67> NB47? 797: :7>6 87=7>L fL 25>:? ;7> Q7?7 P45;:=?67> 7T9B4>7SOV 7L NL ;=7> ;7T78 97M:> NB4Q7T7>L ;=7> P7;7 T7N7 C7>6 ;<97M7>L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$)7?/9/B30 47>:E7 )70CF1F>30 • *B>C:?:97> &=SA7 9B97P ;7> 7854S?7?< 7=SA7 S;7= NB4^:Q:; C7>6 ;<7=:< 5TBM _?=:? ?BQ7= 97M:> FddG 9B4;<4< Y;:7Z 8B95;B C7<9: FL 8B95;B 674 DL 8B95;B ?7T;5 8B>:4:>L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$".3013;1/ C308 =7.;3/>30 E70830 )7?F08F> )3A3; • 0BT7<> ?BN767< PB8N7C74 P7Q7= PB4:?7M77> Q:67 ?BN767< PB8595>6 P7Q7= 9BM7;7P P • • )7?7T7M C7>6 ?B4<>6=7T< S8N:T 7;7T7M P6 NB4?7>6=:97> S;7= NB4?B;<7 ;6 P7Q7=>C7L &P7N S;7= 8B8595>6 :-(;5+/-,' (&) Y8C7 **M DUK 797? Q7?7 =5>?:T97>ZK 87=7 PB4:?7M77> 7=7> 8B>7>66:>6 7=C7 Q<=7 ; PB8B4<=?77> 5TBM _?=:? =74B>7 PB4:?7M77> 7=7> ;<=B>7=7> =B^7Q :>9:= 8B8N7C74 :-(;5+/-,' (&) ;<87=?:; ;<978N7M ;B>;7 N:>67 797? =B9B4T78N797> PB>CB9547> ?BN7?74 Dg ?BN:T7> ;74< P5=5= P7Q7=L @>9:= 8B>6797? ?BN7<=>C7 8BX2&"8 0* >?7=?< ?:P7C7 >7 Q<=7 PB4:?7M77> M7>C7 8B8N7C74 **M *7?7T DU 9B4?BN:9K 87=7 **M C7>6 ; S;7= ;7P79 ;=7> ?BN767< N<7C7L !"#$"%&' !"# %&"'(') )$*$ )*+, "*+" )%#)$+$,$)7.?:B:030 )708F.30830 )[email protected] G &478 947H ))B )1I JK • • 2B?74>C7 PB8N7C747> **M *7?7T DG 9B467>9:>6 ;74< NB?74>C7 **M 9B4:97>6 97M:> T7T:L *B>67Q:7> PB>6:47>67> PB8N7C747> +02*<=02 Y7>6?:47> 87?7Z **M *7?7T DG ; =B ,** C7>6 NB4?7>6=:97> ;B>67> 8BT78P<4=7>V 7L *45CB=?< PB4M<9:>67> T7N7[4:6< 97M:> C7>6 NB4?7>6=:97>h NL *45CB=?< >B47R7 P7;7 7=M<4 97M:> C7>6 NB4?7>6=:97>L *45CB=?< NB?74>C7 **M N7;7> C7>6 9B4:97>6K C7>6 9B4>C797 7=7> 9B4Q7;< =BTBN PB8N7C747> P7Q7=K 7P7NC7 T:8PX?:8 S;7= ;<=:47>6 >#"+&,?0( 8# 7+# @A /&, @B

Grey Area

Recommend Documents