TRIBUNAL REGIONAL FEDERAL DA 5. ª REGIÃO CONCURSO PÚBLICO PARA PROVIMENTO DE CARGOS DE JUIZ FEDERAL SUBSTITUTO DA 5.ª REGIÃO METODOLOGIA DA AVALIAÇÃO DA SEGUNDA PROVA SUBJETIVA (P3)
SENTENÇA PENAL PRELIMINARES I – Incom!"#nc$% &% J'("$)% F!&!*%+. Em "!n&o o ,%"o -&!("*'$)o &! /!0!"%)o &! *!(!*/%)o !*m%n!n"!1 oco**$&o 2( m%*0!n( &o R$o So F*%nc$(co 3'!4 o* %n6%* m%$( &! 'm E("%&o4 7 &! *o*$!&%&! &% Un$o -%*". 894 III4 CF14 &%: *!('+"% % com!"#nc$% &% J'("$)% F!&!*%+4 con,o*m! *!c!n"!( *on'nc$%m!n"o( &% ;ª S!)o &o S'!*$o* T*$'n%+ &! J'("$)% -CC 55.<;9 – SP<4 /.'.4 *!+. M$n. MARIA THEREZA DE ASSIS MOURA 4 DJU &! 8=>9;>899?@ CC .;;9 – RJ84 /.'.4 /.'.4 *!+. M$n. PAULO MEDINA4 DJU &! 95>98>899?1. A&!m%$(4 % con!o !n"*! o( &!+$"o( $m+$c% % *!&om$nnc$% &% J'("$)% F!&!*%+4 !m ,%c! &! (!* !(!c$%+ !*%n"! % J'("$)% &o( E("%&o( -%*". ?4 IV4 CPP1. A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. II – S'(!n(o &o *oc!((o. In!$("! % %on"%&% n'+$&%&!. O co>*7' Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/% H (o,*!' con&!n%)o o* o'"*o ,%"o c*$m$no(%4 !m como (! %c6% % *!(on&!* %)o !n%+. D!("% ,o*m%4 $nc$&! o $c! &o %*". 4 %*"! ,$n%+4 &% L!$ .95. A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. III – C!*c!%m!n"o &! &!,!(%. T%m7m T%m7m no oco**!' o c!*c!%m!n"o &! &!,!(%. K %c:,$co 3'! no 6H n!c!(($&%&! &% &!,!(% (!* $n"$m%&%4 !+o ':o &!*!c%&o4 &% &%"% &! %'&$#nc$% &! $n3'$*$)o &% /:"$m% o' &! "!("!m'n6%. F%>(! %("%n"! % $n"$m%)o &% !!&$)o &% c%*"% *!c%"*$% -Sm'+% n. 8?;;4 STJ1. A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. MKRITO IV – D!(%c%"o -%*". ;;<4 CP1. O &!+$"o no !("H con,$0'*%&o. O co>*7' Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/% (! !ncon"*%/%4 %o $n("%n"! &%( o,!n(%(4 !ncon"*%/%>(! !m !("%&o &! com+!"% ! m%n$,!("% !m*$%0'!. A '*$(*'&#nc$% &om$n%n"! 7 no (!n"$&o &! 3'! % !m*$%0'! % ,%("% o !+!m!n"o ('!"$/o &o "$o -TJSP4 -TJSP4 RT 55;=4 5;?;994 5;8;84 58=;5=599;
%c*7(c$mo %"*oc$n%&o !+% L!$ <<.84 &! 98 &! m%*)o &! 899=. O( ,%"o(4 o* ('% /!4 ,o*%m !*!"*%&o( !m <5 &! ,!/!*!$*o4 no o&!n&o 6%/!* *!"*o%)o in !"#. D$%n"! &$((o4 % con&'"% &! &!("*'$* /!0!"%)o &! *!(!*/%)o !*m%n!n"! *!c%$ no %*". ; &% L!$ .=954 o 3'%+ "*% *!*$m!n&% m!no( (!/!*%. A(($m4 o %0!n"! &!/!*$% (!* 'n$&o como $nc'*(o n%( !n%( &o %*". ; &% L!$ 9.=95. I("o o*3'!4 con,o*m! +$n6%( %%$o4 % 6$"!(! 7 &! conc'*(o %%*!n"! &! no*m%4 6%/!n&o ('% %(o*)o !+o %*". < &% L!$ .=95. A*0'm!n"o <=499 -&!!((!$( on"o(1. VI – A*". < &% L!$ .=955. Con($&!*%n&o>(! 3'! 6H conc'*(o %%*!n"! &! no*m%( !n%$(4 % (!* (o+'c$on%&o !+o c*$"7*$o &% con('n)o4 3'%n&o 'm c*$m! 7 m!$o n!c!((H*$o o' no*m%+ ,%(! &! *!%*%)o o' &! !!c')o &! o'"*o c*$m! -HELENO $L%UDIO FRAGOSO. Li&'" i*i+, -n! / ! n,0! -!*+ 1*!. ?ª !&. R$o &! J%n!$*o Fo*!n(!4 <54 . ;?=1. No c%(o conc*!"o4 o conc'*(o %%*!n"! &! no*m%( !n"*! o( %*"(. ; ! <4 %mo( &% L!$ .=954 o 3'%+ 7 *!(o+/$&o !+% %(o*)o &o *$m!$*o !+o +"$mo4 6%% /$("% 3'! (! "*%"% &! &!+$"o m%$( 0*%/o(o4 $n/oc%n&o> (!4 %*% !("! ,$m4 o$n$o &! EL%DIO LE$E2 -$*i" ,n+*!0n&'" -n!i"4 , i-!+, ! i ," *i" ,n+*! , i, !in+. V!* $"!n( ;.;.8. ! ;.;.8.=. D$(on:/!+ !m .m.*(.0o/.*c*$m$n%+&o'"*$n%. Ac!((o !m 89><<>899?1. In/o3'!>(! "%m7m !n"!n&$m!n"o '*$(*'&!nc$%+ &% *!/%+#nc$% &o &!+$"o m%$( 0*%/o(o -STF4 In3. 8.85 – MG4 *!+. M$n. JOA6UIM BARBOSA4 In,o*m%"$/o – STF nQ ??1. A(($m4 no 6%/!*H 'n$)o !+o %*". ;4 m%( "o>( !+o %*". < &% L!$ .=95. A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. VII – A*". =9 &% L!$ .=95=. No c%*%c"!*$%)o. O( *7'( no con(!0'$*%m n!m %o m!no( $n$c$%* % con("*')o &o /$/!$*o &! c%m%*o. S!n&o %(($m4 no *%"$c%*%m %)o 3'! co**!(on&% %o( nc+!o( con("*'$*4 *!,o*m%*4 %m+$%* o' ,%!* ,'nc$on%*4 $n(!*"o( no *"$co &o *!c!$"o %c$m% m!nc$on%&o. A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. VIII – In/%(o &! "!**%( +$c%( -%*". 894 !-#+4 &% L!$ .?==?1. O nc+!o &o "$o 7 o /!*o $n/%&$* 3'!4 !m /!*nHc'+o4 o("!n"% o( (!0'$n"!( ($0n$,$c%&o( <. En"*%* 6o("$+m!n"! !m4 oc'%* o* ,o*)%@ 8. oc'%* %*% o ,$m &! &!("*'$*@ ;. "om%* o* /$o+#nc$%4 con3'$("%* -,$0.1@ @ !n!"*%* !m4 +%/*%*4 %+%("*%* o' !("!n&!*>(! o*4 %+c%n)%*. -C%+&%( A'+!"!. D$c$onH*$o con"!mo*n!o &% +:n0'% o*"'0'!(%. ;ª !&. R$o &! J%n!$*o E&$"o*% D!+"%. Vo+. III4 . 899=1. <. En"*%* 2 ,o*)% o' 6o("$+m!n"! !m@ oc'%* 2 ,o*)%@ con3'$("%*@ 8. &$,'n&$*>(!@ %+%("*%*>(! o*@ !(%+6%*>(!@ ;. Dom$n%*4 "om%*@ . Ao&!*%*>(! /$o+!n"%m! n"! &!@ '('*%*. -D$c$onH*$o A'*7+$o E+!"*n$co1. <. P!n!"*%* n'm &!"!*m$n%&o +'0%* ! oc'H>+o !+% ,o*)%@ %o&!*%*>(!4 "om%*4 con3'$("%*@ oc'%* 'm +'0%* &! ,o*m% m%c$)% ! %'($/%@ 8. %+%("*%*>(! o*4 !("!n&!*>(! o*@ 0%n6%*4 &om$n%*@ ;. $n,!("%*4 co*$* -%+0o1@ . D!*$/%)o (!n"$&o ,$0'*%&o.Tom%* con"% &!@ %/%((%+%*4 '('*%*. -D$c$onH*$o !+!"*n$co o'%$(( &% +:n0'% o*"'0'!(% 8.9%1. Con,o*m! !n(o4 *!('+"% &%( ($0n$,$c%)!( %c$m%4 o /!*o $n/%&$*4 no( "!*mo( !m 3'! 7 '"$+$%&o !+o %*". 89 &% L!$ .?==4 &H $&7$% &! oc'%)o com /$o+#nc$%4 6o("$+4 o 3'! no oco**!*$% com o $n0*!((o ,'*"$/o no $m/!+ &o &om:n$o +$co n%c$on%+. D%: 3'! o c*$m! !m !%m! no "!*$% (! /!*$,$c%&o. No !n"%n"o4 ('m!"!>(! 2 &!+$!*%)o &% (!+!"% com$((o *oo("% &! !n"!n&$m!n"o %+"!*n%"$/o4
con(o%n"! % 3'%+4 !m (! %c6%n&o o((:/!+ c%*%c"!*$%)o &% %)o &! $n/%&$* n%( c$*c'n("nc$%( !n"o !n'nc$%&%(4 6%/!*$% &! (! *!con6!c!* *H"$c% &o &!+$"o &o %*". 89 &% L!$ .?== !m conc'*(o m%"!*$%+ com o %*". < &% L!$ .=95. A*0'm!n"o 499 -3'%"*o on"o(1. I – A+$c%)o ! &o($m!"*$% &%( !n%(. D$%n"! &% con($&!*%)o !"!n(o &% *oo("% &! (!n"!n)%4 &!co**!n"! &%( /H*$%( 3'!("!( 3'! ,o*%m ('m!"$&%( %o( c%n&$&%"o(4 !m %(($m 3'! o( c%n&$&%"o( H "$/!*%m &! !+%o*%* o'"*% (!n"!n)%4 &! on"'%)o ('!*$o*4 *!(o+/$ *oo* %'(#nc$% &! m%$o*!( !$0#nc$%( 3'% n"o 2 ,$%)o &%( !n%(. A(($m4 !n"!n&o %("%n"! 3'! o c%n&$&%"o *oc!&% &% m%n!$*% (!0'$n"! %. no %*"$c'+%* &% !n% *$/%"$/% &! +$!*&%&!4 7 &! (!* (!% %+$c%&% % !n%>%(! no m:n$mo +!0%+4 com !3'!n% !+!/%)o !m ,%c! &o *$m!$*o *7' -Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/%14 !m /$*"'&! &o( (!'( %n"!c!&!n"!( 4 *oc!&!n&o 2 ('("$"'$)o o* !n% *!("*$"$/% &! &$*!$"o@ % ('("$"'$)o no &!/!*H oco**!* 3'%n"o %o *$m!$*o *7' -Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/%14 con,o*m! /!&%)o &o %*". 4 II ! III4 &o CP4 'n"%m!n"! com % &o %*". ?Q4 II4 &% L!$ .=95@ "%m7m no c%!*H4 !m *!+%)o % Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/%4 % ('(!n(o &% !n%4 o* ,o*)% &! *o$$)o con("%n"! &o %*". ??4 I ! II4 &o C&$0o P!n%+@ . no %*"$c'+%* &% !n% &! m'+"%4 o(!*/%* o c%n&$&%"o % ,$%)o !m %"%m%* *%oH/!+ ,*!n"! 2 n%**%&% c%%c$&%&! !conm$c% &o( *7'(.
A*0'm!n"o 499 -o$"o on"o(1. No $n"'$"o &! %,!*$* ,%m$+$%*$&%&! &o c%n&$&%"o com o &$*!$"o !n%+ %m$!n"%+4 %"'%+m!n"! m'$"o *!(!n"! no( ,!$"o( com "*m$"! !*%n"! % J'("$)% F!&!*%+4 o(!*/%* % *!(!n)% &% $mo($)o 2 *!%*%)o &o &%no -%*".
E$( % !m!n"% &o '+0%&o CONFLITO DE COMPETNCIA. CRIME AMBIENTAL PRATICADO EM WREA DE PRESERVAXÃO PERMANENTE LOCALIZADA YS MARGENS DE RIO CUJO CURSO DWGUA BANA MAIS DE UM ESTADO DA FEDERAXÃO. INTERESSE DA UNIÃO CARACTERIZADO DE ACORDO COM A REDAXÃO DO ART. 894 III DA CONSTITUIXÃO FEDERAL. COMPETNCIA DA JUSTIXA FEDERAL. <. V!*$,$c%&o 3'! o c*$m! %m$!n"%+ ,o$ *%"$c%&o !m &!"*$m!n"o &! H*!% &! *!(!*/%)o !*m%n!n"!4 +oc%+$%&% 2( m%*0!n( &! *$o 3'! %n6% m%$( &! 'm E("%&o &% F!&!*%)o4 c%*%c"!*$%>(! o $n"!*!((! &% Un$o4 con,o*m! *!con$% &o %*". 894 III &% Con("$"'$)o F!&!*%+4 c%!n&o 2 J'("$)% F!&!*%+ % $n("*')o ! '+0%m!n"o &o ,!$"o. 8. Con,+$"o con6!c$&o %*% &!c+%*%* com!"!n"! % 8ª V%*% F!&!*%+ &% S'(!)o J'&$c$H*$% &! R$!$*o P*!"oSP. 8
E$( % !m!n"% &o '+0%&o CONFLITO NEGATIVO DE COMPETNCIA. CRIME AMBIENTAL. ETRAXÃO DE AREIA. USURPAXÃO. CRIMES CONEOS. INTERESSE DA UNIÃO. COMPETNCIA DA JUSTIXA FEDERAL. K ,!&!*%+ % com!"#nc$% %*% *oc!((%* ! '+0%* %)o !n%+ ,'n&%&% n% !"*%)o &! %*!$% &! +!$"o &! *$o4 !m con("$"'c$on%+m!n"! %,!"o 2 Un$o F!&!*%+4 (!m % +$c!n)% &! *0o %m$!n"%+. O c*$m! &! '('*%)o4 con!o %o &! !"*%)o &! %*!$% &! !m &% Un$o4 !n(!% % com!"#nc$% &% J'("$)% F!&!*%+. Con,+$"o con6!c$&o %*% &!c+%*%* com!"!n"! o ':o ('(c$"%&o4 o J':o F!&!*%+ &% 8ª V%*% C*$m$n%+ &% S!)o J'&$c$H*$% &o E("%&o &o R$o &! J%n!$*o. 3
E$( o "!o* &o !n'nc$%&o &! (m'+% In"$m%&% % &!,!(% &% !!&$)o &% c%*"% *!c%"*$%4 "o*n%>(! &!(n!c!((H*$% $n"$m%)o &% &%"% &% %'&$#nc$% no ':o &!*!c%&o.-DJ <.9.89981 9
A*". 59>A. D!(m%"%*4 !+o*%* !conom$c%m!n"! o' &!0*%&%* ,+o*!("%4 +%n"%&% o' n%"$/%4 !m "!**%( &! &om:n$o +$co o' &!/o+'"%(4 (!m %'"o*$%)o &o *0o com!"!n"! -Inc+':&o !+% L!$ nQ <<.84 &! 899=1 P!n% > *!c+'(o &! 8 -&o$(1 % -3'%"*o1 %no( ! m'+"%. -Inc+':&o !+% L!$ nQ <<.84 &! 899=1 [
*%"$c%&% 3'%n&o n!c!((H*$% 2 ('($("#nc$% $m!&$%"% !((o%+ &o %0!n"! o' &! ('% ,%m:+$%. -Inc+':&o !+% L!$ nQ <<.84 &! 899=1. [ 8Q. S! % H*!% !+o*%&% ,o* ('!*$o* % <.999 6% -m$+ 6!c"%*!(14 % !n% (!*H %'m!n"%&% &! < -'m1 %no o* m$+6%* &! 6!c"%*!. -Inc+':&o !+% L!$ nQ <<.84 &! 899=1. 5
A*". <. P*o/oc%* $nc#n&$o !m m%"% o' ,+o*!("% P!n% > *!c+'(o4 &! &o$( % 3'%"*o %no(4 ! m'+"%. P%*H0*%,o n$co. S! o c*$m! 7 c'+o(o4 % !n% 7 &! &!"!n)o &! (!$( m!(!( % 'm %no4 ! m'+"%. :
A*". =9. Con("*'$*4 *!,o*m%*4 %m+$%*4 $n("%+%* o' ,%!* ,'nc$on%*4 !m 3'%+3'!* %*"! &o "!**$"*$o n%c$on%+4 !("%!+!c$m!n"o(4 o*%( o' (!*/$)o( o"!nc$%+m!n"! o+'$&o*!(4 (!m +$c!n)% o' %'"o*$%)o &o( *0o( %m$!n"%$( com!"!n"!(4 o' con"*%*$%n&o %( no*m%( +!0%$( ! *!0'+%m!n"%*!( !*"$n!n"!( P!n% > &!"!n)o4 &! 'm % (!$( m!(!(4 o' m'+"%4 o' %m%( %( !n%( c'm'+%"$/%m!n"!. ;
A*". 89 > In/%&$*4 com $n"!n)o &! oc'H> +%(4 "!**%( &% Un$o4 &o( E("%&o( ! &o( M'n$c:$o(
<
\'%n"o %o co>*7' Joo M%'*:c$o &% S$+/%4 o"!$ !+o( %n"!c!&!n"!(4 %o $n/7( &% *!$nc$&#nc$%4 %*% % !+!/%)o &% !n%>%(!4 'm% /! 3'!4 c%(o *!/%+!)% %!n%( o &!+$"o %m$!n"%+4 % L!$ .=954 &! c'n6o !(!c:,$co4 ,% *!,!*#nc$% 2 *!$nc$&#nc$% !m c*$m!( &! n%"'*!% %m$!n"%+ -%*". <54 I1.
SENTENÇA $=VEL A (!n"!n)% &!/! con"!* ,'n&%m!n"%)o 3'! *!(o+/% %( 3'!("!( *oc!(('%$( *!,!*!n"!( 2 *!0'+%*$&%&! &% *!*!(!n"%)o *oc!(('%+4 2 +!0$"$m%)o %*% % c%'(%4 2 &!,!(% $n&$*!"% &! m7*$"o *!+%"$/% 2 *!(c*$)o4 *!!$"%n&o> %(4 ! conc+'$n&o4 3'%n"o %o m7*$"o4 !+% $m*oc!&#nc$% &o !&$&o4 !m *%o &% $n/$%$+$&%&! &% %+$c%)o !"!n($/% &o !n!,:c$o &% $(!n)o. A"*$'$>(! %"7 <9499 on"o( !+% *!!$)o &% %*0]$)o &! $**!0'+%*$&%&! &% *!*!(!n"%)o *oc!(('%+@ &! 499 % <9499 on"o( !+% *!!$)o &% *!+$m$n%* &! $+!0$"$m$&%&! %*% % c%'(%@ &! =499 % 89499 on"o( !+% *!!$)o &% %*0]$)o &! *!(c*$)o@ &! <9499 % =9499 on"o( !+% &!mon("*%)o &% *!/o0%)o &% $(!n)o ! &!(c%$m!n"o &% %+$c%)o &% *!0*% /$0!n"! 3'%n&o &% %3'$($)o &% %!*on%/!@ ! &! =499 % 89499 on"o( !+% ,o*m'+%)o co**!"% &o &$(o($"$/o4 $nc+'($/! com % con&!n%)o !m 6ono*H*$o( n% ,o*m% &o %*H0*%,o ^ &o %*". 894 CPC.
